Me too, but...
I loved reading the OP's post!
I have a very similar story, except for a few details. Here it is...
The weekend before Christmas is the wife's birthday.
I went to town to shop for a present.
I needed to stop at the farm supply store for some de-icer.
I had no idea there was a firearms department there!
Whelp, I wandered in there to have a look (since I was there anyway, right?).
Right on the counter was a mat advertising the Hellcat Pro, in a Tac Pack.
Laser, 5 mags, and a range bag included.
I am not a fan of ultra-compacts. If I can't get my pinky around the grip, then it's a no-go.
As others have stated, you have to be able to control it or you're not going to use it.
I'm also usually a .45 ACP guy, but only because that's what I know well.
I've carried a S&W E-1911 for over 10 years. And yes, I shoot others calibers, but I don't carry them.
I believe everyone that carries, should carry what they can use well. I'm no snob.
Anyway... (I'm getting there!)
The counterman said, "Here. Why not just check it out."
Ohhh... That rat already knew!
Whoops!
The Pro has a full-length and slim (1') grip, with no pinky wag. Perfect fit for my hands!
It's optics ready, and I've been slowly switching over to red dots for close range stuff in my rifles and pistols.
My eyes aren't as good as they used to be and red dots work really well for me.
I wasn't looking for a laser, but they have their benefits. And hey! it's in the Tac-Pack, so why not?
And 5 magazines?! What's not to like?
So I bought it, right then and there!
Okay, now the rest of the story (I said I was getting there!)...
I'm driving home and realized, "Uh oh! I never got my bride her birthday present!!"
So I get this brilliant idea. I tell myself, "I'll just say that I saw it, held it, and it seemed like a great pistol for you sweetie. If you don't like it, then we'll just go get the one you want. And I'll keep this one. I kinda' like it, anyway."
Now, she's been a full-size Glock 9mm girl her whole life (we're not young). And yes, she carries it.
She also likes shooting with me and she'll pull the trigger on anything (pretty well, I might add!).
So this was a really weak idea, but I came home empty-handed so I had to go with it!
So she opens her present, Surprise!
I give her the line I came up with on the way home, while she's opening the box.
She didn't even blink an eye at by BS line.
I'm sure I've got this in the bag!
Um, oops!
She says, "Put the laser on it, dear." Not one sign of approval or disapproval on her face.
So I mounted the laser (took about 4-5 minutes) and handed it back to her.
She drops the mag, checks the chamber, re-inserts the empty mag, then grips it (she has good technique), pokes the laser button with her off-hand trigger finger, snaps to low-ready, then up and looks down the slide and notices the great iron sights that line up with the green dot on the wall (perfectly, I might add)...
This isn't going well for me, at all!
She stands up and repeats the low-ready followed by putting the green laser dot on various "targets" in the room.
"Ooh! That laser is Neat! Ya' know... This actually fits my hands really well..."
A smile comes to her face and she said, "Gee hon', this is really great! Thank you!"
And at that moment, I lost the Hellcat. sigh...
But there's a happy (short) ending!
Christmas Eve I went back the the farm supply store.
And yep! I purchased one for myself!
So, now we have his & hers Hellcats. She stayed with the laser and I added a red dot to mine ( I have a spare pistol laser now).
Range day was wonderful! Both of them were reliable and accurate.
Merry Christmas to us!! (or happy birthday, since mine is right at Christmas too)