Question for anyone with a Simply Rugged Sourdough Pancake

[AKAOV1MAN]

I carry my 3" 625 in an SR. It holds the gun VERY well. But I did order the strap and I use it, but I am a cop, not only that I am like Inspector Cluseau(Cluso?), I suspect everyone, trust no one-looked in the mirror this morning and thought I looked shifty.
If you are not in a situation where you are unlikely to be in a struggle over a gun grab, the no strap is fine. On the other hand, like those guys in the DeNiro movie about Vegas, "why take a chance".

 

[6pack]

I recenly picked up a 2.5" Model 66 and I am trying to figure out which holster to go with. I like the looks of the Simply Rugged Sourdough Pancake and it has gotten very good reviews. I plan on ordering the IWB straps just in case I want to try and carry that way.

My question is about the hammer strap and if I should order it or not. From pictures it looks like the gun sits in the holster fairly secure and the strap really would not be needed. I would like to hear opinions of those who have the strap and those that don't.

Any info is greatly appreciated!

Thanks,

Person

I recently ordered two of these and couldn't be more happy. I opted not to have straps. Both guns are N frames...a 4" & 8 3/8" and they sit down in the holsters nicely. I have no fear of one slipping out a bit. I love the nice high coverage of these.

 

[Sparrowbird]

Every holster I own has a strap except my SR. With that I don't see the need.

 

[kensnra]

I have one for my 696 and it works fine, plenty secure w/o safety strap. Did order the IWB straps and they work fine also. The only thing that I'm learning is to holster my revolver with one hand. I have to start the barrel & when I get to the cylinder make a twisting motion and then it slides on in. Really not much trouble to do.

 

[H Richard]

Surprised that no pictures have been posted t actually show how the pancake retains the gun. Here's mine, with my Pre-27 in it. The way the holster covers the gun it is nearly impossible for the gun to "accidentally" fall out. I am well satisfied with mine.

 

[Steve_NEPhila]

I think the best way to address this question of straps or not is from a real expert holster maker. Rob Leahy, the holster maker and proprietor of Simply Rugged states;

"I do not encourage the Hammer Strap for general carry. If you sky dive, fly high G acrobatics or ride motorcycles inside a metal cage,THEN you might need a hammer strap. My holsters are designed and built to retain your pistol when worn on a proper belt without a mechanical latch or strap."

Citation of page: Leather gun holster, concealed carry holster - Simply Rugged Holsters? - Proudly made in the USA
(just below the pictures)

I have three sourdough pancakes, none have the straps. I see no need for them since I gave up motorcycle cage riding weeks ago.

 

[Sistema1927]

Two SR Sourdough Pancakes and one SR Long Hunter, and none of them have, or need, retention straps.

Rob's holsters are the best on the market.

 

[Person]

Mine was shipped yesterday so I am crossing my fingers it gets here tomorrow. If not it will be Tuesday because of the holiday.

 

[6pack]

Three SR pancakes, none of them have a strap and none of them need a strap. The only way a pistol would fall out is if someone held me upside down and shook me hard.

I completely agree. Very secure hold on my N-frames in mine.

I'll keep buying these.