Try trimming 15 brass to 1.74 and see how they measurer after shooting them. For reference sake, mark and keep one unused, reload and repeat. You will then know how your rifle and loading die combo treat your brass.
The sizing of the neck and pulling a button through it, to bring it back up to size, shortens the life of the brass and cause to stretch excessively. The other type of sizing uses changeable collets (size based on neck wall thickness) to take the neck diameter to a very specific diameter (+/-.001" diameter, and .0005 for one brand). You can get these dies in Full Length Size or Neck Size. With this method I have one bolt action 223 that I trim the brass every 10 loadings, weather they need it or not! My AR I trim every 3 loadings (I could go 4 or 5, but try to keep everything the same!)
Like a previous poster said, Consistency is the important part!
When trimming, some trimmers have a little difficulty getting the shell base consistently tight into the shell holder, This can end up making a hole batch very by up to 3/100" in length (I had this happen several times with an old RCBS system). Lee's & L.E.Wilson's are the best for consistency in length. They are respectively, the least and most expensive!
Ivan