I had the top one, it was a good case but when I got my Midway Case I gave it to a friend. I have two of the Midway cases for my AR's one Green one Black. The only issue I had with the Optics Planet case was I was going to sell it to him but I found a small hole that had been rubbed through the material on one of the Magazines Pockets, I dont think that was the cases fault but mine in the way I have to store my rifles.