Review - Craft Holsters Cross Draw Holster w/ Light/Laser

SchemaEnigma

Member
Joined
Feb 10, 2021
Messages
255
Reaction score
307
Location
Minnesota, USA
I bought this to try a cross-draw for when I am on a long trip in my truck. I haven't used it yet on a road trip, so this review is a bit preliminary. (Works well and is reasonably comfortable in my computer chair and on short trips around town.)

Very good workmanship. Arrived sooner than promised. Looks really good.

Breaking in is a work in progress. I've done the break-in guide alcohol bit 3 times now. It's getting better, but not quite there yet. Still, it will be a keeper, I expect.

At this point, it would be 5 stars, but...

My pistol is a S&W M&P 2.0 9mm full size with a thumb safety.

Two disappointments:
1. It interferes with the magazine release button. Several times when drawing the gun, the mag ended up on the floor, and a couple of times when I just bent over while wearing the holster, it released the mag - which fell on the floor. I "fixed" this by changing the mag release from the left side to the right, but that means I have to re-learn the reloading drill. It's not "natural" to use my trigger finger to release the mag rather than my thumb.

2. Even though I told Craft Holsters my gun had the thumb safety, the holster does not allow for that at all with the retention strap. As a result, the holster will switch off the safety when holstering or drawing, and to make matters worse, the retention strap completely covers the safety so I can't even verify whether it is on or off when holstered with the strap snapped.

Neither of these will make me return the holster, but they may have prevented me from buying it in the first place, so, if this matters to you, take note.

I didn't buy this for CC, (especially with the full-sized 9mm), and that's a good thing, too, because wearing it in the 9:30 - 10:00 position for comfort while seated gives a whole new meaning to the word "printing" if I try to cover it with a shirt. It might work better had I bought it for my EZ pistol, but I still suspect it would be obvious SOMETHING was under my shirt!

Overall: 4 out of 5 stars.
 
Register to hide this ad
Sounds like a no star review to me. They do make nice holsters, but that one was wrong for the gun and wrong for you. I would have returned it in a heartbeat.
 
Dumping your mag; having to modify your pistol; issue with thumb safety and strap. Too much for me. There are too many others available. I might have contacted them and see if they could offer another option


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
I, too, would have returned the holster for either the magazine or safety issues. Certainly for both.

The holster is unsafe.
 
I appreciate everyone's comments, and I do understand what you are saying. However, …

The mag dump is no longer an issue, as I explained. Calling it "having to modify" the gun is a bit of an exaggeration; taking advantage of an option provided as standard is more like it.

Switching the mag release to the other side took 5 minutes. I do plan on seeing how that works for me during my normal range practice time. So far, my dry practice at home has shown it to be no problem; no fumbling. Since I am semi-ambidextrous, I don't expect any issue other than muscle memory. I may also switch my other pistol so they both operate the same. And after doing it once, I expect that one to take just a minute or so.

The safety thing is an annoyance and not a critical issue to me. It does not make the pistol "unsafe", unless you think the versions of this same gun without a safety are inherently unsafe as well.

As I work on increasing the flexibility of the strap it may become no issue at all (it is coming along... I had no issue with the safety today, but a sample of one day is not conclusive.)

Finding a leather holster suitable for cross-draw and that can accommodate my attached light … let's just say it cuts down the number of vendors. My first choice was not Craft Holsters, but I went that way due to cost; that is, since this is an experiment, I decided it would be foolish to spend a couple hundred or more on a holster for a carry style that just wouldn't work for me.

I may eventually buy the more expensive, more attractive, one anyway if this experiment works out. A holster in the rarely used / unused box is probably not a foreign concept to many of you!

I said in the opening this was a preliminary review. I will post back after my six week long road trip coming up later this month.
 
Rookie mistake by the maker, the pros have known to 'clear the mag button' for literally one hundred years (since the Shelton Payne Arms holster were patented for the 'new' 1911 Government pistol). No maker worth his salt makes this mistake in the 21st century, IMHO. Lots of ways to avoid pressing the mag button ranging from perimeter shaping to featuring within the holster pocket. In this case it was the change to crossdraw for the maker that apparently caused him to think, "can't be helped". Also bear in mind that all little makers today rely on plastic molds when designing and making their products; while relying on the real thing for testing EXPOSES these interface issues with buttons, safeties, triggers, slides. Send it back is my suggestion, holster makers like us are a dime a dozen but there are only a few who have enough training and time in the saddle to design their products well.
 
UPDATE:

Based SOLEY on my review, Craft Holsters contacted me to make it right. Again, I DID NOT contact them directly, or ask to send it back (although that is part of their guarantee).

They are now in the process of making me a new holster to fix the issues.

Great integrity and customer service, I'd say.
 
Back
Top