Well, I'll put my .02. I am a traditionalist. I love my old revolvers, and John Browning autos. I shoot them fairly well, for an old guy. I am a Smith and Wesson collector, my S&W revolvers are not tools! They are prized possessions, even heirlooms. My EDC requirements are much like my car requirements. Absolute reliability, user friendly, not too big, not too small. Not a status symbol, and doesn't attract attention from bad or good people. I drive a RAV4, I carry a Glock 48 with TFO sights. I can shoot it as well as any other pistol. I carry one extra mag. It looks like a ****, but it's a fine tool.