The new NYS law requires ALL private sales to go thru an FFL so that a NICS check is done.
We have had this for private sales at gunshows since 2000, though until very recently, it was largely ignored.
Then KingKomo's A/G (Schneiderman) set up some sting ops and arrested many doing private sales w/o NICS checks.
So the last year or so, it's been pretty much by the book with everyone looking over their shoulder wondering who the other guy really is. Kind of Police State like which is how they want it.
Now the new law (yesterday), ammends the old by demanding that ANY private sale of a firearm must be handled thru an FFL so that a NICS check be done.
There is one small loophole for transfers within 'immediate' family as I understand it. 'Immediate family' was not defined in that rough version of the bill as I recall.
That was in the bill as it was being pushed through,,but I don't know if it's in the final signed into law version.
There was for a time in NYS when your NYS P/P was proof of a background check and you could by-pass the NICS check when buying a firearm from an FFL.
The FBI decided that NYS & the County's that issued the permits didn't do a good enough job handling the background checks of P/P holders, updating info, ect,,and after a couple of years of that,,it went away.
The only thing that that extra background check did for you after that was being able to transfer a pistol from one individual to another (permit to permit) w/o getting a dealer involved to do the NICS check.
That's gone now too with the new law.
FBI will never extend the NICS system to private sellers. To do so would be to expand the number of FFL's in so many words. That's something Clinton diminished by Executive order in 2001(?) and something they would never allow to go back.
If anything the restrictions will be more cumbersome, European like. The same direction they are taking everything else.
They know what's best for you, they will take care of you and keep you safe. Trust us.
Don't forget it can happen anywhere,,see how quickly they can make laws when they really want to..literally over night..