More 686?'s

boingboing

Member
Joined
May 30, 2010
Messages
309
Reaction score
167
Location
Louseyana
Well after so many years of owning guns I finally got a large frame revolver in the form of a 4" 686. The only other revolver I own is a SP101 so I know next to nothing about the 686. It's a -8, whatever that signifies and is in immaculate condition. I really couldn't see a drag mark on the back of the cylinder either. I paid a pretty premium for it and hope I didn't get ripped off. So, can anyone tell me the specifics on the -8?
 
Register to hide this ad
Hello,
I have the latest edition (3rd) of the Standard Catalog of S&W. The reference material only covers up to the 686-7 change (2002).
 
As far as I know 686's are currently on the -6 configuration. The -6 added the internal lock. I would imagine the "-8" is actually a sloppy -6. Post some pics of your new score.
 
It looked like a -8 but I didn't have my glasses on. The SN is CTL6370. It's on lay a way right now hence no pics.
 
If it's on layaway, you still have time to change your mind then I assume. I'm not saying that gun is a bad choice, but you will learn more about specific variations on here and might realize you can have a 686 variation that you would actually prefer more and pay a far less price. Used guns to me are great if you plan to shoot the gun anyway, it's not like under normal conditions you're going to wear the gun out, and the value is typically less on used guns (unless you get into highly sought after collector guns). This forum will provide a wealth of information and you might get more information/opinions than you want, but take the information that is useful to you and make the most informed decision you can. A newer S&W with a lock is not a horrible thing, I doubt it will ever give you any problems at all.....however, if you could have a gun w/o it, along with forged parts (MIM parts really aren't a horrible thing either) all for a cheaper price that might be something to consider. To me the lock just looks a bit awkward and I feel that it will affect the long term value of my revolvers, and since my revolvers are not only used for protection/fun......I consider them an investment as well. In many cases I have purchased older used wheel guns with out the lock and w/o MIM parts much cheaper, and today these guns have appreciated in value more so than had I purchased a gun new and never fired it. Just some food for thought, either way you will love than gun and it will serve you well for years to come.
 
As far as I know the current production ones with the Lock are 686-6.
They have made a 686-7 which is in 38 Super I believe.

You have a very good start with an SP101 as well as a 686. Both should be very shootable revolvers.

Enjoy

Bob
 
Good choice

A 686 in immaculate condition at a decent price is a very good choice. I got my 686 no dash used but in almost new shape. I'm definitely glad I bought it. They are sweet shooters.

Oh, BTW. The 686 is a medium/large frame in S&W terms.
 
Last edited:
I'm pretty sure I have a -8 too. I think all the newer Talo editions are now -8 and 7 shot with round butt frames. Great guns. For what they sell new, good ones that are older are selling for the same or higher in today's market. Don't worry about the lock, it's already been over 12 yrs that they've had them and none of my revolvers with it shoot any different. 30 yrs from now I'm sure they will still shoot the same. Enjoy it and have fun.
 
Looked at one in a local pawn shop yesterday. 686 no dash w/6". It is in excellent condition. They are asking 725 and will not budge. Sure seems like a lot to me but I haven't researched current pricing and would appreciate the collected wisdom of this forum.
 
Thirty years from now S&W revolvers with the lock will be collector's pieces.

Further comments will get me politcally dinged.

You may be correct, but I doubt they will bring the premium that the older S&W's are bringing. Can you think of one newer gun with the lock and newer features that has skyrocketed in price since they stopped making them? Maybe the 610 and the 647, but the 610 no dash and -1 is still bringing a higher price to the table than the newer -2, and the 647 was never offered w/o a lock but I imagine if it was the no lock model would out price the newer one. Trust me though, I really hope you are correct.....
 
No reason for a panic attack if someone buys a newer smith. I would like to see them remain in business.
 
I have a 686 4" and in my opinion, it's a sweetie. It shoots 38's and +P's like a dream and 357 mag is cake after you get used to it.

I wouldn't worry too much about the lock. Not worth waiting/worrying/hoping to find one and miss out on shooting one in the meantime. If you decide you really want one without the lock you'll have something to use while you search and you won't have much trouble selling either one. I'd rather drive a `57 Chevy too but until I find one I still need a way to get to work!

Enjoy!
 
I'm pretty sure there are -8's. Mine's a 686-8. Look at the pics. Doesn't look like a -6 to me. I have looked at it under a magnifying glass and it's definitely an 8. Was manufactured new in 2010. Sweet shooter too.
 

Attachments

  • P1010779.jpg
    P1010779.jpg
    64.9 KB · Views: 101
  • P1010775.jpg
    P1010775.jpg
    98 KB · Views: 101
You can definitely

Looked at one in a local pawn shop yesterday. 686 no dash w/6". It is in excellent condition. They are asking 725 and will not budge. Sure seems like a lot to me but I haven't researched current pricing and would appreciate the collected wisdom of this forum.

You can do much better than that with some shopping around unless there is something about that particular gun that makes it unique. I got a similar for $550 which is in the ball park for these.
 
you can usually get older used 686's for less than 600, unless there is something unique that makes them highly desireable. No reason to pay 200-300 more for a newer lock model when they can be had much cheaper.....
 

Latest posts

Back
Top