Pinkerton Man

OLDNAVYMCPO

US Veteran, Absent Comrade
Joined
Jun 13, 2014
Messages
1,068
Reaction score
7,404
Location
EL Paso, Tx
Charlie Angelo Siringo, born 07 Feb 1855 in Matagorda County, Texas came to be called " The Cowboy Detective". Born to an Irish mother and an Italian father, Charlie spent his formative years as a working cowboy on local ranches. If you have ever been on horseback in Matagorda County, you know it is absolutely the toughest, most impossible, continuous mesquite thicket in which to try and work cattle. Brush popping at its worst.

After making a number of cattle drives, Charlie settled in Caldwell, Kansas, married and wrote a book on life as a Texas Cowboy. A year later it was published and won great acclaim.

Bored, he went to work as a stock detective. In Feb 1881, Cowboy Detective Charlie Siringo was assigned to a case involving cattle rustling from some major ranches in the panhandle of Texas. The cattle thief was none other than Billy the Kid. After the Lincoln County Wars, Billy who had always dabbled in cattle rustling, joined into a working relationship with Pat Coghlan, owner of the Three Rivers Ranch in the Tularosa Valley of NM (north of present day Alamogordo). Coghlan had the contract to supply beef to Fort Stanton. Rather than use his beef, he bought stolen beef from Billy.

Billy the Kid would steal cattle or horses in Arizona, drive them to the Texas panhandle where he would sell them. Steal cattle there and drive them to NM's Tularosa basin and sell them to Pat Coghlan. Charlie Siringo trailed the herd and found five fresh hides in Coghlan's butcheryard wearing the LX brand. He confronted Pat Coghlan with the evidence. At first Pat bowed up and refused to return the stolen cattle. Charlie had backup just north at White Oaks. They came to an agreement, Pat promised not to butcher anymore cattle and to help roundup the remainder in the spring when the grass was fresh.

Pat reneged on the deal, Charlie caught his men butchering more LX cattle. Seringo and his men rode into Coghlan's ranch but only found 8 head of LX cattle. Charlie had sufficient evidence to send Pat to the Pen. Charlie contacted the deputy US Marshall at Roswell, John Poe, and Pat was arrested. Pat whined and begged for mercy, even tried to bribe Poe but he was unrelenting. Coghlan was indicted by a grand jury in Mesilla. He eventually bribed the prosecuting attorney and got free. He was, however sued by the big ranches and paid restitution.

In 1886, Siringo moved to Chicago and went to work for the Pinkerton National Detective Agency. Charlie worked undercover and joined gangs and outlaw bands as part of his job. At one point in his career, he worked with assassin Tom Horn. Horn was an agency hired gun at the time. His undercover work led to hundreds of arrests. He and Horn worked together to infiltrate the Butch Cassidy gang.

Several members of the Wild Bunch were captured as a result of Charlie's efforts. Most noted of which was Kid Curry who was tracked down and killed in a shootout in Colorado. Butch and The Sundance Kid both fled to Bolivia.

In 1907, Charlie Siringo retired from the Pinkertons to continue his writing.

In 1916, Siringo became a NM Ranger and pursued rustlers until 1918 when he retired because of failing health. He continued to write and ranch, he died in 1928.
 
Register to hide this ad
How strange it is that you posted this, I was just thinking about Charlie Siringo today. I have read much about Siringo and admired him, he was something of a lawman.

The wife and I are fixin to travel to Matagorda to spend some time there, and knowing he was from there, I was reading more about him today.

Thanks for posting.
 
I like the story and it makes it better since I've been to all the places mentioned.
 
OLDNAVYMCPO, thanks. You're quite right about that brush around Matagorda, Indianola and the Powderhorn. Siringos legend certainly comes up around the campfire. Matter of fact, the first good norther will be coming soon- that'll get it started.
 
Pinkerton Agency exist today as Pinkerton Corporate Risk Management, a private security firm. Charlie Siringo enjoyed a strange working relationship with the Pinkertons. They tried to suppress his books because they felt he exposed corp secrets on methods. They tried and tried, thru all kinds of legal maneuvers to get him to write fictional accounts of his activities, but Charlie refused.
 
Great thread. I bought this 1911 made Colt .45 that was originally a 32-20. It came with the 1969 Colt invoice for rebuilding and caliber change. The price reflected the lack of originality. The seller said he got it from the original family and that they said it had a "Pinkerton connection" in Nevada, whatever that means. Might be a good one to letter. There's just something historically cool about "Pinkerton".

 
A friend of mine sent this email this morning...

'Walking out of the VA hospital in Prescott yesterday and managed to get turned around.

Old guy asks if he can help and was going to the same parking lot.

We got talking and when we parted I introduced myself: "my name is ___ _____"

He took my hand and said "I'm Charlie Siringo."

At which point I said something bright like "No ****?"

He grinned and told me , "No! Not that one."

Further discussion turned out he isn't, yo his knowledge, related to the original.

Anyhow, kinda cool, even if it doesn't mean anything.'


That is a kewl name to have. BTW... I know an insurance man who's name is Jesse James.... really.
 
In Siringo`s book he said he got his start by attending some kind of lecture given by a ??????? that could tell by feeling the bumps on his head that he should be a detective! Then Charlie sought out that type work!
Sorry, I am too lazy to dig out and dust off the book to get the name right of what they called that "profession".
 
Thank you Master Chief an if you ever turn these into a book? id like a few signed copies. My Bro in Law and Sis, and three Nephews and a friend in England--would love these.
 
In Siringo`s book he said he got his start by attending some kind of lecture given by a ??????? that could tell by feeling the bumps on his head that he should be a detective! Then Charlie sought out that type work!
Sorry, I am too lazy to dig out and dust off the book to get the name right of what they called that "profession".

Phrenologist.
 
I've read all of Siringo's books and several others about him.

OLDNAVYMCPO's information is accurate. What might be added is that Siringo left the Pinkerton agency with a lot of hard feelings, and fought with them for years over publication of his books and other writings, which bankrupted him. Eventually Siringo lost his little ranch at Santa Fe, NM, and ended up living in a cottage owned by his estranged son in Los Angeles where he continued writing, but lived mostly on the generosity of old friends.

The Pinkerton National Detective Agency operated during the time before there was any form of national law enforcement agency (US Marshals were primarily officers of the federal courts, although having some LE responsibilities in pre-statehood territories). Pinkerton operatives were generally paid fees for actual days worked plus necessary expenses, rather than set salaries. Major customers were the railroads, banks, insurance companies, and wealthier people. Siringo's assignments included livestock, bank robberies, train robberies, mining frauds, embezzlements, and a considerable amount of work in labor disputes (notably the Cor D'Alene <spelling?> debacles.

As one of his biographers has noted, there are many discrepancies in Siringo's various accounts in different books and articles written about the same incidents. Some of that can be attributed to his being forced to limit his writings about his time with the Pinkerton agency, but much can also be seen as pretty self-serving, especially in his later years when finances were difficult for him.

Siringo was known to have carried a Colt Single Action Army .45 revolver, silver plated, in what he called a "J.W. Hardin" holster rig (shoulder holster similar to that used by John Wesley Hardin, the infamous Texas gunman), along with a Bowie knife. By his own accounts he never had to use "old Colt's .45" on a human target. Also, by his own accounts, the "old Colt's .45" was frequently in a pawn shop so that he could support his wife and young daughter.

His wife passed away at a young age, Siringo sent his daughter to be raised by relatives, and they never had much of a close relationship. He remarried at least once (which was quite brief), and also had a son with whom he never had a close relationship.

A lot of disappointment and sadness can be sensed in much of his later writing.

Interesting character living during interesting times.
 
Back
Top