I like both Kydex and leather, prefer Kydex for IWB and the look and feel of leather for OWB.
I already had a Desantis suede IWB in my holster drawer, I think it was for a G19 but it fits my .45 Shield well.
For an OWB, I hated to pay $100 plus for a new leather holster, but happened to see this Bianchi Shadow II on E-Bay for $39.95 shipped.
They are meant for a G36, but I took a chance and ordered it and it fits the .45 Shield like it was meant for it.
Thumb break paddle holster, can be worn in two positions, straight up and down or forward cant. These are new holsters in the factory packaging, not used ones.
Very comfortable, and I was wearing it concealed last week while walking the dog early in the morning, I just left my shirt out to cover it.
If anyone is interested they are sold on E-bay by a company called Brick City Concealment.