John Westley Hardin

OLDNAVYMCPO

US Veteran, Absent Comrade
Joined
Jun 13, 2014
Messages
1,068
Reaction score
7,403
Location
EL Paso, Tx
John Hardin( May 26, 1853- Aug 19, 1895) is an iconic figure of the Borderland. He was an accomplished killer/ gunfighter who by his own accounts had killed 42 men ( spotty records of the time puts the number closer to 27). He lived here in El Paso since shortly after his release from prison in 1894. He was shot and killed by John Selman,sr in the Acme saloon and is buried at the historic Concordia Cemetery.
Hardin was born near Bonham, Tx to a circuit riding Methodist preacher and a cultured mother. He was the second son of ten children. Descended from a Revolutionary War hero, Col Joseph Hardin, John Hardin ran away from home and tried to join the Confederate army at age nine. He was unsuccessful but six years later, shot and killed his first victim, a freed slave named Maje. He fled what he feared would be Yankee reconstruction justice, then ambushed and killed the three Union soldiers sent to arrest him. He claimed he started the proceedings with a dbl-barrelled shotgun and finished with a cap and ball revolver.
As a fugitive, he teamed up with the outlaw Frank Polk. Pursued by Union soldiers, Polk was eventually captured, Hardin escaped.
The Reconstruction period in Texas was chaotic beyond reason, atrocities were frequently committed on both sides. It was a lawless period in which someone of Wesley's character could thrive. Resentment, distrust and hatred were common human commodities. Desperation and poverty were common conditions. Blacks, Mexicans and Union soldiers were common targets for Hardin's hatred.
In Jan 1870, Hardin participated in a face to face shootout witnessed by a sizeable number of citizens in Towash,Tx. The fight was over a card game, the sore loser of which, Benjamin Bradley, came looking for Hardin later in the day. During the game, Hardin was unarmed, later he was said to be wearing a vest rigged with crossdraw holsters. Bradley fired and missed, Hardin drew both guns and didn't. One head shot and one center of mass. Hardin is also credited with three more victims during that same month.
One year later, at the age of 17, Hardin was arrested for the murder of Laban John Hoffman, city marshal of Waco,Tx. Hardin was secured in a temp jail in Marshal, Tx until he could be transported to Waco. He supposedly bought a pistol from another prisoner. During the trip to Waco, one of the escorting officers left camp to procure horse feed. During his absence, Hardin shot and killed the second officer, Jim Smalley, stole his horse and fled to south Texas. There, he joined in a criminal enterprise with his cousins, the Clemmons, rustling cattle for Jake Johnson and Columbus Carol. The plan was to steal cattle and drive them to market in Kansas.
They gathered a herd and drove them up the Chisolm Trail. With trouble always in his footsteps, Hardin got in a number of fights along the way with Indians and Mexican vaqueros, leaving several fresh graves on the plains.
In Abilene, Ks, another gunfight another killing and Hardin fled. Forty miles down the trail, another killing. While he had been in Abilene, Hardin had used the alias Westley Clemmons but was better known by his nickname " Little Arkansaw". There, Hardin befriended Wild Bill Hickok, Bill being unaware of Hardin's criminal status. Hardin was always his own biggest fan and reveled in his relationship with Wild Bill. Hardin was forced to flee Abilene after he accidently killed a friend in the infamous snoring incident.
Back in south Tx, Hardin once again joined with his cousins and sided with the Taylor family in the famous Taylor-Sutton feud. Trouble followed Hardin like a shadow. Wounded and nearly killed by a shotgun blast in a fight over a poker game, Hardin made a surrender from his sickbed to Sheriff Reagan of Cherokee County, Tx. Yet, when he found out how many murders he was going to be charged with, Hardin reneged, escaped and fled.
In May 1873, Hardin killed DeWitt County Deputy Sheriff J. B. Morgan in Cuero, Tx, then in July, killed the County Sheriff Jack Helms in Albuquerque,Tx. One year later on his 21st birthday, he killed Brown County Deputy Sheriff Charles Webb. In October, he killed one and wounded another Texas State Policeman.
Hardin fled to the Ala/Fla border under the assumed name of James W. Swain. This region was as wild and unruly as the wild west. Hardin was arrested on a train in Pensacola, Fla by local authorities and Texas Ranger John B. Armstrong.
Convicted of killing Webb, Hardin served 17 of a 25 year sentence at Huntsville Prison. He moved to Gonzales, Tx, was pardoned, and passed the state bar exam. He moved to El Paso where he gambled, practiced law and hung-out with a part-time prostitute, M'Rose. His girlfriend was arrested by El Paso lawman John Selman,jr. Hardin confronted Selman verbally and then later argued with Selman's dad, also a lawman. That night, Selman,sr walked up behind Hardin with a revolver, put it to the back of his head and pulled the trigger. Once Hardin lay on the floor, John Selman,sr shot him three more times. A hung jury freed him in the ensuing murder trial.
P.S: For brevity sake, I could not include all the killings for which Hardin is credited. Today, Hardin is back in the news in El Paso because of the recent discovery of the bound, beaten, stabbed, and burned body of "Mexican Jerry" in the basement of the very building which housed the Acme Saloon where Hardin was killed.
 
Last edited:
Register to hide this ad
Good story. I notice you call him Westley several time and I've never seen that before. Also, I believe his relatives and fellow cattle thieves were Clements.
 
I stand corrected, the proper name is Wesley. However the family name is on record as Clemmons.
 
Great read! You have become my weekly reader. I would anxiously await its arrival then barricade myself in my room until I finished it. You have spoiled me. I now look for your posts and when I see your user name I think, oh boy! oh boy! oh boy!
If you stop doing this, I will go through withdrawal so keep it up.
Rusty,
President of your new fan club
 
Mexican Jerry?

Just wondering, is this a current crime or a recently discovered 19th century crime?
 
Another good write up OLDNAVYMCPO, I sure enjoy your articles. I have an old Guns and Ammo special issue that has an four or five page articles about the old gun fighters. I don't have it right in front of me but the name is something to the effect of "Guns and Gun Fighters of the Old West" and I read the old "Triggernomety" every year or two. Those old timers were a pretty tough bunch. Keep up the good work.
 
Just wondering, is this a current crime or a recently discovered 19th century crime?

This is indeed a current crime, unsolved to date and very much in the current news. The fact that it took place where it did is just another facet of the crime story.
 
Those old timers were a pretty tough bunch. Keep up the good work.
I remember reading one time that many of the lawmen and outlaws both were homicidal maniacs and decent people stayed away from both. From my reading I am lead to believe that there is a lot of truth in that statement. Both sides would shoot first and in the back if that is what it took to win. Larry
 
Excellent, Master Chief...

If anybody here is interested in "dark" westerns... read the book... The Pistoleer: A Novel of John Wesley Hardin... by James Carlos Blake. It's not near as dark and desperate as Cormac McCarthy's dire western, Blood Meredian... but it can depress ya.

Ya'll ever notice that the three most dangerous gunmen in the old west... was kilt by bein' shot in the back of the head? Hickok, James... and Hardin.
 
Excellent, Master Chief...



Ya'll ever notice that the three most dangerous gunmen in the old west... was kilt by bein' shot in the back of the head? Hickok, James... and Hardin.

I have read that Hardin was shot in the back of the head and it came out his eye. Some have argued that he was shot in the eye and it came out the back of his head. Someone said if he was shot in the eye it showed good marksmanship. If he was shot in the back of the head it showed good judgement. Larry
 
Post-Civil War Texas was indeed a rough place to keep living. Reconstruction government replaced all local authorities with political appointees (the Texas Rangers were disbanded and the new Texas State Police created, with Union loyalty and political connections the primary requirements). Carpet baggers in cahoots with the reconstruction crowd worked tax scams and property sales displacing many farmers, ranchers, and businessmen. Cash money was almost nonexistent. The majority of people remaining lived in abject poverty. Crime was beyond any possibility of control, and criminal gangs operated with relative impunity.

J.W. Hardin was but one product of those times. Thousands of others lived similar lives, but with less documentary evidence.

Good post!
 
There are reportedly only 2 old west law criminals who crossed paths with the Lincoln County war and the Earp Cowboy feud and those two are John Hardin and Dave Rudabaugh who both sided with the Cowboy fraction although the extent and length of their roles is not hugely known. It is always interesting to me to know which old west outlaws were friends with one another. I believe they made their own reputations and did not want to infringe on another mans territory.

Love these stories though.
 
I have read that Hardin was shot in the back of the head and it came out his eye. Some have argued that he was shot in the eye and it came out the back of his head. Someone said if he was shot in the eye it showed good marksmanship. If he was shot in the back of the head it showed good judgement. Larry

I read that he was shot three times... Selman, Sr. shot him two more times after he fell. Selman, Jr. came in and told him that he didn't have to shoot anymore. The first shot actually came out just a little to the left of Hardin's left eye. Didn't want to post the pic... the rules may not allow it... but here is a link to the pic of Hardin dead... you can see the wound above the eye. Notice another exit wound on the right side of the chest...

http://symonsez.files.wordpress.com/2010/02/johnwesleyhardindead.jpg
 
Polk County Texas just N of Livingston was the place of the first killing, after a fight with the boy.
He had a cousin who became a Texas Ranger.
East Texas was the most populated portion of the state and ruled Texas politics until the 1950's.
The first two tiers of the state, just west of the Sabine and Louisiana were notoriously Southern and as lawless as the Trans Pecos.
One could live within 30 miles of another town and never know it was there.
The old town of San Augustine had a state hwy within a mile of the center of town but would not build a road to connect to it.
Blessings
 
Thank you Master chief for another great read.My son lives in El Paso so I get there occasionally did not know the bar Hardin was killed in was still there.Untill I read of the modern crime there.I am looking forward do visiting it on my next trip to El Paso
 
Thankyou for this too Master Chief. Not to stray much fromthis thread--I was watching a late season 2 episode of Maverick--one that had both brothers in it--and I THINK was the one that had Clint Eastwood in it? Anyway, they were leaving a town and encountered a stranger on the road asking where the town was? and asking about the man who "killed"John Wesley Hardin? Bret told him a guy named Bret Maverick "killed" Hardin--and pointed the way to town. Hardin introduced himslf and thanked them, needless to say--both Mavericks sped away as fast as possible wearing yellow streakes down their backs a mile wide. :D

Back on topic.
 
Whe the Gene Autry museum last year I saw the Hardin guns again. In the case is Hardin's .45 (behind George Scarborough's shotgun), The plain .45 Selman used to kill Hardin, and the pearl handled .45 Scarborough used to kill Selman. I spent some time gawking at these amazing historical guns used by three very tough Texans.

 
Back
Top