I appreciate all the help. I've been working it with various solvents and such, and it's loosening up. I'm familiar with the extractor rod issue, a buddy showed me that years ago. Not long afterwards I was set up at a gun show when a guy came by with his son, who was about 12. Guy was carrying a S+W with the cylinder swung out. Ok, not so unusual. I asked to have a look at it, closed the cylinder, looked it over, tried to open it. Very difficult. When I got it out I turned the extractor rod in, it moved about a full turn or so. I handed it back to him. As they walked away I heard the kid say "He fixed it!" I'm pretty sure the guy was trying to peddle the gun without telling of the issue. Oh well.