I have to express my concern.

At this point, I'm thinking her ideal handgun might be a compact SA or DA/SA 9mm that she can keep cocked and locked.... I'm gonna take my 1911 with some target loads, and see how she likes it.

My wife and I often carry 9mm EMPs (a 1911 style 9mm from Springfield), and we carry them cocked and locked. But carrying any gun cocked and locked takes a lot of practice and constant training until the proper grip becomes engrained in muscle memory. Otherwise, the thumb will not rest on the thumb safety and your little lady will wind up wondering why she can't pull the trigger as the perp advances on her.

You already noted that she has difficulty getting a grip on a gun. I'd re-consider bringing your 1911. Once she shoots it and sees how accurate it is and how easy it is to control because of the light trigger, she may want one. IMHO, it's not the gun she should own - unless, of course, she becomes your new range buddy.
 
kbm6893
please don't point to the trigger within a trigger and tell me that's a safety

Amen to that! Don't trust those triggers! ;)

I just went through this with a first time buyer, explained all the rules of gun ownership, explained to him what he should be looking at for the first time buyer and not to be swayed to the Black Magic Plastic but I will guarantee you he wil not take any of the advice given!
Funny isn't it how we know this! ;)
 
Yes. It IS happening all over the country.

I won't opine on which is better - I own both and like both.

But here's my favorite recent story. On the lane next to me is an older couple. The wizened gentleman has purchased his & hers Glocks. The lady has a 9mm and the man has the .45 cal. Lady is shooting at 3 yards, can't hit squat and the muzzle is moving around so much that several of us put our guns down and stand behind her. She's throwing hot brass into her big hair, frantically trying to get it out before her hairspray causes her to spontaneously combust - all the while waving her firearm around. But they persist. Next, the wizened gentleman explains that; in case of an intruder, she may have to pull the .45 out - so she'll need to be able to shoot that one too. He hands her the .45. We go out in the lobby until they're done.
 
I own a gun shop and we really push Greenies towards revolvers. The problem is friends and TV. People always want what there friends have. Sometimes its a loosing battle.
 
Riggs: "Six shooter, huh?"
Murtaugh: "Mm-hmm ..."
Riggs: "Lotta old timers carry those."
lethalweapon.jpg

I resemble that remark.

ECS
 
For me, its a simple matter of mechanics. When a round misfires in my semi-auto, I have to rack the slide to eject the faulty round and chamber another live round, then re-acquire the sight picture and squeeze the trigger. With my D.A revolvers (is there any other kind?). I retain the sight picture and simply pull the trigger again, and normally hear a nice, satisfying, BANG. For a night intrusion or other unsettling encounter, it will always be a revolver for me. If I can't get the job done in 6 rounds, I should have been looking for other work anyway.
Just sayin.
 
I'm a wheel gun fan, but I would not recommend one to a novice who does not plan on training with it extensively. Revolvers are reliable guns. But that is only 1/2 the equation. The other 1/2 is that one has to hit the target one aims at; and the harder the trigger pull, the more a novice will throw the gun to their weak side when jerking the trigger. A near miss is still a miss.

I agree with this, but believe it's a lot more than 1/2. Revolvers, semi-autos, shotguns, machine guns, it's really apples and oranges. You must learn about your weapon, then practice and train with it, whatever it is. A revolver is a great weapon to start with in some respects, but is different in so many ways than an auto and can be just as complicated as an auto without training and practice. It's probably better to know the functions and capabilities about different weapons, but what's most important that no matter what you own, starting out or otherwise, you are completely proficient with it, which also indicates the level of safeness and effectiveness. Negligent discharges can occur with any weapon, and most likely occur due to lack of knowledge, training and practice and not weapon design. It's a rare event that a modern weapon is the cause of an ND; it is invariably some failure of the operator. One of my least favorite excuses of all time is "the gun went off while being cleaned". Yet, pick up a newspaper and you will see that often. Ignoring for one minute the complete obsurdity of that action, anyone that would clean a loaded weapon should instantly be considered negligent.

I've seen some strange posts of late, mostly in the semi-auto areas with opinions on carrying rounds in chambers and "un-safe" weapons like Glocks. I actually saw one post defending an individual that negligently shot another individual in a church, no less. The poster claimed that the shooter had an "accident". Many seem to get accident confused with negligent it seems. Weapon safeties are only as good as the operators understanding and use of them; the safety is the operator via safe handling by qualified operators/shooters. The Glock is inherently no less safe than any other modern weapon in good condition as long as the operator understands how to use it. No weapon is more lethal than the other; a .22lr is just as capable of killing and individual in a situation of negligence every bit as much as a .460 Weatherby. All firearms must be used by competent, physically capable and trained operators or disaster can or will ensue.

I don't care what one starts out with, or purchases later, training is the number 1 consideration with any weapon. I have carried a Glock, and found it to be as easy and safe to handle as any other firearm that I've used, but it took some education and practice to use, like all other firearms I have used. It starts with simple exercises like reading the manual, basic operation (to include clearing procedures), dry-fire and range use, and maybe even more formal training by qualified instructors.
 
Back
Top