Post Your Very First 5-Screw S&W

I picked up my first five-screw from a forum member a dozen years ago -- a K-22 Masterpiece shipped January 1948, serial number K14784. Since all my photos are currently in turmoil, I can't offer an image right now -- but that's a close-up of the revolver's right front frame area up there in my avatar.
 
Last edited:
My first 5-screw

I only have two, but here's my first. It's a 1955 Pre-Chiefs that I rescued from my LGS for a surprisingly low price. The stags are from bigmtnman. My other one is a mid 1941 M&P 38.
 

Attachments

  • B1D91E0B-51A6-4334-A87C-629072E8157B.jpg
    B1D91E0B-51A6-4334-A87C-629072E8157B.jpg
    99.5 KB · Views: 30
  • 9BD8A8B4-A4C9-4753-93F4-A56E08A51CD6.jpg
    9BD8A8B4-A4C9-4753-93F4-A56E08A51CD6.jpg
    93 KB · Views: 27
  • 99350112-499A-42BA-91D3-4E0648244B9A.jpg
    99350112-499A-42BA-91D3-4E0648244B9A.jpg
    110.3 KB · Views: 29
This post war m&p someone thought fit to slap a heavy barrel on, made it out of the country and back at some point. Ugly as sin but the action is unrivaled in its smoothness....
20200110-111528.jpg
 
I can't believe this is the first time I've seen this, but so be it. Okay----well, no picture, and no gun either----gone along with almost all the rest of them. David called a couple of days ago, and we compared notes. I said there were nine left, he said seven. He figured Brewster had the missing two, and I haven't heard different; so the mystery must be solved---or close enough.

It's a long time ago. I'm either between my freshman and sophomore year of college----or sophomore and junior. I live in St.Louis. I have a lady friend who lives in Tennessee-----about 50 miles from Georgia----right where we live now. But what's most important then is you could buy a handgun in Georgia as soon as you're 18 years old. I qualify.

So it's off to Georgia---or rather Tennessee to visit my lady friend---and meet her parents----oh, and maybe take a side trip to Georgia. Speaking of side trips, we---she and I took another side trip later on-------on our honeymoon (June, 1959)--600 miles out of our way to visit with Herbie Harris in Chicago---and pick up one of those odd ball "pre-war-post-war" .32 Regulation Police Target guns. Herbie had called a few weeks earlier---said, "You call yourself a collector of S&W target guns, I got one you have to have." That's all it took!

So anyway, I found Tennessee, and we found Georgia, and we found this hardware store in Dalton, and they had S&W handguns, brand new in the boxes, stacked up higher than you could reach---no lie, higher than you could reach----in a hardware store---in Dalton, Georgia!! And they had K-22's---and pretty much anything else, but a K-22 is what I'd been dreaming about.

There was one problem---they had them with that funky "satin blue", and I wanted one with "bright blue". That wasn't really the problem, because I could have one of those "bright blue" ones----in about six months, is what they said---to this kid--------you'd think they'd know better.

So off we went with a "satin blue" K-22----back to Tennessee---where I got my clock cleaned by her daddy in a little shooting match. And then back to St. Louis.

Once there I packed up that gun, and shipped it off to Springfield. I asked them to put the "bright blue" finish on it----and to go through it and make it as perfect as can be. It was back in St. Louis in nothing flat----a few weeks. So much for having to wait six months.

It took a long time before I figured out what they'd done to "make it as perfect as can be", but one day I noticed it didn't have one of those dreaded "turn rings" on it. Actually, it did, but it was only about 3/32" long---at the lead into each cylinder stop notch---and this was after it'd had about a half a box car full of ammo run through it. I remember telling Jinks about that one time. He scowled, and said "They never should have done that----it'll skip chambers in rapid double action fire." I didn't have the heart to tell him about half of that half a box car full of ammo was used in rapid double action fire, and it never missed a beat. I didn't tell him that because then I'd have to tell him I never did get to be as fast as McGivern.

My Tennessee Lady friend didn't care for that K-22---too "klunky" she said. She has a 4" Kit gun----and she's keeping it.

Ralph Tremaine
 
I can't remember my first 5-screw Smith I bought, since I've been collecting S&W's for almost 40 years. I'll go out on a limb and assume it was one of the many early K-frame .38's I've bought over the years. One of my favorite old 5-screws is a old, beat up P.D. marked 2 inch pre-Model 10, C-26710. It's been carried by someone a lot years ago (the right grip panel is worn almost smooth). I wish she could talk...It probably has a interesting history.
 
Last edited:
Just got this one. S174xxx. I have a set of Jordan troopers ordered.
 

Attachments

  • 068CE85A-188D-43DF-B22F-5EE16A641A7E.jpg
    068CE85A-188D-43DF-B22F-5EE16A641A7E.jpg
    75.6 KB · Views: 39
  • D00EB26B-5BB6-409B-B592-C8AD98F42DE0.jpg
    D00EB26B-5BB6-409B-B592-C8AD98F42DE0.jpg
    120.4 KB · Views: 32

My Grandfather, father of my Dad was born in Hungary in 1900 and emigrated to the United States as a teenager. This was the only handgun he ever owned and in June of 1990, he gave this to me as a graduation gift -- perhaps mostly because of his five grandchildren, I was the only one that was really a dyed-in-the-wool gun guy. (as it happens, I am the youngest of those five)

He was 90 on that day that he gave it to me and of course, I asked him what he knew and remembered about it. He was pretty sure that he bought it in Fairmont, WV in 1923 and I want to say that he told me he paid $25 for it, but I'm not sure about that bit.

I asked him why he bought it (as he wasn't much of a gun guy at any point) and his answer was simple and this part I do remember as if it was yesterday... He said "well in those days, a man had a gun, you see?"

In 1999 it came to my knowledge that you could write to S&W and ask for information on an old gun, so I did that, and I sent along the $35 that it cost at that time. To this day, it is the only gun that I have ever gotten a factory letter on.

Roy Jinks replied that this revolver, SN 3572xx was a S&W Military & Police Model of 1905 Fourth Change and was shipped from the factory on May 31, 1921 and delivered to Emmons Hawkins Hardware Co, Huntington, WV. The nickel finish is original but of course the genuine mother of pearl is not, it was shipped with checkered walnut.

It was reassuring that the memory my Grandfather had of where and when he bought seems to line up with the letter. I'm left to wonder if my Grandfather purchased it used with the MOP grips on it or if it was old stock and still "new" and if perhaps he bought the MOP to put on there.

His memory of Fairmont could be accurate and the revolver would likely have made the trip across West Virginia by it's first owner.
 
I had to consult my gun spreadsheet to answer this question. Then went back through my post history. The crazy thing is that while I did have a few S&Ws before I came across this thing, the first actual 5 screw I ever bought is my $150 beater Registered Magnum:





I snapped a few shots of it wearing some good looking but (when I bought them) dinked up Ropers, on a bed of good Montana River Rock. Which, when they arrived in my hands were so warped they were unusable. After years of tightening down the screw on them once in a while on a gun, they eventually seem to be back in shape. They fit my hand great.

I honestly wanted a set of appropriately messed up and worn Ropers (or Kearsarge) for this gun, but I have never been able to find a set that fit my hand right, and are properly worn. I've found some that feel ok-ish, but are very abused. They don't work as well for shooting the gun as this set does.

So the other day I decided something. I thought; 'Why not just put the stocks on it that *I* like to shoot it with, even if they are "too good" for this gun'.

So here they will stay. Only being supplanted if I happen across another, more worn, set that fits my hand as nicely.

I do feel a bit sheepish about this being my first 5 screw, considering it was nearly a decade before I was able to acquire another pre-war .357 magnum, and I know some guys have yet to find one to call their own. I really thought that I had owned at least one 5 screw before this gun, but not according to my records. Heaven knows I have owned a *lot* more 5 screws since then...
 
I bought my first 5 screw in 1960 and only kept it for a couple of years and sent it down the road. I don't know what it was other than a .44 Special. magna grips, shrouded ejector rod and a 4 or 5 in. barrel.
After that I had a 2 in. .38 Special, 6 shot with a round butt and half moon front sight. Kept it for a little while and sent it down the road.
Since I was poor I had to sell something to get something else. I'm pretty sure that I got the worth of them when sold and if I had kept them they would be beat up and wore out by now and not be worth much. Larry
 

Latest posts

Back
Top