Originally posted by 84CJ:
A courios question. If you improve the fuel milage on a vehicle above what it gets brand new and running at its best.
My vehicles generally don't get their best fuel economy when they're brand new. Most of mine show improvements as I drive them, usually getting better mileage by 10,000 to 15,000 miles. A few have actually improved after that. My 2003 Jeep is getting its best mileage now at about 43,000.
Maybe I've altered its breakin period by running synthetic from the first oil change. Doesn't matter, we track every gallon and the miles indicated on the odometer. It closely parallels the GPS indicated miles, too.
As for running different grades of fuel, I've experimented. You can't tell squat from one or two tank loads, but when you've run about 10 of them, you get a good indication. Remember, different pumps shut off at different pressures. You need to top them off a little to be sure you're full. When you've done that a few time, you can be pretty sure you're getting good numbers. Also, driving conditions can make a huge difference. Its why you run multiple fill-ups to even out those differences.
If premium costs less than 10% more, and you get more than 10% better fuel economy, its a bargain. Tire pressure can make that much difference alone, so do your comparisons with the same pressures, cold. Only change one variable at a time.