Most "representative" S&W revolver?

Joined
Jan 24, 2007
Messages
10,358
Reaction score
52,003
Location
Arizona
Last week I had the rare privilege to attend the annual Smith & Wesson Collectors Association meeting, this year held in Tucson, Arizona.

I have never seen such an assemblage of Smith and Wesson firearms. The displays were absolutely out of this world. One could see Registered Magnums, Triple Locks, and at least one example, it seemed, of nearly every S&W ever made, from first to last. Ever see a S&W 9mm light rifle? Neither had I, but there were two at the show, made for the British during WWII but never accepted by them. That's just one example.

Seeing all these fine firearms got me to thinking. If one could point to just ONE Smith & Wesson that would be representative of the entire breed; one that could be displayed proudly on the cover of a book exclusively devoted to S&W craftsmanship, what should it be?

My thinking is that it should be a revolver, of course. Smith is known for its revolvers over and above everything else. And it should be in a classic caliber - perhaps the first Magnum, the still potent .357. The gun itself should not be elaborately engraved or anything like that - it should be representative of the majority of revolvers turned out. An finally, it should be esthetic - a nice looking, classic piece.

My choice would be this one: a 3 1/2" barreled Model 27, with the classic blue finish - target stocks, red ramp, target trigger and hammer. In my mind, about as representative a S&W firearm as exists. You may have another choice - how about it?

MODEL27-captioned-small.jpg
 
Register to hide this ad
I'm with Dick on this one. The "classic" S&W revolver.
 
Firstly, thank you Paladin for your many fine posts; I have enjoyed them thoroughly for sometime.

In reference to your question, and boy is it a hard one, my vote for a only one to represent all would be the .44 magnum, Model 29.

I completely understand the advocacy of the .357, Model 27--and your's is awful purdy. But, personally, if I were to select just one to represent the entire gamut, it would be a 5-screw .44 S&W.
 
I would vote for the M&P. That gun was the "bread and butter" gun for S&W and they sold far more of them than any other model. The M&P and all it's variations, the 1902, 1905, Victory, pre-10, 10 etc. is the most representative of the majority of S&W revolvers as mentioned in your post. These guns to me are the most classic of of S&W's and one added benefit is that a decent collection of these guns can still be built without selling your house. While the M&P is not glamorous like a Triple Lock or a R.M. it was for many years the backbone of the company.

An interesting post and I very much enjoyed meeting you in Tucson.
 
I'm with Lt JL on this one. It is THE classic revolver that defines Smith and Wesson.
 
Dick, and another ten people, are clearly right. But I have held on to my 4" 29-2 as a sort of representative of S&W's best (at that time). I know that an older pre-29 might be slightly better made, and the endurance package was an improvement, and I won't even start a flame war by telling you what grips I have on that 29, but I do feel that S&W is entitled to have that 29-2 represent them just as much as the Model 10.
 
As far as the members of the forum are concerned, the Model 10 or 27 may be indicative of Smith and Wesson, but as far as the general public-those unschooled in Smith firearms are concerned-everyone has heard of the 44 Magnum. It has to be its most famous gun. My $ .02.

Model29LargeCustom.jpg
 
The MOST representative? Hands down,the M&P. Not my favorite by any means,but if you're not an adolescent,when you say Smith & Wesson,this is the one that immediately comes to mind. Any length really. This just happens to be a 5" version. Read the words on the blue banner on the box. Pretty much sums it up! Only one I've ever owned. Recently sold it to a serious collector.

guns052.jpg


f.t.
 
I think the general public views (at least in my experience) the N frame .44 Magnum as the quintessential Smith & Wesson.
 
Back
Top