I thought that maybe this is where I should post this - I recently retired and wanted to take up marksmanship - so I bought a S&W 22 A-1 SS - its really nice - however I haven't found the time to devote - until now - I'm committed to perfecting my skills - The 22 A1 is really nice and should be a great training pistol for me - I've started looking at a second gun and I keep coming back to the S&W 41 - but at 1400.00 it seems a lot of money up front - What makes the model 41 so much better that's its worth so much more? And should I continue to focus on using iron sights or go to an optical sight?
Any thoughts?
Thr short answer to the first part of your question is twofold.....
The 41 is affected by economies of scale. Meaning that the unit cost for S&W to make one is higher (and thus the price) because volume is low. The volume is low because the gun isn't in high demand relatively speaking. The bullseye leagues are made up of ageing people who already own the guns they will use, and few new people enter this discipline despite the shooting sports becoming much more popular lately. The secon reason is that the 41 is built "like they used to make 'em". It's a high quality handgun made out of carbon steel with close tolerances and high levels of finish. This means labor, materials, and skilled employees that can productively make the gun correctly. It is very accurate and reliable and to anyone who owns one and uses it, well worth it. Even with the shrinking bullseye market, competition from cheaper guns, and increasing cost, smith sells every 41 they make, and the dealers get top dollar for them often before they ever hit the display case.
As far as your second question. That entirely depends on your eyes. I'd stick with irons for now until you find yourself becoming limited by your body, or you try the guns of other shooters usig red dots.
$1400 sounds a bit high. You may be looking at the performance center model. They should trade about $1200-$1300, but it might be more regionally. Used should be an option for you also. Again, top dollar will be needed, but you can get A LOT of used 41 for $800. (And many will argue that the older guns are better anyways)
I hope this helps. The 22a is a good blaster, but the 41 is at a totally different level. It won't make you shoot like a champ, but it will certainly help you shoot closer to your true ability, and wil not hold you back.