Perfected Model

I have always thought this model was one of the most interesting of all the top-breaks. I enjoy shooting my examples and they are an important part of my collection of S&Ws to me.

As for barrel lengths, based on my data from when I did a Commentary on the 38 Perfected a few years back, the most uncommon barrel length was 5". Both 3.25" and 4" ended up about 35% of production each, while the 5" was only 5%, and the 6" barreled Perfecteds were around 25% from the data I have collected. I think this is a common spread for top-breaks, since buyers seem to have either wanted shorter barrels for pocket carry or long barrels for accuracy and holster carry. The 5" is normally the least popular barrel length.

This is an interesting revolver, probably the most exported of all top-break S&W models. They were particularly attractive to both South American and European markets. This is one of the of the reasons why we do not see large numbers for sale in the US.

The rarest examples of this model was a handful of 38 Perfected revolvers that were made without a thumb release. Even more interesting is the fact that they show up in the mid to late serial number range. Pictures are attached. Also, there were 3 patent date change stampings on this model. The earliest showed the last patent date was 1906, a later the stamp added the 1909 patent date, while the very last revolvers made added a hammer block safety patent date of 1914. Less than 2000 made at the end of production had the hammer safety block, giving this model a "1st Change" designation as noted in SCSW4. As with all early hand ejector models, the 1914 safety hammer block was a change designated with a new model or change designation, one that is deserved for the Perfected as well.
 

Attachments

  • 1.jpg
    1.jpg
    46.9 KB · Views: 38
  • 2.jpg
    2.jpg
    45.6 KB · Views: 38
  • 38 Perfected 43602a.JPG
    38 Perfected 43602a.JPG
    170.6 KB · Views: 42
I always find it amazing how much knowledge is just floating around out there. Seems you guys really know your stuff. Perhaps one of you can give me a bit of history on this holster I got with the gun, theres a stamping on the belt loop of a 5 over 38 over 4. I've tried to research it and have had no luck.
 

Attachments

  • rsz_20190304_200431.jpg
    rsz_20190304_200431.jpg
    279.9 KB · Views: 35
  • rsz_20190304_200437.jpg
    rsz_20190304_200437.jpg
    280.6 KB · Views: 29
Welcome to the forum, Tanker. Stick around. As you've observed, there is a tremendous amount of knowledge and experience here.

There are also some really great people. Visit the Lounge and you'll see how these folks rally around someone in need of help and encouragement. You'll also encounter some fine silliness and good recipes.
 
Hey Army,
Thanks for the holster photo. Lots of folks out there really like the early leather. This holster presents itself as an early " mail order" flap holster. I know we often don't like to hear the " Mail order" term but it was an important part of early product distribution in this country with the coming of the railroad. Major Distributors like Hartley & Graham, Turner & Ross, Sears & Roebuck, Montgomery Ward, and about 80 others provided the consumer with product availability from all over the country. Your flap holster can be seen in many of the early catalogs that date back to ; My earliest in my collection is circa 1876. The pattern weave design on your holster was typical of the late 1800's but surplus could have been easily sold decades later! The catalogs are great historical reference for what was available at a specific time in our nations history and what they sold for.

The singular numbers stamped on the leather normally represent ideal barrel length for the holster in question. The 38 is obviously the caliber in this case of the revolver. If there was a manufactures stamp on the holster the value would skyrocket. Example ; Denver, San Antonio Texas, or even San Francisco. Collectors of leather go nuts for that stuff.
Notice also that yours has stitching repairs? Just helps to prove it's old!
I would say it's very likely that it's been with that Smith a long time and should remain with the piece for historical preservation. It does help value but not a ton. You mentioned Pinkerton? If you have any documents to prove that it would increase value considerably but two things are wrong with that? I don't think the Pinkertons were still called Pinkertons when this Gun was manufactured. Plus agency's are usually stamped on the holster and very often on the firearm also. I have a few AM. EX. CO. ( American Express) Smith's That factory Letter and they are stamped on the backstrap and some on the side plate. Collectors call it Provenence(Proof) otherwise it's just another interesting story.
 
Last edited:
Here are some agency marked holsters. Notice also that they tend to be a plain design of heavy/ thick leather.
 

Attachments

  • 3A5FE4CE-02B1-4859-9DD2-980B51FA9335.jpeg
    3A5FE4CE-02B1-4859-9DD2-980B51FA9335.jpeg
    82.8 KB · Views: 24
  • 616D3528-4086-4BF6-B489-6EDCC77096EE.jpeg
    616D3528-4086-4BF6-B489-6EDCC77096EE.jpeg
    92.3 KB · Views: 31
Here are some agency marked holsters. Notice also that they tend to be a plain design of heavy/ thick leather.

You may have already looked, but eBay had this, and others for sale. Gives you an idea of the value of JUST the holster.
Le

Original Vintage Railway Express Agency Pistol Holster Small 4" Barrel Revolver
Pre-Owned
$130.00
 
Back
Top