Best LE Revolvers Article

Register to hide this ad
The Best Law Enforcement Revolver of all time is objectively speaking the Smith & Wesson Performance Center 327 TRR8.

Lightweight Scandium Alloy Frame, drilled and tapped for picatinny rails, 8-shot .357 Magnum Cylinder cut for Moon Clips. It covers all bases and provides virtually everything an Officer could ever need.
 
Last edited:
What, Reg Mags not listed?!?!? KCPD used theirs from 1939 to 1957…….
93e85c7732438f354ee9a58ffa8b2f61.jpg
 
I think I’d drop the Triple Lock and the Python and add the great Colt Official Police and the Colt New Service.

Agree about the Colt Official Police. Seems the article cover both the the 19th and 20th Century.

Pictured is my 1956 Colt Official Police and 1979 S&W Model 10-7 (nickel). I would say that for sixty years between 1920 and 1980 more LEO's carried one of these than the others.

In 1933 the Colt OP was standard issue for Police Departments in New York, Chicago, San Francisco, Kansas City, St. Louis and Los Angeles as well as State Police of NJ, Pa. Maryland, Delaware and Connecticut as well as the FBI. (from American Gun by Chris Kyle, page 225)

I carried a Model 10 and later Model 64 2".
 

Attachments

  • IMG_1441.jpg
    IMG_1441.jpg
    78 KB · Views: 49
Last edited:
The Triple Lock’s inclusion among “best” LE revolvers is a bit strange, as according to the author’s explanation it is not due to the gun’s actual LE service record, but as an ancestor to other guns.
 
Listing the Model 10 covers a lot of models, including the Model 15 which I carried as a civilian police officer, as an Air Force Security Specialist, and as a combat aircrew in B-52s and KC-135s. Since the Model 10 was the basis for the Model 19/66, there really wasn't any reason to list it separately. The same can be said about the Triple Lock, as the foundation for the Model 27, 28, and 29.
I think the article really missed the mark by not listing the Model 36.
 
I'd bundle the 19 and 66 as one item. Maybe combine the 10,64 , 15 and 67 into another. While I love the python, I don't recall seeing it in a lot of holsters at least in the Northeast. I also think the 686 aand Gp100 should be on the list, possibly displacing the triple lock.

Edited to add the 64.
 
Last edited:
I can't agree with the Triple lock. Yeah, it fathered a lot of great guns, but it wasn't a common cop's holster gun.
Absolutely agree with the Dick Special. Very popular with plain clothes and IMHO the best snubby ever made.
I agree that pretty much all of the K-frames could be lumped together.
I'll give the Python a nod. Some cops loved them, but not a common as other models.
Personally, I think the L-frames were the best of the breed. S&W took into consideration all the best and worst of prior models and build the ideal .357. But they came along at a time when semi-autos were becoming the big thing. That's the only reason I can come up with for their omission. :rolleyes:
 
Without slighting Ruger revolvers in any way... Colt and and Smith & Wesson had almost all the law enforcement business decades before Ruger marketed a double-action revolver. With law enforcement's transitioning to semi-automatic pistols thirty-to thirty-five years ago, it would seem Ruger's market share of LE revolver sales would have been very small to insignificant.
 
Without slighting Ruger revolvers in any way... Colt and and Smith & Wesson had almost all the law enforcement business decades before Ruger marketed a double-action revolver. With law enforcement's transitioning to semi-automatic pistols thirty-to thirty-five years ago, it would seem Ruger's market share of LE revolver sales would have been very small to insignificant.

Agreed. Except the author was dead on about the importance of the Ruger Security Six, Service Six and to a lesser extent the Speed Six as an economical option for officers buying their own service weapons. Shooting a steady diet of .357 Mag without the problems associated with the K frames was just a bonus.

I bought one in the early 1980s as I wanted a reliable weapon on the approved list that cost a lot less than a S&W Model 19 or Colt Python.

The Colt Trooper and Lawmen were other economical options but had sintered iron lock work parts that were inferior to the oversized but tough as nails cast parts in the Rugers - and they were discontinued in 1983.

——

Revolvers also have to be viewed in the context of the times. Despite the lessons that should have been learned in the Newhall shooting and elsewhere some departments were still very antiquated, often because of politically appointed police chiefs who were anti-gun.

In the late 1970 and early 1980s a friend of mine worked for a department that issued each officer 12 rounds of .38 Special ammo - six for the revolver and 6 more for a dump pouch. No speed loader or even speed strip allowed. Even asking for a seventh round for the dump pouch (in recognition that few officers would be able to load six rounds without dropping one under stress) wasn’t met with much positive regard. He also worked for the police department in the second largest city in the state.

Many officers in his department carried a Model 36 or Colt Detective special in an ankle holster as a backup, figuring being fired for violating policy after a shoot would be far better than being dead.

In comparison I was extremely privileged in my department as we were able to carry .357 Magnum, and not one but two speed loaders.
 
…. it would seem Ruger's market share of LE revolver sales would have been very small to insignificant.

Ruger‘s impact on the market should not be underestimated.

Of course the country was growing. In the 16 years of production of the Security Six series, 1972 to 1988, Ruger sold more revolvers (close to 1.5 mill) than Colt sold of its premier police gun, the Army Special/Official Police, in 61 years, 1908 to 1969 (just above 600,000). And from 1955 to 1969 they made about 100,000 Pythons.

Both brands pale compared to the several million M&P‘s/Model 10’s that S&W produced.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top