Grail Gun secured

Joined
Aug 31, 2021
Messages
891
Reaction score
1,645
Location
Ohio
My first S&W was a 686-1 4" square butt. Well I just landed the grail, a 686-3 snub with the most beautiful combat grips I've ever seen. I had to break a personal rule of 1k or under but in the long run I think this was worth it.

attachment.php


attachment.php
 
Last edited:
Register to hide this ad
That's a very nice score! I have a similar "rule" that I don't buy anything that's not a really good dea. But when something comes up that I can't resist and is at market price or a little over I pretend the extra cost is balanced out across the rest of the good deals and I'm still pretty deep into the black.
 
Nice score on a very desirable revolver. Is that a 2-1/2" bbl. or 3" bbl. on your 686-3? If it's a 3", does yours happen to be stamped "CS-1" in the yoke? There was a production run of these for the U.S. Customs Service in 1988, both 3" and 4" barrels. Can you share the Production Code and Special Features on the box label? That could add to the value of your acquisition. Enjoy!
 
Nice score on a very desirable revolver. Is that a 2-1/2" bbl. or 3" bbl. on your 686-3? If it's a 3", does yours happen to be stamped "CS-1" in the yoke? There was a production run of these for the U.S. Customs Service in 1988, both 3" and 4" barrels. Can you share the Production Code and Special Features on the box label? That could add to the value of your acquisition. Enjoy!

2.5" I wanted the shortest possible for weight and concealment purposes. The wooden combats were also desired for carry reasons. Some hate finger grooves, but I like them. The rubber grips with grooves fit my hand perfect but stick to my clothes. The smooth wooden ones shouldn't have those issues is the hope.
 
I paid $1150 for a 686-3 snub. The guy gave me some ammo too. I wouldn't stress over paying too much . In the years that I got mine, I haven't seen another one like it.
If I didn't buy mine- I wouldn't have one.
I think you did good.

Mine was 1230$ with box and original tools so I am fine with it. As someone mentioned Grail guns are not subject to price restrictions and I got mine.
 
That is one sharp revolver. I want one. A forum member sold me a 586 snubby but I still need the 686!

Always looking although there are very few on the buy list nowadays.
 
That is one sharp revolver. I want one. A forum member sold me a 586 snubby but I still need the 686!

Always looking although there are very few on the buy list nowadays.

It was the only one I saw, and it was everything I wanted in one revolver. Birth year gun, snub, -3, and S&W 'combat grips with original packaging/tools/manual. Just couldn't pass on that even if it was more than I wanted to spend.

Any advice on defense ammo? I'm torn between 38+p or 357
 
Last edited:
It was the only one I saw, and it was everything I wanted in one revolver. Birth year gun, snub, -3, and S&W 'combat grips with original packaging/tools/manual. Just couldn't pass on that even if it was more than I wanted to spend.

Any advice on defense ammo? I'm torn between 38+p or 357

That L-Frame will easily handle .357 Magnum loads...
 
That's a very nice score! I have a similar "rule" that I don't buy anything that's not a really good dea. But when something comes up that I can't resist and is at market price or a little over I pretend the extra cost is balanced out across the rest of the good deals and I'm still pretty deep into the black.

....and, besides that, it will be more than worth what you paid for it in a short period of time.
 
Congrats on acquiring a grail gun! It's always satisfying, and pointless to put a price on.

A 2.5" 686 was my carry gun in 1987-88, though I sold it to fund a 3" 629 back in the day. I always regretted that and finally replaced it with a 686-1 2.5" I picked up earlier this year.

53516525117_d61b9633db_c.jpg


As far as ammo for defensive purposes, I like the Buffalo Bore .357 short barrel/low flash/recoil 140gr Barnes bullet loads. Serious, but not as unpleasant out of short barrel guns as the iconic Federal and Remington 125gr JHPs. No exposed lead to deform over time with repeated loading/unloading.
 
Congrats on acquiring a grail gun! It's always satisfying, and pointless to put a price on.

A 2.5" 686 was my carry gun in 1987-88, though I sold it to fund a 3" 629 back in the day. I always regretted that and finally replaced it with a 686-1 2.5" I picked up earlier this year.

53516525117_d61b9633db_c.jpg


As far as ammo for defensive purposes, I like the Buffalo Bore .357 short barrel/low flash/recoil 140gr Barnes bullet loads. Serious, but not as unpleasant out of short barrel guns as the iconic Federal and Remington 125gr JHPs. No exposed lead to deform over time with repeated loading/unloading.

I think that the 686 will always have a special place in my heart as my first S&W. This one is slightly shorter than my 4" but the learning curve should not be too harsh as I have shot thousands of rounds through my 686.

I am leaning towards silvertips since they worked so well in my 4"
 
Back
Top