Model 28
- Thread starter tedog
- Start date
I've seen 'em like you describe at about 5 on Gunbroker.
That's an "N" prefixed gun, an older "S" might sell a little stronger.
GF
That's an "N" prefixed gun, an older "S" might sell a little stronger.
GF
Jack Flash
Member
Does it have a dash number? Is it a 3-, 4-, or 5-screw? Those things have a bearing on the value.
"no box or tools & original stocks"
I take it that means it does have the original stocks(?) That would be a big plus, especially if it is an early model-marked M28.
No reason to dispute the $500 price estimate, but that may well be at the low end, depending on the answers to the above questions.
"no box or tools & original stocks"
I take it that means it does have the original stocks(?) That would be a big plus, especially if it is an early model-marked M28.
No reason to dispute the $500 price estimate, but that may well be at the low end, depending on the answers to the above questions.
I will see it tomorrow, he said he bought it new in the 60s and threw away the box. Said he did not change stocks. I'll let you know tomorrow about the dash and if I now own it. Thanks
Traded a new model Superblackhawk for the 28-2, N81XXX. The gentleman had it graded a little high IMO, so we made an even swap. It did have numbered stocks to the gun. It appears to have been fired very little as he purchased it himself around 1970. It has some very light rust on the cylinder but most should come off. Will make a fine shooter. Will post pics later.
Jack Flash
Member
Well 1970 is the year S&W went from the S prefix to the N prefix so it could be either. It should be an M28-2, three screw, pinned and recessed.
I think there were only three options -
4" or 6" barrel
Target Stocks (vs. standard service "magna" stocks)
Smooth Trigger (vs. serrated)
I think there were only three options -
4" or 6" barrel
Target Stocks (vs. standard service "magna" stocks)
Smooth Trigger (vs. serrated)
I think that $300 to $400 is more likely depending on condition because the Model 28 is the "cheapo" version of the Model 27 which goes for maybe $600 to $800 (also depending on condition).
They are the same pistols, but the 28 is the "Patrolman", a duty pistol with a lesser finish (matt instead of gloss blue) and some other cost saving features as well.
Internally, it is identical to the 27 but not as "pretty".
I'd consider the 28 to be a good range shooter or car gun, but I don't see lots of collectable value in it.
That may sound harsh, but it's similar to the difference between a brand new Mustang Shelby GT 500 and a new Mustang V6.
Same basic car, but done differently, and I know which one that I personally would find more desireable.
I've been given the opportunity to pick up a Model 28 from an estate at $200, and it's in really nice condition. But I'm tending to think I'll pass on it at that price. No one else wants it at this point, and I'm going to offer them $125 to take it off their hands, and if I get it for that, it will become another house gun to be stashed somewhere for quick access.
They are the same pistols, but the 28 is the "Patrolman", a duty pistol with a lesser finish (matt instead of gloss blue) and some other cost saving features as well.
Internally, it is identical to the 27 but not as "pretty".
I'd consider the 28 to be a good range shooter or car gun, but I don't see lots of collectable value in it.
That may sound harsh, but it's similar to the difference between a brand new Mustang Shelby GT 500 and a new Mustang V6.
Same basic car, but done differently, and I know which one that I personally would find more desireable.
I've been given the opportunity to pick up a Model 28 from an estate at $200, and it's in really nice condition. But I'm tending to think I'll pass on it at that price. No one else wants it at this point, and I'm going to offer them $125 to take it off their hands, and if I get it for that, it will become another house gun to be stashed somewhere for quick access.
Last edited:
Jack Flash
Member
I would definately jump on any M28 for $200. (Well, assuming it hadn't been dragged behind a truck or such 
)
I think $250 or so would have been a reasonable estimate for a decent shooter three or four years ago, but they have gone up recently. Now $400 is more the base price, and they go up from there depending on how nice they are, barrel length, etc.
The one Tedog is looking at may even have little diamonds around the screw holes on the stocks. Those seem to send folks here into a swoon!
Of course, we now know there is some rust on Tedog's, so that would negatively impact price, but probably not too badly, depending on how it cleans up.
)I think $250 or so would have been a reasonable estimate for a decent shooter three or four years ago, but they have gone up recently. Now $400 is more the base price, and they go up from there depending on how nice they are, barrel length, etc.
The one Tedog is looking at may even have little diamonds around the screw holes on the stocks. Those seem to send folks here into a swoon!
Of course, we now know there is some rust on Tedog's, so that would negatively impact price, but probably not too badly, depending on how it cleans up.
Moonman
Member
Prices have definitely increased for Model 28's. A chance for a 28 at $200 would have been LONG GONE around here.
A10
Member
Check the Ultimate Highway Patrolman thread if anyone here has a question about desire/collectability of the 28. I think people love them because they aren't the "beauty queens" that 27's are. ( Ever date a cheerleader? Talk about high maintenance!) And, they're great shooters!
Long gone is certainly correct.....$500, unless it's beat all to poop.
If you get this for $200, you better go buy LOTS of lotto tickets.
We want photos too!!
$200 for a 28? Someone has been asleep or a long time.
JCS&W
US Veteran
$200 for a M28-2? $200 is not even a good down payment around here. Prices on these workhorses have jumped way up. I see them in the gun stores starting at $400 and go up if they have the original anything with them. I bought a really nice M28-2 6 months ago for $350 and felt like a thief. Guess it is all about where you are.
