Are the SD series reliable enough for a car gun??

Qmark

Member
Joined
Jul 7, 2004
Messages
220
Reaction score
166
Location
Phx Az USA
After being ripped off twice losing my car gun. I'm considering a SD. I want something reliable but I also don't want to be out big bucks if I cross paths with another thief. I saw 9MM SD shipped to my FFL for only $244 in a spam email today. My preference though would be 40 cal but being a cheapskate I could live with a 9MM. Previously my car carried S&W revolvers but I'll be dammed before I give another valuable gun to a low-life animal again.

So without me cruising this forum anymore. Do any of you have any good or bad experience with the SD line of pistols you might share?? I'm aware the SD's triggers are nothing to brag about but having plenty of shooting experience with D/A triggers I can deal with it. THX in advance for any advice you may want to share.
 
Register to hide this ad
I've no reason to think you can't find an SD that works.

As you point out, their triggers are pretty bad.

My philosophy about sd guns is different: I use my best guns for that purpose: customized Colt 1911's and Smith M 38's.

I don't want to lose one, but I want my best shooting guns in a sd situation.

Perhaps you should give some thought to improving security for your vehicle.
 
Of course it's reliable enough for a car gun. Far better question, IMO, is why need a car gun? Can you not legally carry?

Anything left in a car routinely is begging to be stolen. Depending on your state laws, a loaded handgun in your car puts friends or family members at legal risk of being in the car if they are not licensed to carry.

Just saying... with a handgun on me all the time, a car gun is a poor idea. (For me.)
 
The SD9VE I have is as reliable as any pistol I own,I got rid of a G19 when mine was broke in .I carry mine in the truck on coat wearing months,I NEVER leave it in the truck.
 
I have a SD9VE 9mm with over 1600 rounds through it without any failures with any ammo I've used. You're right, the trigger is not as good as any of my other guns, but it's always been an accurate gun. It also has a good price tag.
 
I think you'll be hard pressed to find a more reliable gun out there. These guns have been around for quite awhile, and are of a proven design. While the triggers are nothing to write home about in stock form, you can spend $20 and change on an Apex spring kit to make the triggers much more appealing.
 
My car gun for nearly ten years was a Sigma 40. When it became out of production, I put it away and started carrying a Hungarian Makarov as both car gun and carry weapon. The thing about car and carry guns is if your car is broken into, you don't want a high-dollar firearm there to be taken. Second, if you do use your firearm even in 100% justifiable circumstances, the gun is going to be confiscated for the duration of the investigation, which can be two years or more and if you have a gun-grabber probate judge, its unlikely they'll sign an order returning the firearm too you. Makarov's are great carry guns, they're effective and reliable in the ten-yard self-defense situation that most often occur. Beyond ten yards, you may or may not have an issue arguing self-defense, depending on how left-wing your county AG is. Makarovs cost around 250-bucks. Are hammer firing rather than striker firing. And use 9mm Mak which is equivalent to 9mm Parabellum in close-range personal defense. If the gun is stolen or taken after an SD event, you go to a gunshow and get another. Czech P-83's are also good choices for the same reason and are dirt cheap.
 
Nothing wrong with the SD. Seems to me it'd be a pretty good truck gun (I'm currently using a Glock 26 for that). What I'd consider more carefully is how you store it . . .

After being ripped off twice losing my car gun. I'm considering a SD. I want something reliable but I also don't want to be out big bucks if I cross paths with another thief. I saw 9MM SD shipped to my FFL for only $244 in a spam email today. My preference though would be 40 cal but being a cheapskate I could live with a 9MM. Previously my car carried S&W revolvers but I'll be dammed before I give another valuable gun to a low-life animal again.

So without me cruising this forum anymore. Do any of you have any good or bad experience with the SD line of pistols you might share?? I'm aware the SD's triggers are nothing to brag about but having plenty of shooting experience with D/A triggers I can deal with it. THX in advance for any advice you may want to share.
 
I saw 9MM SD shipped to my FFL for only $244 in a spam email today.

That's a good price, if it includes shipping...but you still might have to pay a transfer fee, which might be $15 or so, depending on your FFL dealer, plus tax.

I don't know if there is one near you, but Academy Sports routinely stocks the SDVE series (9 and 40) and right now they have them for $289 (no transfer fee, but state tax) in the stores here. If you really want a 40, it might be worth the few extra dollars to get the one you want.

Are the SDVE pistols reliable? I've owned a few of them, and yes they are reliable. If yours isn't, S&W will fix it. The trigger is indeed heavier than most striker fired semi-autos, but not as heavy as most DA revolver pulls (in DA mode.) I wouldn't hesitate to buy another one, if I needed a great gun on a budget.

I'd also echo what others have said here...you might want to look into a better secure storage method for your car. While nothing will stop a determined thief who has the time and the tools, most smash and grab thieves have neither. You can get a good handgun safe for a lot less than a new pistol. Be aware that the tether that comes on some models can be easily cut with bolt cutters. Side cutters will cut them too, but it takes longer. I secure my handgun safe with a heavy chain and very good padlock...I had a hole drilled in the safe as near to the edge as I could get it, so that I could pass the shackle of the lock through the hole, and then attach the chain to the safe using the padlock...and the other end of the chain I lock to the seat frame post with another heavy duty padlock. This also helps prevent the safe being pried open, which can be done on most of the lesser expensive models. (I have to leave my gun in my car when we go somewhere where a gun cannot be legally carried, like to the doctor or hospital...which is becoming more frequent these days.)

There are inexpensive options for the SDVE series that I would recommend: a metal rear sight that fits the M&P 1.0 series pistols to replace the plastic rear sight (you will also need a set screw, which for some strange reason isn't included with the sight); an extended take down lever to make taking the pistol down easier; and a grip sleeve, although the newer models may have a better texture. I don't see the need for a stainless steel recoil spring or a trigger kit, but they are available if you want them. Of course, if you spend this much, you are fairly close to the price of a new M&P 2.0, which is a better pistol and won't need the upgrades I just mentioned.

Anyway, good luck with your next gun, whichever one you choose. :)
 
People who have a propensity for leaving their gun(s) unattended in a car, allowing them to be stolen, shouldn't even be thinking about getting another "car gun".
nono.gif
 
After being ripped off twice losing my car gun. I'm considering a SD. I want something reliable but I also don't want to be out big bucks if I cross paths with another thief. I saw 9MM SD shipped to my FFL for only $244 in a spam email today. My preference though would be 40 cal but being a cheapskate I could live with a 9MM. Previously my car carried S&W revolvers but I'll be dammed before I give another valuable gun to a low-life animal again.

So where can I get a "THIS CAR PROTECTED BY SMITH & WESSON" bumper stick like yours. ;);):)
 
People who have a propensity for leaving their gun(s) unattended in a car, allowing them to be stolen, shouldn't even be thinking about getting another "car gun".
nono.gif

Hard to argue with this logic. I seldom leave one of mine in the car but when I do it is in a gun vault cabled to the seat, and never overnight.
 
To refer to internet expertise, this was the Jeep gun for this gentleman, he put a steel rear sight on it and then passed it to a needy relative. I note the SD series has the equivalent of the "New York City Police Department Glock 19 trigger" which is a good combat trigger, NOT a target trigger.
Geoff
Who owns an SW with an even heavier trigger.
[ame]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=REDBk1413ks[/ame]
 
People who have a propensity for leaving their gun(s) unattended in a car, allowing them to be stolen, shouldn't even be thinking about getting another "car gun".
nono.gif

I often have to travel impromptu so I don't have a lot of planning involved on my daily routine. Most of the time, I don't carry as I doubt I'll be in an SD situation at the grocery store in the middle of the day, at the hardware store, so on. However, I sometimes have to travel to south Atlanta and having it there where it can go into my pocket or come out quickly when my vehicle is approached is a profound peace of mind. Any of you that have been there will know precisely what I mean. I like to be left alone by strangers and people I share nothing in common with. My Mak lends to that.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top