Do I get the 29 or the 629?

An actual original 29? Where would I come across one of those? The only ones I've seen are the "new" versions for sale online

There is a huge aftermarket for older S&Ws. Members of this forum routinely offer older guns for sale in the classified subforum. Look on the consignment shelves of gun stores. You can also find guns on Gunbroker, GunsAmerica, or any of the auction sites. It may be that you will receive some private messages from forum members who own some older .44s and wouldn't mind tuning their collection. Don't feel that you need to go with modern production to get the model you want. It's a constant argument, but some believe that the fit and finish of guns made in the 1950s will always be better than anything manufactured afterward. Balance that with engineering improvements in later decades, and you get the consensus opinion that the 29-2 is the best combination of quality and features you can get.

Now having said all that, I will confess that when I decided it was time to pick up a .44 Magnum a few years ago, I bought a brand new 629-6 with the internal lock and a six inch barrel. I have not been disappointed in it. The only change I made was to put some smooth ebony target stocks on it to beef up its rather bland image. If I ever want another one, I will probably go for a mid-'50s gun from early in the model's production run.

I'll show the 629 just to let you see that a stainless gun can display its own kind of cool. :)

KuracR.jpg


This is actually a round butt gun, but it is wearing square butt conversion stocks to give it a more traditional profile.
 
I wanted a 44 and while looking around in my local gunstores, I came across a 629-1. It wasn't exactly what I wanted but it satisfied my hunger for a while.

Then one day I saw a perfect 29-2 6 1/2 inch beauty in a wooden case. I didn't have any money.....:(

dh%20688x640.jpg


Oh, what could I do? I just had to have it. Here's what I did..I sold the 629 for nearly what the guy wanted for the 29 !

The 29 is a masterpiece of a work of art.

A year or so later I stumbled on another 29-2 that a local friend had:

29Nright%20600x370.jpg


Again no money. :(

The story of my life.

No I didn't sell the other 29, but I did sell off 2 Rugers and the nickel beauty was mine.

These were both within 5 miles of me. So don't give up. They are out there and you'll find one probably when you don't have the money.

I've had all three different finished (Stainless Steel, blue and nickel) and if you take care of them, they'll all look good for a long time.

Look for an older one. Find the $ if you can.

Good luck
 
One like that 73 you have would be perfect. I may indeed take a look into a 70s 29-2. As you guys said I gotta stay true to the namesake.;) Just out of curiosity may I ask what the difference is between the vintage ones like yours and a new "classic" 29?
 
It's nice to have one of each like others here.;)

I'll be honest when I get into a hobby I usually get caught up in it for awhile so yea I admit at some point I may indeed get both a 29 and a 629, but for starters I'll go with the original.
 
This is "Big Blue" a 29 Classic, circa 1994. My first .44HE, and my all time favorite. I have a 629-2 Mountain Revolver, too. I like the contoured barrel of the Mountain, but prefer the rich blue of the 29.

Go Blue!
 

Attachments

  • SW29CKrein05Walkabout.JPG
    SW29CKrein05Walkabout.JPG
    124.7 KB · Views: 32
Last edited:
If you are looking for a modern production gun that is "as close to the original as you can get," that's probably it. I didn't compare production codes, but I imagine that is the new S&W "Classic" Model 29, which means it comes with the internal lock.

My own view is that fully original is as close to original as you can come, and I'd still be on the lookout for a Model 29 through 29-2. Those guns won't have the internal lock, and will have recessed cylinders that surround the cartridge case rims. You may not pay much less for what would some would consider a "used" gun, but collectors will be far more likely to buy it from you in the future if you ever wanted to sell.
 
S&W added a locking feature to their handguns in 2002. For the 44 Magnum it first appeared as the Model 29-8. These guns have a hole on the left side of the frame above the cylinder release latch that a key fits into and can lock the action and make the revolver non-functional. The internal lock has been a source of controversy and has been the subject of many discussions (not to be rehashed here).

The revolvers used by Clint Eastwood in the movie "Dirty Harry" were Model 29-2s that were built in 1970 or early 1971. The revolvers used in the movie "Magnum Force" were Model 29s (4-screw) that probably date to around 1960 or 1961. I actually held and examined one of these in the spring at the gun show in Tulsa. It is owned by the NRA Firearms Museum.

I don't know for sure, but I assume the 44 Magnums used in subequent movies were Model 29-2s.

If you want a 44 Magnum that is like the ones used "Dirty Harry", you should look for a Model 29-2 with a 6 1/2-inch barrel and bright blue finish in the serial number range N18000 (1971-72) to N400000 (1976-77). The 44 Magnum pictured in the link you provided is a 29-10 that first appeared in 2006 as the 50th Anniversary Model 29 and later that year as the plain version in blue or nickel.

Bill
 
Last edited:
My take on it is if I plan on doing any hunting with it, I prefer stainless,if not I like the looks of the blued 29's.
 
Back
Top