Model 37 opinions?

duckloads

Member
Joined
Sep 4, 2006
Messages
903
Reaction score
27
Location
Nicholasville, Kentucky
I'm still looking for a purse gun for my wife. The Model 15's (I bought 2 in nickle) are just to heavy for her. My local dealer has an as new M37 in nickle. It's a nice little gun with a nickle plated aluminum frame and nickle steel cylinder and barrel. It's really light. My wife likes it.

any opinions on the gun?
 
Register to hide this ad
Originally posted by duckloads:
I'm still looking for a purse gun for my wife. The Model 15's (I bought 2 in nickle) are just to heavy for her. My local dealer has an as new M37 in nickle. It's a nice little gun with a nickle plated aluminum frame and nickle steel cylinder and barrel. It's really light. My wife likes it.

any opinions on the gun?

The 37 is a fine gun. The questions that I cannot answer for you are: (1) although light, can your wife handle the extra recoil of an airweight, (2) is the hammer likely to catch on things in the purse or the purse itself on removal, (3) will your wife learn and remember the only proper and safe way to lower the hammer so that the risk of negligent discharge is reduced?

Personally, if she can handle the recoil of an airweight, I would prefer the 642 for the application you suggest. If she cannot handle the recoil of an airweight, you need to re-think the whole project.

Better yet, instead of you picking it, why don't you let her fire several and pick the one SHE likes?
 
The nickel finish on the 37 you're looking at is far superior to the finish on a 642.
I wish all my Smiths looked like my nickel Model 49, purchased in 1984.
Unless you go stainless and you said steel is too heavy,
you won't find a current Smith with a finish as nice as the one you're looking at.

Yes, the hammer can be an issue, but she can learn to cover it with her thumb,
if she needed to get to it. She can choose a bullet with recoil she can handle
and become proficient with that ammo. If she ever had to use it to protect herself,
odds are it would be used at a distance of 8 feet or even closer.
Nobody really needs a flame thrower from that distance.
Also people trained properly will shoot double action in a defensive situation
regardless of whether their revolver is double action only or single/double.

My wife was trained by a professional, learned on a Smith Model 39 9mm
and shoots 38, 9mm, 357, 45 and 44 (both Special and Magnum).
Purse gun? Used to be a nickel Model 37. Then she went to a blue Model 38.
She just decided she wanted a blue gun and I had that model.


I would also bet the 37 you're looking at has a better trigger than a 642.
I have a 442, a 340 PD and a 640 (38), and the 49 has the sweetest
out of the box action of them all. They don't make things like they used to.
Speaking of which, the Model 38 has better bluing than any blue gun made nowadays.
Yes I know, Pythons had the best blue ever, but those aren't made anymore either.

Also, let her try a few different grips to see the one she's most comfortable with.
 
Mod 37 with a Tyler T or a boot grip is a great combination, man or woman. I have a Mod. 38, 649, Mod 60, 60-4 and half doz other J frames. Even two nice Cobras. I prefer the Round Butt 37, Tyler T and load "often" with 148 gr. full wadcutters. Soft shooting, but potent in that "8 feet or even closer." Shot placement is much easier with the low recoil of the wadcutters. An all steel J would have Speer +P but that is not under discussion here.--Tom
 
It would be fine for a purse gun, but it is not rated for +p.
I would only use wad cutters or 158gr. lead.
In other words carry but shoot seldom.
 
Thanks for all the words. A few months ago, I bought a pinned 15-4 in nickle. It was to nice to carry, so I found anouther 15-4 in nickle that had enough wear on it that it didn't matter to carry it. She said it was to heavy. She shot it just fine with light trail boss loads and "full power" Unique loads both with 158 gr SWC bullets.

Today, I took her into Larrys and she got to handle a M60, M36, and the M37 amoung others. When she held the M37 she said, "this is it". She likes the nickle.

So I guess I'll "have" to go back on Monday and get the little jewel.

Thanks
 
Back
Top