Looking at your guns .... takes me in another direction.
IMO the best all around/utility/duty .357 is a 4" 686....... grip frame and trigger reach of a K frame and strength of a N-frame.
designed from the ground up in the late 1970s to shoot the hottest .357 ammo all day every day! but will also handle everything from shotshells, wadcutters to any .38 special.
Some say the -4s are the best but again IMO any "dash" is good to go!!!
IMO the best all around/utility/duty .357 is a 4" 686....... grip frame and trigger reach of a K frame and strength of a N-frame.
designed from the ground up in the late 1970s to shoot the hottest .357 ammo all day every day! but will also handle everything from shotshells, wadcutters to any .38 special.
Some say the -4s are the best but again IMO any "dash" is good to go!!!