Well, it took me five years —more accurately, I took a five-year break while the project was in process— but I have completed my Gerstner machinist's chest spiff up:
It was pretty grimy when I got it — or, had a "very nice patina" for you purists:
In the above pic I've polished the drawer pulls on the left and center, and removed other hardware.
A major issue (for me) was that the veneer on the front panel had warped in two places:
I fixed that by slitting the veneer with the grain, injecting glue beneath the veneer, placing a damp dishcloth on top, ironing the veneer, and then placing weight on the panel while waiting for it to dry.
I made some other minor wood fixes here and there as well. (Initially I was disappointed that the front panel and lid were veneer, but I later learned that the use of plywood beneath veneer was a sturdier solution to prevent the warping and cracks that can happen to larger pieces of solid wood over time.)
I did not replace the felt lining as someone else had earlier and it was in pretty good shape. (Other than where I have torn holes in it removing and reinstalling hardware. Some of these are covered by the patches displayed in the lid top above.) I may get around to new felt lining some day.
I'm pretty happy with how it turned out.
The chest, a model 52 Journeyman, above dates from between 1946 and 1955, per Gerstner. I thought at one point that I had narrowed its DOB to 1952, but learned that there are errors in Gerstner dating info found on the internet.
Gerstner is a family owned business, established in 1906, and operating out of the same building in Dayton, Ohio, since 1908. They continue to use many of the same tools they've always used. They sell replacement hardware and felt for restorations. In addition, they have a less expensive, Gerstner International, line, made overseas. (Currently in China, is my understanding.)
A similar to mine, US made model nowadays costs over $2000, as would a full, factory restoration by Gerstner. (They will also fix and replace parts of their chests.) In 1906, Gerstner's original tool chest cost $6. But...
In 1906, per Gerstner, $6 was a week's wages, and a working week was 60 hours. So, they like to say, their pricing remains consistent as their current chests cost about a 40 hour week's wages, plus 20 hours of overtime.
I like the Gerstner chests, and I like the company. They take great pride in their product, their company's history, and in their Gerstner chest fan base.