How Many Have DUMPED their J-Frame for a NEW MINI Semi-Auto?

[Kho]

I went retro, switching from a G26 to an SP101.

 

[semperfi71]

I have J-Frames and a Diamondback DB380. They both have their uses.

 

[clkeith]

I started carrying a Bodyguard 380. Then bought a 642 Airweight J Frame. I love them both and wouldn't get rid of either one.

 

[Lobster Picnic]

I carry my 7-shot J when I want extra capacity. Normal carry is a 5-shot Black Widow in .22 Mag.

 

[RIDE-RED 350r]

Not I...And it aint going to happen any time soon either!

 

[jimmyj]

I went from a "J" Frame 2" to a "K" Frame 2" and NEVER regretted the jump.
I like to have the weapon grip fully in my hand from beginning draw to firing.
The only way I could do this with a "J" Frame was with Pachymar Grippers there for I decided that the large grips defeated the purpose of the small frame, hense a "K" Frame and an extra round.

 

[PatAz]

I got my 642 after a mini auto. I certainly have no plans on dumping either one.

 

[Arik]

The one thing I can't do is 380s. I'll take 38 snubbies and sub compact 9 but 380 is just not enough of anything

Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk

 

[gm272gs]

There is so much Heresy in this thread, I cannot read all the replies.

Model 36 (with the skinny wood grips that came with it) is where it's at, guys.

 

[CatboatWilly]

Carried a J frame model 36 for 30 years - and in my old age - I must admit, it is getting heavy. But why mess with success ? I pull the trigger and it goes bang ! Never a question.

I read the discussions here on the forum about all the problems with various auto loaders and return to my old friend, that dependable J frame. Why mess with success ?

 

[ISCS Yoda]

There is so much Heresy in this thread, I cannot read all the replies.

Model 36 (with the skinny wood grips that came with it) is where it's at, guys.

TYLER T-GRIP!!!!!!

***GRJ***

 

[shawn mccarver]

I would not "dump" a J frame revolver. That said, it might be that it has become sort of second team with the influx of the pocket size 9mm pistols, such as the S&W Shield and M&P Compact, the SIG 290RS, the Beretta Nano, the Glock 26/19, etc. The G19 takes up the same real estate as the J frame, and its magazine holds three times as many rounds of ammo that is a little better than the best personal defense 38 Special +P ammo. So, the mini-9 with appropriate ammo is here to stay. That said, "dump a J frame?" No way!

 

[radar1972]

I purchased a Sig P290 and a Bodyguard 380, both with the intent of EDC. Tried 'em, didn't really like 'em. I just didn't feel they were as reliable as carrying my J-frame. Those semi-autos are now "emergency" guns stashed strategically in various rooms at home.

The J-frame is back on my hip every day.

 

[dscampbell]

After 30 years I did get rid of my model 36 but I replaced it with a model 10-5 3". Yes a k frame. I added laser grips and it is so sweet to carry.u eyes see the sights on the k frame better during the day and at night the laser grips are great. I sold the model 36 to the grandson of the officer I bought it from. For I price I paid in 1974.


Wheel guns are still real guns too. Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[75Vette]

I actually replaced a Taurus TCP .380 with a m60. I never could get a hold of the Taurus out of my pocket and never really liked it anyway. I sho do like my j frame. I carry everywhere now..

 

[snubbyfan]

For me, it's a 442 either in my pocket or on my belt all day everyday. I've checked out those dinky little wonder pistols at the local gunshop and they just don't fit my hand as well as my 442 with Pachmayr Compacts.

 

[Jaymo]

Negatory. Still prefer the J frame. Used to carry an I frame, but there's no good .38 S&W loads out there any more.

Ahh, but they do make a good one.


https://www.buffalobore.com/index.php?l=product_detail&p=350


I dumped a J frame sized Taurus 85 for a 10 shot Taurus compact 9, and then a Kel-Tec .380.
Never had a minute's trouble with any of the three.
BUT, I found a 36 no dash and reverted back to carrying an old, outdated, obsolete, useless "wheel-gun".

I prefer to launch at least 125 grains of lead. 158 is even better.
Neither of which are real options in a pocket 9 or .380.

Plus, the P3AT is tiny. I get a much better grip on the Chief.
And, it has better sights.

I pray I never have to use a gun in SD.
I prayed even harder, when I was carrying the .380.

I haven't met many guns I didn't like.
I like autos a lot.
I just like revolvers better

 

[acco40]

J-Frames

My J-frames will still be reliably pushing lead out the end of the barrel for many decades to come. So why would I ever replace them?

 

[flgolfer29]

I dumped the j frame for a shield 9. It's greater capacity (7 + 1), I shoot it better than the j frame, and actually enjoy shooting it. It also disappears in a Remora holster.

Joe

 

[Wee Hooker]

When it comes to reliability: Snubies rule! Bottom Feeders Drool!