need advice (help)

[kenjen]

I have the option to buy ONE smith revolver. My choices are a 586 no dash, no M, 6" bbl. with a nickel finish. The other is a Model 28-2, 6" bbl. Both are in very good condition and shoot well. Like I said I can only buy one,(he will only sell one). So my problem is which one should I buy, they both are the same price.

 

[murphydog]

What a dilemma . You mentioned they both shoot well, so you should opt for the one that felt best to you. For me, it would be the 586; N frames handle too big, if that makes sense.

 

[Culina]

I would go for the 28-2 for no other reason than its an N-Frame and thats what I like.

 

[skeezix]

I'd buy the 28-2. I like old N-frames, too.

 

[kenjen]

I really like the looks and feel of the 586, but there is something about the 28 that tells me that I have to have it.

 

[Tyrod]

I bought a new nickel 19 in 1985 and I couldn't look at it without getting a scratch.

 

[NE450No2]

I agree, get the one that feels best to you. For me it would be the Mod 28 because it would fit all the holsters I have for my 44 Mag and 45 ACP/Auto Rim revolvers.

Either one would make a great 357 Mag.

 

[CWH44300]

go for the N-frame...they rule

 

[PMRet]

I really like the looks and feel of the 586, but there is something about the 28 that tells me that I have to have it.

Sounds to me like you've answered your own question...

 

[jebe]

you said same money...... the 28 just in case you change your mind its worth more,and it sounds like you might......jebe

 

[Gman56]

If they are in the same shape and price I would get the 28.I have a 28 and a 686-1the 28 is more accurate.It is a little heavy but the wieght helps to absorbs the recoil.Get the 28 you can pick up a 586 latter. The 28s are going up in value so buy cheap and enjoy!

 

[Joe in SC]

Having owned both, I would go with the 28. I sold my 586 and 686, but I still have my 28-2. It will be one of the guns that get passed on. It's just a better 357 magnum revolver !

 

[kenjen]

well after reading your posts and alot of thinking i got the 28-2. thank you for your input; it was tough to decide

 

[C.S.63]

Congratulations on the model 28
Pictures?