There was a guy on gunbroker a few years ago who had tons of S&W revolvers, with a bright stainless finish. Almost like nickel. Obviously buffed with a wheel and shined with Mothers. He had them listed as "new in box", but the boxes were generic plastic factory ones. And the stocks were aftermarket wood with no medallions. He had a bunch of 3" 65's. Wanted nearly a grand because they were "new in box and rare". A little research showed this guy was partnered up with a local refinishing house. He was taking scratched up guns, probably PD trade-in's, and buffing out the scratches.
My feedback on there is 100%, both as buyer and seller. I'd never send a stranger with a **** rating, any payment.