Model 617: go for 6 shot or 10 shot?

ric426

Member
Joined
Feb 17, 2010
Messages
91
Reaction score
14
Location
S.E. Michigan
I've got a line on a couple of used Model 617's locally at decent (not great) prices. They're both 6", but one's a 6 shot and the other is a 10 shot. I'm interested in one to use as a practice clone for my Model 14 so a 6 shot is tempting, but are there compelling reasons to go with the 10 shots instead? Would one or the other retain a better resale price? Does the action of a 10 shot feel significantly different than a 6 shot?
 
Register to hide this ad
I have 10 shot 617's in 4 and 8-3/8 barrels and a 6" 17 6 shot. They are all nice but I have to say that I like to shoot revolvers in steel plate and bowling pin shoots so the 10 shot is the only way to go. But for target, plinking and hunting the 6 shooters work just fine. So I guess it comes down to what you want to use them for. I personally can't say that I notice any difference in the feel of the actions. As far as resale goes I really haven't got a clue which would hold value better!
 
The 6 shot guns usually have target hammers and target triggers,the 10 shots may not.I would lean toward the six shot version,since you mentioned having a Model 14.
 
I own a 6 shot. The best part is that you only have to clean 60% of the amount of chambers you would have to clean with a 10 shot.

Bill
 
Last edited:
I can't come up with any good reason to avoid the internal lock on a recreational revolver, except, perhaps, cosmetic reasons. The ten shot is a lot of fun, more trigger time until empty.
 
I'd personally prefer the 10 shot.

Because.....it holds 10 rounds, instead of just 6!:D
 
I have a 10 shot 6" and 6 shot 4". I like the 4" better because i can shoot it better. Amazing for a guy with old eyes.

John
 
I have four 617's. Three are pre lock - one 4 inch and two 6 inch - 6 shot. My one 10 shot is a 4 inch drilled and tapped so it sports an Ultradot 30 and it gets a lot of shooting. One of the 6 inch has a better double action trigger and it also gets shot a lot. It is hard to pick a favorite. All are very accurate and I like and shoot them all. Given a choice and for similar dollars, I would buy the 6 shooter. They are hard to find now.
 
I prefer the 6-shot versions, as the cylinder looks better IMO than with a 10-shot version. Same goes for a 8-shot model 63, which is not so good looking as the 6-shot old version. However, 6 or 7 on a 686/686+ have almost no 'visual' impact, but with more a gun looses it's classical look and seem like cheap stuff.

If it would be an unfluted cylinder, I would mind less. But maybe that's only me.
 
i have a 10 shoots 4 " the only bad thing it's long to clean when i bought it i'm looking for a 34 or 18 ,2 months lather i see a add for a 34 4" like new and at fair price (250 euro)
 
I called the dealer and they're holding the pre-lock 6" 6 shot for me. I'll check it out later today and if everything looks good I'll put a deposit on it and get a purchase permit on Monday.
Anything in particular I should look for beyond the usual checks? Is there any way to tell if it's been dry fired? From what I read on the S&W site that dry firing a rim fire revolver can damage the firing pin.
 
On the 617 with the standard firing pin, IMO the only harm that dry firing will do is stress the hammer. The fact is the firing pin doesn't extend far enough to contact the cylinder so the only real harm is the shock that the hammer strike causes. There isn't anything present to cushion the hammer fall when it falls so that it shoots the firing pin forward and then hits the frame, so it's a heck of a shock. I seen reports of hammer spurs breaking off due to excessive dry firing and suspect that it no applies to any S&W with a frame mounted firing pin.

Best way to avoid this problem is by using snap caps to act as a cushion for the firing pin and hammer. However you cannot find snap caps for rimfires, so in this case it's best to save your fired brass and use an undimpled area on the rim for each dry fire strike. It's a big PITA but it will protect the gun. BTW, if you compare the noise with an undimpled area under the pin to one that has been struck, you'll note that it's distinctly different.

BTW, I prefer the 6 shot 617. Not only is there less to clean but it's also less time waiting for smoke to clear. I do most of my shooting at indoor ranges because outdoor rages in my area are a minimum 35 mile drive. One thing about shooting 22LR in a revolver is that it's a very smoky shooting round. So much so that I have to wait for hte smoke to clear after 6 shots so I can see the target. With my 6 shooter, I'm reloading at that point, so the smoke has a chance to clear. With a 10 shooter it would probably mean shooting 5 at a time with a pause as long as a reload takes to wait for the smoke to clear. So, for me, a 6 shooter is a more logical choice. Plus, it's traditional and I like tradition.
 
From what I'm reading most of you prefer the 6 shot because It "looks" better or more "traditional". That is a poor way to choose a firearm. I'm not trying to be mean or personal, just an observation.

IMO that is very faulty way to make a decision. The choice should be by the one that shoots the best. That is not always possible so the one that locks up good and doesn't have timing issues. One that appears not to have been messed with. Other things to look for would be barrel/cylinder gap. Is there any end shake, etc.

John
 
Back
Top