Model 28 barrel on a Model 27?

TennTony

US Veteran
Joined
Jan 18, 2010
Messages
382
Reaction score
404
Location
Washington State
Using the search function I found posts that say barrels can be swapped between Models 27 & 28.

I am considering buying a Model 27-3 with an 8-3/8" barrel that I want to replace with a shorter barrel. Thus far all I have found is a barrel listed as being for Model 28 and/or 28-3. Assuming this is feasable, what problems am I walking into attempting such a change? What is the rough probability that I will need a lathe to complete the project?

Thanks for any advice.

Tony
 
Register to hide this ad
The barrels are interchangeable (with fitting of course i.e. lathe work), the other considerations, however, are the matte finish, non-checkered rib and "Highway Patrolman" markings on the model 28 barrel.

I hope this answers your question, good luck,
Steve
 
Last edited:
Rough probability for tools needed (that you may not already have) is: Frame fixture and barrel wrench - 100%, Lathe - 100%, skills and experience in turning barrel ends (at forcing cone) so you don't mess up the barrel/shroud/frame interface and end up with a proper sight picture as well - 100%. Of course, you could get some practice with that setup, and you may end up with a snubby (only kidding, sort of). The cost of the tools alone will far exceed the cost to have it professionally rebarreled. Here's another consideration - the 27 has a high polish blue, whereas the 28 has a bead-blasted finish, and the gun will look pretty strange if the barrel is not stripped, polished and blued (in fact, the entire gun should be re-blued, if you want the finish to match between the barrel and frame). Evan after that, you'll have a Model 27 with a barrel that is stamped "Highway Patrolman" on the right side. If I were you, I'd keep that barrel on the 27 until I found the right barrel (for a 27) and get the barrel and gun to a competent, skilled gunsmith with experience in these things (and with the proper equipment), or trade the gun (if you buy it) on a 27 with a shorter barrel. Of course, if you're looking for an excuse to buy a lathe, frame fixture and other tools, that's OK, too.

Oh yeah, not only is the 28 barrel a different finish, with roll markings specific to that model, but it also lacks the checkering along the top of the rib that the 27 has. I don't think you'd be happy with the finished result, and you run the risk of turning a beautiful work of art into a bit of a mongrel (just my opinion). It certainly would destroy the value of the gun.

One other suggestion - if you buy the gun, try it for a while with the 8 3/8" barrel, I bet you'll fall in love with it. I sure like mine.
 
Last edited:
That didn't take long. I'm convinced to stop.

Thank you very much for the advice. I will either buy the gun with plans on swapping it later for the shorter version. Or, I will pass on this one.

I truly appreciate the excellent advice I get here.
 
Back
Top