In a dilemma!

Skip Sackett

US Veteran
Joined
Mar 19, 2006
Messages
4,379
Reaction score
585
Location
Hoosier Land!
Recently, I was able to pass on some reloading equipment to our oldest son. He got bit big time and honestly, I'm glad! No regrets about getting/giving him some "stuff".

Well, now I have a real problem. I decided to give our one son in law a setup too. Awhile back I left my Glock 22 RTF in one of his desk drawers and then came home. About 1000 miles home! :)

While I miss the firearm, never shot it too well but felt well armed with it, I think I have burdened this young couple with something they cannot afford to "feed"! They are very frugal, don't get me wrong, but as you well know, milk and such comes before bullets.

I think I need to try to remedy that a bit! So, to try to make that happen, I began accumulating some stuff I didn't have duplicates of. The main this was scales. Personally, I'm not too keen on the digital ones, just me, not throwing stones at all. Just me.

To be honest, I'm not too enamored with the Dillon manual scale nor the Lyman or for that matter any of the other 3 poise ones available today. Again, just me, don't stone me, friends!

At any rate, we found an old Texan that is just like the one I currently use and gave it to son #1. Actually, I guess I gave him mine and I kept the one I bought for him! (I think I just answered my own dilemma! Read on though! ;) )

So, the search was on for a third Texan. They just "feel" and look like they are quality. Paul5388 says "Texan stuff was mostly over engineered." OK, since it isn't new, that is cool! ;)

Long story short, couldn't find one. Remembering that there was another scale that used the same beam, a Hornady, I began looking for one of them.

Well, there was one on ebay and the auction was ending soon so I jumped on it and won. When the scale arrived I was really pleased at the condition and quality of the Hornady (Pacific) scale.

I went through all of the check weights in the Lyman Check Weight set I had and this thing is rock solid and right on!

OK, now, this thing is soooooooooooooooo nice, and here is the dilemma, do I pass this on or keep it and give him the good old Texan. Both are of exceptional quality and condition.

Might be kind of hard looking at that red thing in the sea of blue on my reloading bench. Might get me kind of patriotic though being red and set against that blue field! :)

I know this is kind of silly but, hey, I thought it would liven your day!

Go ahead and give me your opinion on what to do! Should I pass it on or the Texan?

Pictures:
 

Attachments

  • Check weights.jpg
    Check weights.jpg
    60.3 KB · Views: 78
  • Conversion table.jpg
    Conversion table.jpg
    47.3 KB · Views: 84
  • Good 1.jpg
    Good 1.jpg
    61.3 KB · Views: 93
  • Hornady sticker.jpg
    Hornady sticker.jpg
    59.5 KB · Views: 85
  • Large Poise.jpg
    Large Poise.jpg
    42.5 KB · Views: 85
Register to hide this ad
One more picture!

Couldn't get all of the pictures in the last post! :D
 

Attachments

  • Smaller Poises.jpg
    Smaller Poises.jpg
    33.9 KB · Views: 75
Skip,

There isn't a nickel's worth of difference between that scale and an Ohaus/RCBS 505, especially since they're all magnetic dampened and have three adjustment weights. This Ohaus is a 1973 model and still works just the way it's supposed to. ;)

aba.jpg
 
My preference is a digital scale (a QUALITY one) but any of the major players make a GOOD balance beam scale (except Lee's - I don't care for that one).

You can sleep well whichever one you ship to your SIL.

Dale53
 
I have a model M like that one that I have been using since 1974 and it has never missed a beat. I now have digitals that I use day to day but the M is still there as a back up.
 
If they are both good and accurate scales I do not see a problem.:confused: Give him either one. Why not keep the one You like the best? If you are giving it to them so they can reload for the Glock then that's a pretty nice thing and if I read this correctly you already gave them the Glock also.

You could easily solve this and adopt me.:D
 
Thanks all! OCD1, I have 5 natural kids! Not in the market for any more either. You know the old saying; "Wouldn't take a million for any one of them, and wouldn't give a penny for another!" ;)

(Just kidding folks!)
 
Fun post Skip! From another who is still really happy with his RCBS 5-10 scale from Christmas 1978.

Keep the one with which you are the most familiar and send the others own to the young folks who are just now learning to become familiar with a set-up.
 
Skip, if it were my decision, I'd give away the second Texan so that both recipients have the same scale (no favoritism). And then you're left with a Hornady/Pacific that you really like! (Don't you love it when a plan comes together?)
 

Latest posts

Back
Top