I don't like the idea of the tape on system either, even though I tested that tape pretty rigerous. Great stuff, but I carry a J frame snub anyway, and it doesn't fall off. I weigh in at 155, 5'9" my model 38 fits right in a dent behind my hip bone, 4:00, and just about disappears. The hump on the bodyguard also helps keep movement down to nothing. Very handy when I can't carry OWB.