Recommend a .44 magnum

OK, 1gunlover61 did a post and run, but I have benefitted from the discussion and got to post photos of my model 69 some more.

I just love the look, feel, balance, and carry ability of the 69. The 629 with the 8 inch barrel was great for hunting and range shooting, much less perceived recoil, but in my opinion the 4" 69 gives much more "bang" for the buck.

My 360PD AirLite has more recoil when firing .357s than the 69. I can't imagine what a 629 lightweight .44 must be like.

digiroc
 
Last edited:
The 10 5/8" 29s are good standing shooters. Probably less front heavy than the 8 3/8" Classic barreled guns

How is that possible?
 
A SS 629 is all I use these days. No optics and no longer barrel than the 6". Its the most balanced and effective hunting handgun when it comes to weight, portability, knockdown power and accuracy. I hunted all over the country with larger handguns and calibers like the 454 but have since come back to the good old 44mag and its putting them down just as hard and as far a distance.






 
Last edited:
I understand what you're saying about "so I can say I have one". I bought a "classic" 29 6 1/2 inch a few years ago because I always wanted a Dirty Harry gun when I was a kid. Shooting full power loads are painful and I plan on switching out the "issue" grips that came with it to something with more heft. My only other .44 is an AutoMag.
 
I hunted all over the country with larger handguns and calibers like the 454 but have since come back to the good old 44mag and its putting them down just as hard and as far a distance.
That's a fine shot. My 8" 629-2 shoots plenty accurate at 175 yards. I tested it at the gun range and that was about as far as I could shoot accurately without using a rest. I did lean against a post. But at that distance it would have been a good shot on a whitetail. And that's with off the shelf Hornady LEVERevoltion.
 
A SS 629 is all I use these days. No optics and no longer barrel than the 6". Its the most balanced and effective hunting handgun when it comes to weight, portability, knockdown power and accuracy. I hunted all over the country with larger handguns and calibers like the 454 but have since come back to the good old 44mag and its putting them down just as hard and as far a distance.







Hellva shot, once again it shows that a 44 Magnum in the skilled hands can get the job done. Thanks for sharing, and I am not a hunter.
 
Can you change grips on a M69 from rubber to wood for the 'classic look'...

considering these below:

ARMSLIST - For Sale: SMITH & WESSON 629 DELUXE .44MAG 6.5" (TALO)

ARMSLIST - For Sale: Smith & Wesson 69 L-Frame DA/SA 44 RemMag 4.25"

The M69 can be outfitted with wood grips. There are many "off the shelf" and custom makers that supply L Frame round butt grips. Even though I love the look and feel of wood grips, the recoil shoulder, or hump, on the backstrap of the double action revolver hammers the bone at the base of my thumb. My guns are equipped with the S&W X Frame 500s which solve the problem for me.

I have both of the guns you linked above. For general use, I gravitate towards the M69 – if I could only have one, it would be the M69. Shooting plates double action with the M69 is just plain fun. You can use gentle .44 specials, moderate level .44 spec/mags, or full on .44 Magnums – whatever your pleasure may be. There is a subtle but noticible difference between the M69 and the larger N Frame .44s and contrary to what some believe, recoil of the M69 is more manageable than that of an 4" N Frame, either standard bbl or Mtn Gun – lower grip to bore axis. The M69 makes a great carry gun if you needs evolve in that direction.

As you can see from the above posts, everyone has a different opinion. This is as it should be – no two individuals are the same and personal experience will dictate preference. Example: With factory grips and magnum ammo, recoil (for me) of the frequently recommended 7 ½" Ruger Super Blackhawk is downright painful. The square trigger guard of the Dragoon grip hammers my middle finger unmercifully -- and yet I can shoot full house .475 LInebaugh (420gr/1,300 fps) ammo from a 6" Freedom Arms single action (same weight as the Super Blackhawk) without any pain.

The .44 Magnum has taken every game animal on this planet (including Elephant), and while marginal on the largest of species, it is a very capable and flexible cartridge. Ammo is readily avail even in remote areas. It's basically the 30-06 of revolver cartridges – not particularly sexy, but very capable. Larger calibers/cartridges are more effect on big game but are harder to shoot well, and somewhat more expensive to feed. I enjoy my 475 Linebaugh and 500 JRH, but if I could only have one revover/cartridge, it would be in .44 magnum.

IF at all possible, you should shoot whatever guns you are interested in before you make a decision. If not possible, you can always try one and sell it if not your liking (consider the loss on sale as a rental fee). Part of the fun and probably not to much more expensive than a good meal out for a family of four.

FWIW,

Paul
 
A 10 5/8" heavy barrel vs. an 8 3/8" full underlug barrel.

Are all the 8 3/8" models full underlug? BTW I really don't have a problem holding mine and that is something I can't say for a lot of guns since my back started having problems. I don't think I'd want to do it all day though. It could be that I'm just holding on tight for the recoil of those .44 mag cartridges.
 
Last edited:
Are all the 8 3/8" models full underlug? BTW I really don't have a problem holding mine and that is something I can't say for a lot of guns since my back started having problems. I don't think I'd want to do it all day though. It could be that I'm just holding on tight for the recoil of those .44 mag cartridges.


I did specify 8 3/8" Classic
.

I don't mind shooting the long tubed Classics standing, either, but only iron sighted or with micro reddots in the conventional manner. Scoped, they get to be a bit much during all day shoots.
 
5" Smiths

Well I don't have a ton of expertise on .44 Magnum shooting, but I have found my 5" 629 Classic to be about as much as I can handle with full power loads. IMO, it's a great "if you're only going to have one" .44 Magnum as it's still a manageable carry gun in the woods while being a good range shooter as well. While some may disagree, I don't see how you can say the same for a 8-3/8" gun or a 329/629 snub. Those are neat guns but definitely don't compromise.

I spent years looking for a 5" 629-4 and found a pristine one at a gun show in Dallas last summer. I felt like I stole it.

Now I want a new 6.5" Classic for a regular shooter and will probably sell the 5" since it's worth more to other folks than it is to me.
 
Are all the 8 3/8" models full underlug? BTW I really don't have a problem holding mine and that is something I can't say for a lot of guns since my back started having problems. I don't think I'd want to do it all day though. It could be that I'm just holding on tight for the recoil of those .44 mag cartridges.

No, up until the Classic line all 8 3/8" model 29s had the untapered heavy barrel with only the ejector rod housing, which the factory refers to as "half-lug" for unclear reasons.
 
I bought a 4" model 29-10 a couple of years ago because I couldn't find a 6.5" "Dirty Harry." My friend said the 4" 29 was one of his must have's. A couple of weeks later, the gun store called and said they got a 6.5" in. I grabbed it the next morning, and my buddy bought the 4". Several months later, I saw the model 69 on the cover of American Rifleman, and I got one a few weeks later.

I actually like shooting the 69 more than the 29. To me, the recoil is about the same despite the 69 being smaller.

In terms of looks, the 4" 29 that I sold is probably the prettiest gun I've ever owned. IMO, the proportions with the 4" barrel is perfect compared to the 6.5" barrel. I kinda wish I hadn't sold it.
 
I spent years looking for a 5" 629-4 and found a pristine one at a gun show in Dallas last summer. I felt like I stole it.

Now I want a new 6.5" Classic for a regular shooter and will probably sell the 5" since it's worth more to other folks than it is to me.
The -6 6 1/2" Classics are great. It's the only one I have so I can't really speak knowledgeably about its virtues over different barrel lengths, models, configurations, but this one is sweet and a workhorse. Shoot the hell out of it. Accurate, balanced, eats up recoil, great fit and finish, can't say enough good things.
 
Back
Top