RM Vivas
US Veteran
Project NOVEMBERFRAME
I have many research projects going on right now and they are really making me into a much more rounded individual when it comes to Smith & Wesson firearms.
I may have very little interest in Model 19’s or in New Departures’, but as I wander through the archives I pick things up and while I may not be a Subject Matter Expert (SME) on those guns, I am developing a knowledge base that will let me speak more to them than I might otherwise have.
A downside to this cornucopia of archived information is that it is very easy to get distracted from one project and on to another. I am guilty of this and have several projects running at once.
I am going to try and focus on the two or three that I think are most important, both to myself and the SWHF and the collecting community in general. The two that I’m thinking on focusing on are this Pre-war N-Frame project (NOVEMBERFRAME) and my attempt to document all the Defense Supplies Corporation sales project (DISCUS38). I think these two will have the broadest reach within the collecting sphere; the Pre-war N-Frames because they encompass some iconic and groundbreaking models and the Victory data because they were so plentiful and are widely collected.
Up until now I have posted about the various projects in different threads and on different boards and I think the time has come to try and better organize things.
I am going to give each research project a weird name that does not usually come up on the web site search feature. This way, if I want to see if someone is referring to my project or using it in a post, I can search for that unique name and see where it is and follow along.
I am going to post a single thread that will detail my project and try to limit my mentions of findings and the like to that thread only.
There are three S&W forums that I post to and, generally, I will post the same to all three threads. I may post a more detailed entry on the Smith & Wesson Collectors Association (SWCA) forum because some information will be from sources proprietary to them.
I’ll be posting to:
https://smith-wessonforum.com/
https://www.smithandwessonforums.com/
https://forum.theswca.org/ (Private Forum for SWCA members)
Project NOVEMBERFRAME
The goal of this project is to produce an enhanced accounting of all Pre-war N-frames from s/n 1 through approx. s/n 62,500. The statements that I make here are specific to the N-frame pre-war records only.
Currently these guns are recorded using seven data fields:
The model of gun is usually, but not always, listed but with a distinct lack of specificity; for instance, .38/44 could mean either a Heavy Duty, an Outdoorsman or even the seldom seen McGivern Target Model.
The same can be said for .44 Military Revolver, which could be a 1st or 2nd Model .44 Hand Ejector (HE) or a 3rd Model .44 HE a.k.a. a Model 1926.
A typical entry might look like this:
S/N Case No. Model Date Recipient City State
1234 567 38/44 2/1/36 Joe Blow Guns Brooklyn NY
Now, it is important to understand that currently all the serial data is in the form of microfilmed images of ledger books that have been scanned and saved as images. There are no searchable features and no way to find a specific gun or destination or date except by eyeballing the microfilmed records. The only order they are in is serial number order; you cannot search for any other data point except by sitting down and reading every page (which I enjoy). There are 100 entries per page, so for my purposes I am looking at approximately 625 pages.
My goal is to take all the entries and enter them into a database that will allow me to search by all seven data fields. On the face of it, this is relatively simple and straightforward. However, the lack of specificity in the records as to Model presents a quandary.
Let us say I want to compare how many Outdoorsman’s shipped in 1936 versus how many Registered Magnums shipped at the same time. If I have the database done, I can simply do a count of 1936 shipped Registered Magnums and come up with a figure; however, I can’t come up with a figure on Outdoorsman’s in the same manner because Outdoorsman’s and Heavy Duty and McGivern Target are all lumped under the single classification of 38/44.
So how does one fix this?
In addition to the microfilmed shipping ledger that contains the original data points, there is a limited amount of microfilmed shipping invoices. These run from December 1925 up through around 1947.
These ledgers are in chronological order but that’s about it. What I do is look at an entry like the one shown above. Ship date was 2/1/36. I pull up the digitized roll of microfilm that covers 10/25/35 through 4/12/36 (Roll 83) which is 1,994 pages (images) long and scroll through until I hit the first entry for 2/1/36. Then I scroll through the rest of the 2/1/36 entries until I find the one for Joe Blow Gunshop on page 1,234. The entry shows a single gun shipment labelled as a .38-44 Heavy Duty B 5” (.38/44 Heavy Duty Blued w/ 5.000” barrel).
I’ll make the notation in the database so now the entry will read:
S/N Case No. Model Date Recipient City State Notes Source
1234 567 38/44 2/1/36 Joe Blow Guns Brooklyn NY HD; B; 5.000” R83/1234
R83/1234 is a note so that whoever follows me knows the source of information for this entry was Microfilm Roll 83 Page/Frame 1234.
Now I have more searchable data fields. How many Heavy Duty’s were shipped in 1940? How many in nickel? How many to Wolf & Klar? What is the earliest N-frame s/n for 1940? What is the latest for 1940? How many McGivern Target Models were made and where were they shipped?
The ability to quickly and accurately answer those questions is the impetus for this project.
There are still some kinks to be worked out. For example, if the Joe Blow Gunshop ordered two guns, both labelled in the shipping ledger as 38/44 but the invoice says one was an Outdoorsman’s and the other an HD, unless they also list serial numbers (seldom) there is no way of knowing which serial number goes to which gun. In that instance I’ll tag the entry as an Either/Or (Schroedinger's Gun?) sort of thing and hope to find some more data later. One possibility is to take the serial numbers and run them through the Correspondence and Repair files and see if a few years later someone wrote a letter saying they were sending in their ”…Outdoorsman #xxxxx for repair…”.
A marvelous side benefit to this project is I get to look at a couple hundred invoices every day in searching out the subject N-frames and while doing so, I come across all manner of interesting things. One very valuable thing I have come across is shipping invoices that contain serial numbers for guns that appear on the invoice as going to the Acme Gun Shop or Podunk Police but appear in the shipping ledger as Open On Books. I anticipate getting at least some of these Open On Book entries resolved.
Part of this thread will be to highlight what I find in my travels, both in terms of actual guns and background things that one never really considered. For example, I found a number of invoices where S&W was taking in Colt revolvers from dealers at $5 and then disposing of them through their sales agents. Some familiar names turn up, especially people who ordered Outdoorsman’s revolvers and then their names appear multiple times in the Registered Magnum records. I guess these were the folks who developed a taste for hot .38’s in an N-frame with target sights and became the ‘early adopters’ of the Registered Magnum (Dr. Wishart and Dr. Hertzel spring to mind).
Also, as a way of keeping me motivated, I’ll be chronicling the progress I’ve been making. Right now I have about 2,500 entries complete but they are spread across a very wide range of serial numbers and dates. My immediate short-term goal is to complete a solid block of 1,000 serial numbers and then statistically dissect that and see what comes up. The block I am looking at is 44,000 through 45,000. At the moment I have perhaps half of it done and I have found some interesting things, such as a half dozen or so McGivern Target Models, a few famous people guns, some odd destinations and some interesting trends, particularly amongst export orders.
I figure in another week or so I -should- have the sample 1,000 entries done and once that happens I’ll nerd-out on a statistical kick and see if my theories are sound. I suspect they are.
Getting all 62,500 entries done will take probably a couple years. It’s hard to say. Entries from before the start date of December 1925 for invoices go in fairly quickly since I can’t cross reference them with the shipping invoices. Also, they will be almost all some variation of the .44HE since the HD and Outdoorsman’s didn’t come out until the early 1930’s
So, there you have it. I’ll try to keep everyone updated.
Best,
RM Vivas
I have many research projects going on right now and they are really making me into a much more rounded individual when it comes to Smith & Wesson firearms.
I may have very little interest in Model 19’s or in New Departures’, but as I wander through the archives I pick things up and while I may not be a Subject Matter Expert (SME) on those guns, I am developing a knowledge base that will let me speak more to them than I might otherwise have.
A downside to this cornucopia of archived information is that it is very easy to get distracted from one project and on to another. I am guilty of this and have several projects running at once.
I am going to try and focus on the two or three that I think are most important, both to myself and the SWHF and the collecting community in general. The two that I’m thinking on focusing on are this Pre-war N-Frame project (NOVEMBERFRAME) and my attempt to document all the Defense Supplies Corporation sales project (DISCUS38). I think these two will have the broadest reach within the collecting sphere; the Pre-war N-Frames because they encompass some iconic and groundbreaking models and the Victory data because they were so plentiful and are widely collected.
Up until now I have posted about the various projects in different threads and on different boards and I think the time has come to try and better organize things.
I am going to give each research project a weird name that does not usually come up on the web site search feature. This way, if I want to see if someone is referring to my project or using it in a post, I can search for that unique name and see where it is and follow along.
I am going to post a single thread that will detail my project and try to limit my mentions of findings and the like to that thread only.
There are three S&W forums that I post to and, generally, I will post the same to all three threads. I may post a more detailed entry on the Smith & Wesson Collectors Association (SWCA) forum because some information will be from sources proprietary to them.
I’ll be posting to:
https://smith-wessonforum.com/
https://www.smithandwessonforums.com/
https://forum.theswca.org/ (Private Forum for SWCA members)
Project NOVEMBERFRAME
The goal of this project is to produce an enhanced accounting of all Pre-war N-frames from s/n 1 through approx. s/n 62,500. The statements that I make here are specific to the N-frame pre-war records only.
Currently these guns are recorded using seven data fields:
- Serial No.
- Case No.
- Model (or Registration number if Registered Magnum)
- Ship Date
- Recipient
- City
- State
The model of gun is usually, but not always, listed but with a distinct lack of specificity; for instance, .38/44 could mean either a Heavy Duty, an Outdoorsman or even the seldom seen McGivern Target Model.
The same can be said for .44 Military Revolver, which could be a 1st or 2nd Model .44 Hand Ejector (HE) or a 3rd Model .44 HE a.k.a. a Model 1926.
A typical entry might look like this:
S/N Case No. Model Date Recipient City State
1234 567 38/44 2/1/36 Joe Blow Guns Brooklyn NY
Now, it is important to understand that currently all the serial data is in the form of microfilmed images of ledger books that have been scanned and saved as images. There are no searchable features and no way to find a specific gun or destination or date except by eyeballing the microfilmed records. The only order they are in is serial number order; you cannot search for any other data point except by sitting down and reading every page (which I enjoy). There are 100 entries per page, so for my purposes I am looking at approximately 625 pages.
My goal is to take all the entries and enter them into a database that will allow me to search by all seven data fields. On the face of it, this is relatively simple and straightforward. However, the lack of specificity in the records as to Model presents a quandary.
Let us say I want to compare how many Outdoorsman’s shipped in 1936 versus how many Registered Magnums shipped at the same time. If I have the database done, I can simply do a count of 1936 shipped Registered Magnums and come up with a figure; however, I can’t come up with a figure on Outdoorsman’s in the same manner because Outdoorsman’s and Heavy Duty and McGivern Target are all lumped under the single classification of 38/44.
So how does one fix this?
In addition to the microfilmed shipping ledger that contains the original data points, there is a limited amount of microfilmed shipping invoices. These run from December 1925 up through around 1947.
These ledgers are in chronological order but that’s about it. What I do is look at an entry like the one shown above. Ship date was 2/1/36. I pull up the digitized roll of microfilm that covers 10/25/35 through 4/12/36 (Roll 83) which is 1,994 pages (images) long and scroll through until I hit the first entry for 2/1/36. Then I scroll through the rest of the 2/1/36 entries until I find the one for Joe Blow Gunshop on page 1,234. The entry shows a single gun shipment labelled as a .38-44 Heavy Duty B 5” (.38/44 Heavy Duty Blued w/ 5.000” barrel).
I’ll make the notation in the database so now the entry will read:
S/N Case No. Model Date Recipient City State Notes Source
1234 567 38/44 2/1/36 Joe Blow Guns Brooklyn NY HD; B; 5.000” R83/1234
R83/1234 is a note so that whoever follows me knows the source of information for this entry was Microfilm Roll 83 Page/Frame 1234.
Now I have more searchable data fields. How many Heavy Duty’s were shipped in 1940? How many in nickel? How many to Wolf & Klar? What is the earliest N-frame s/n for 1940? What is the latest for 1940? How many McGivern Target Models were made and where were they shipped?
The ability to quickly and accurately answer those questions is the impetus for this project.
There are still some kinks to be worked out. For example, if the Joe Blow Gunshop ordered two guns, both labelled in the shipping ledger as 38/44 but the invoice says one was an Outdoorsman’s and the other an HD, unless they also list serial numbers (seldom) there is no way of knowing which serial number goes to which gun. In that instance I’ll tag the entry as an Either/Or (Schroedinger's Gun?) sort of thing and hope to find some more data later. One possibility is to take the serial numbers and run them through the Correspondence and Repair files and see if a few years later someone wrote a letter saying they were sending in their ”…Outdoorsman #xxxxx for repair…”.
A marvelous side benefit to this project is I get to look at a couple hundred invoices every day in searching out the subject N-frames and while doing so, I come across all manner of interesting things. One very valuable thing I have come across is shipping invoices that contain serial numbers for guns that appear on the invoice as going to the Acme Gun Shop or Podunk Police but appear in the shipping ledger as Open On Books. I anticipate getting at least some of these Open On Book entries resolved.
Part of this thread will be to highlight what I find in my travels, both in terms of actual guns and background things that one never really considered. For example, I found a number of invoices where S&W was taking in Colt revolvers from dealers at $5 and then disposing of them through their sales agents. Some familiar names turn up, especially people who ordered Outdoorsman’s revolvers and then their names appear multiple times in the Registered Magnum records. I guess these were the folks who developed a taste for hot .38’s in an N-frame with target sights and became the ‘early adopters’ of the Registered Magnum (Dr. Wishart and Dr. Hertzel spring to mind).
Also, as a way of keeping me motivated, I’ll be chronicling the progress I’ve been making. Right now I have about 2,500 entries complete but they are spread across a very wide range of serial numbers and dates. My immediate short-term goal is to complete a solid block of 1,000 serial numbers and then statistically dissect that and see what comes up. The block I am looking at is 44,000 through 45,000. At the moment I have perhaps half of it done and I have found some interesting things, such as a half dozen or so McGivern Target Models, a few famous people guns, some odd destinations and some interesting trends, particularly amongst export orders.
I figure in another week or so I -should- have the sample 1,000 entries done and once that happens I’ll nerd-out on a statistical kick and see if my theories are sound. I suspect they are.
Getting all 62,500 entries done will take probably a couple years. It’s hard to say. Entries from before the start date of December 1925 for invoices go in fairly quickly since I can’t cross reference them with the shipping invoices. Also, they will be almost all some variation of the .44HE since the HD and Outdoorsman’s didn’t come out until the early 1930’s
So, there you have it. I’ll try to keep everyone updated.
Best,
RM Vivas







