*New S&W 586

[kouch]

I saw a new s&w 586-8 at my local gun store, and I am in the market for a 357 revolver to target shoot with. I was wondering if anyone has a range report on this gun yet, I know it is a new release, or if anybody has any recomendations. Thank you in advance!

 

[cornfed83]

While many people don't mind buying new guns I tend to think that I can find a used one that will generally be a better price and of the higher, older quality. I personally don't own any brand new Smiths mainly due to sites like GunBroker where I can find good deals on used guns. Bear in mind that most guns will "break in" after so many rounds and it is ridiculously difficult to wear out a revolver, so often by buying used you'll already be at a nice break in point on your gun.

 

[xopher88x]

I have a couple older model 686s which is the stainless equivalent to the 586. The L frame makes the .38 Special feel like a .22LR. And you can comfortably shoot as many .357 Magnums as you can afford. Mine are crazy accurate out to about 75 feet. Beyond that distance I don't really do the gun any justice. I'm sure a better shooter certainly could. I have several new Smith revolvers, a couple have the lock (gasp!), and they are all of superb quality. You're picking a great gun and if you want new, get new. If you happen upon a used one for a good price, don't hesitate going that route either.

 

[ma deuce]

Much to my surprise, a LGS has two new ones in stock, a 4" and a 6", $689 apiece. I'm sorely tempted, but might hold out for an old one.

 

[bananaman]

Only MY opinion, ( many would agree) find an old one! Mine is a no dash, 4", 1983. It is super nice, and I would like a 6" 686 to go with it. I have approx $440, in mine. Pull the trigger on a new 1, and what is it worth? ( used dollar wise) Regardless 586's are nice, and if the new ones equal the old, you will be a happy camper! Bob

 

[Loy Loyola]

Kouch: how much is this gun that you are considering? price factors in most responses of "buy it or buy old!".

 

[Dpris]

Have one here, have not had a chance to shoot it yet.
Looks pretty nice externally.
Barrel's not canted.
Denis

 

[kouch]

Thank you for all the responses, the gun I am looking at is $689. Maybe I will look for an older model, if I am unable to find one I guess I will give the new model a try.

 

[Research Nerd]

I don't think you can go wrong either way. Everything I read about the 686's is they're fantastic guns with or without the lock. I've shot several and they're fun to shoot, accurate and easy on the eyes. I think my wife is getting me one for father's day. If so, I'll be one happy pappa.

Enjoy,

 

[Gman56]

As much as I don't want a lock 586.I hate to say it but the new 586 is growing on me. I' ve been looking for a 586 4 in for a few yrs now. I have not found one that did not have any problems. They will have flame cutting badly or they are just ran very hard and are loose!
The pics I see of the new 586 look great. I would have to get the plug cover kit. I will keep looking for an older S&W 586.I have not seen any in my LGS yet so ordering is what I will have to do to get it.I have not talked to my LGS to get a price so the search continues.

 

[Titegroups]

Nothing really wrong with the new models, most seasoned gun buyers strongly prefer the older no-lock models. If you do buy a new one check the barrel to make sure it's not canted in relation to the frame. The 586/686 guns make great range guns.

 

[kouch]

What's the best way to check to see if it is canted? Is it really noticeable or do you have to really look hard for it? Thank you for any help with this.

 

[Rod-Man]

My preferred for target shooting is 686 6-inch barrel in double action,at 27 yd with .38 wc:very nice trigger and low recoil