I am thinking of getting a new smaller pistol for CC in 9mm. Carry would be IWB, wearing jeans or shorts and a T shirt. Narrowed the field down to 3, Shield, Ruger SR9C, or a Glock 26. I know that some conceal better than others so I would like opinions on what to choose for this application.
Shield 9mm Or Others For CC
- Thread starter Spartan 2
- Start date
Register to hide this ad
JAREDSHS
Member
I carry the Shield in my jeans pocket-works very well.
uncleted327
Member
- Joined
- Jul 23, 2012
- Messages
- 508
- Reaction score
- 791
For year around carry I would say the G26, if you wanted something for Summer only I would add the Shield into the discussion. I've never been a big fan of the Ruger semi's. It ultimately depends on what is comfortable for you. The G26 is a little longer than the Shield, but carrying IWB it won't matter. The Shield has a longer grip but the Glock is wider and a little heavier but has a higher capacity. I would opt for the higher capacity and shorter, easier to conceal grip of the Glock personally. I carry IWB all the time and other than the really warm months don't notice the difference between the two, even when it's hot there isn't a problem with the Glock. You can also carry G19 or G17 mags for backup with the 26.
My normal EDC is a Glock 32 by the way.
My normal EDC is a Glock 32 by the way.
Last edited:
I went through a similar process and one the big factors for me choosing the Shield was price. It was significantly less the the other ones. I also liked the single stack for conceal-ability, compared to the double stacks.
uncleted327
Member
- Joined
- Jul 23, 2012
- Messages
- 508
- Reaction score
- 791
When I was trying to pick a pocket gun the concealability of a single stack was definitely the way to go, but for IWB carry I have never seen an advantage. For myself I've found the choice of holster made more of a difference than the gun.
Last edited:
CharlieSW
Member
I have both the Shield and the SR9c; my son has a G26. The major difference is that the Shield is narrower than the other two. My SR9c is a terrific pistol -- accurate, reliable and easy to shoot, but the Shield has the same characteristics and is less bulky and easier to carry (in my Crossbreed Super Tuck). Anyway, there are no bad choices in your three options -- Good Luck!
FloridaFeMan
Member
Have both a Shield and a G26. I carry IWB and the slimmer profile of my Shield makes it easier and more comfortable for me. Both are great guns however.
Would think any you listed would be fine. More depends on whether you want a single stack or a double stack for primary carry. There are pros and cons to each type and various carry situations crop up where one type may work better than the other type.
I can not imagine having only one carry piece if for nothing else in case the primary has to go in to the shop or something. So I split the difference and usually carry a double stack 45 in the form of a 30S then there are those times when a smaller/thinner piece is called for. For instance when I need to use a smart carry holster, then I choose the single stack in 45 which is also striker fired and is very similar in size and weight as the Shield. Do feel I benefit in having both types available to me to choose from.
I can not imagine having only one carry piece if for nothing else in case the primary has to go in to the shop or something. So I split the difference and usually carry a double stack 45 in the form of a 30S then there are those times when a smaller/thinner piece is called for. For instance when I need to use a smart carry holster, then I choose the single stack in 45 which is also striker fired and is very similar in size and weight as the Shield. Do feel I benefit in having both types available to me to choose from.
Thank you all so very much for your help here. Since all 3 are suited here I will visit some lgs to see what will work best. B3500 I do have an H&K P2000 & a Glock 19 Gen 4 so i could use either if need be, just wanted something smaller. Thanks again everyone.
checkmyswag
Member
Need to decide how much capacity you want/need. Im fine with 8+1 and a reload. Others arent. Interesting though because I bet a lot of double stack guys dont carry a reload but the single stack crowd does.
highaltitude
Member
If you already have a G19, I would opt for the Shield. I have both those firearms and it's an excellent combination.
checkmyswag
Member
Another +1 for the Shield is it shoots like a bigger gun than it is. Recoil isnt bad and its pretty accurate. An SR9C to me isnt a heck of a lot smaller than a Glock 19.
CatSnipah
Member
Agreed. This is my combo, as well. Only carry the G19 in cooler months, when I'm wearing more clothes. And still use my Shield a vast majority of the time, regardless. So easy to carry and conceal.
Remember...get what is most easy and comfortable for you to carry (nothing will likely be 100% cozy). If you aren't happy, you won't carry and that defeats the purpose all together.
Redlegvzv
Member
This about sums up my opinion. The Shield is a great carry gun due to its narrow profile and it is a terrific gun.
I also have a Ruger SR40c in my carry rotation but it is heavier than the Shield.
For pocket carry the Shield works for me if it is jacket weather.
mafbloggerdanny
Member
can't go wrong with either but I would say Shield is a hands down winner for CCW. Glock is just toooooo thick UNLESS you typically wear more loose fitting clothing. IMHO most "modern fit" jeans will conceal a Shield a lot better. Winter carry I guess the Glock will be no problem but the Shield is good all year round. If you live in a really warm climate you might even consider something even smaller like the BG380
ScrapmasterFlex
Member
"Shield is a hands down winner for CCW" my colleague above hit the nail squarely on the head. Look, I am no Smith and Wesson fanboy. Prior to the Shield, my first and only Smith and Wesson was the 15-22, and I bought it because it was reported to be the best of the best .22LR AR-15s, not anything to do with S&W. I bought the Shield because of the reputation and features of CCW usage , and let me say, it is quite possibly the perfect CCW pistol... I mean, I love other brands, I like other things and styles, this is just perfect.
I and you and others would quite probably be happy with several other pistols for CCW; however, I'm extremely satisfied and happy with the Shield.
I and you and others would quite probably be happy with several other pistols for CCW; however, I'm extremely satisfied and happy with the Shield.
+1
check out the holsters from OverWatch holsters if you opt for the Shield. I got the Treadstone model, and couldn't be happier. gun just disappears IWB, and you can barely feel it's there.
Beat Trash
Member
I've owned a Glock 26 since they are first introduced. It was a great gun when it was introduced. Still is. But mine is living in semi retirement, having been replaced with a Shield.
The main reason I got the Shield was because I'd be able to Front Pocket carry. If I were ONLY going to carry IWB, my G26 (or G19) would get more carry time. I shoot all three equally well and have no problem comfortably concealing either of the Glocks IWB.
I have a Sig P938 and am very pleased with it as my daily CCW. I know it is substantially more expense then the shield but the comfort (in a Remora IWB) in the hot summer months in the south is second to none. It is very accurate up to 15yds and very reliable. I just had to drop that into the discussion, I know it may be off point for some. My winter carry btw is an M&P40c (also in a Remora) and I absolutely love it!
M&Pmeister
Member
- Joined
- Aug 5, 2014
- Messages
- 166
- Reaction score
- 64
Cannot answer OP's question without knowing 2 things:
1. How comfortable do you want your CC IWB to be?
2. What sort of area do you frequent? High crime 'hoods, or glitzy 'burbs?
Yes, anything could happen anywhere, but even a full-size service pistol is a compromise, much less a CCW. So playing a bit of probability analysis before choosing what to carry is not a bad idea. I would say that's one big reason why a lot of us have more than one pistol on our EDC rotation.
1. How comfortable do you want your CC IWB to be?
2. What sort of area do you frequent? High crime 'hoods, or glitzy 'burbs?
Yes, anything could happen anywhere, but even a full-size service pistol is a compromise, much less a CCW. So playing a bit of probability analysis before choosing what to carry is not a bad idea. I would say that's one big reason why a lot of us have more than one pistol on our EDC rotation.
marathonrunner
Member
- Joined
- May 10, 2014
- Messages
- 899
- Reaction score
- 224
apex mod
If you get the shield, the apex duty carry along with the aluminum trigger is a must do modification. The stock trigger on the shield is awful. I love my shield after the mods
If you get the shield, the apex duty carry along with the aluminum trigger is a must do modification. The stock trigger on the shield is awful. I love my shield after the mods
Mine works just fine stock without modification. Maybe the OP should try the Shield and then decide for himself if it is a "must do" modification or not? I'm not trying to step on your toes here, your opinion is yours and I'm sure you feel strongly about it, but it is your opinion and not his and telling the OP that he "must" do anything to a gun he hasn't had experience with is presumptuous...like telling him he "must" use a certain holster over another. Alerting the OP that he might want to evaluate the trigger pull because some people feel it could be better is a fair thing to do, but telling him if he gets the gun it "must" be done for it to be a great gun is dead wrong.
Last edited:
marathonrunner
Member
- Joined
- May 10, 2014
- Messages
- 899
- Reaction score
- 224
shield
Well, compared to stock trigger, the apex with the aluminum is better period. The stock may shoot OK but the apex makes it more accurate. I don't think anybody can disagree on that. My comment was meant to help enhance the experience. I don't think anybody who shot a shield with the apex mod would disagree
Well, compared to stock trigger, the apex with the aluminum is better period. The stock may shoot OK but the apex makes it more accurate. I don't think anybody can disagree on that. My comment was meant to help enhance the experience. I don't think anybody who shot a shield with the apex mod would disagree
Thanks again for some valid points. As far as being comfortable I would say wearing for a couple of hours per day with minimal printing if thats what you mean. I frequent neither high crime hoods nor glitzy burbs just a average town. But I do like your idea of probability analysis and its a good point for anyone who carries. I also would suggest reading books by Massad Ayoob & Gabe Suarez which to me give some sound advice & information. As far as the apex mod I think the writer just stated that his particular trigger was not to his liking and the apex seemed like a nicer improvement that he was happy with. Of course when I first fire the shield and the trigger is not to my liking I would consider a mod to improve it but if good to go out of the gate then there would be no reason to change. Just like to end by saying when Glock came out with the Gen 4 pistols there was such an uproar about brass to the face almost every forum had posts about it. I still bought one. After 800+ rounds my Gen 4 model 19 I have never had brass to the face or any other problem with it.
Jaysq
US Veteran
I think everyone has just about kicked around all the things you asked about and you got some good advice. I would like to point out that I carry a Shield every time I leave the house, but I carry it OWB. Hanes makes a very lightweight tee in various colors that I wear tucked in and I cover it with a button type shirt, left unbuttoned and un-tucked. It is still cool enough for the hottest weather and makes all day carry pretty easy. I hardly even think about the Shield on my side.
Still only your opinion. Some will agree, some will not. Why do you think it is OK to speak for others as though your experience and preference will be the exact experience and preference of others? So it was better FOR YOU, that does not mean everyone will agree. Especially someone that is new to the Shield and needs to decide such a thing for themselves. The OP might decide the trigger is fine the way it is or he might agree with you and decide to try a trigger kit. It's great that you brought it up, but why not let the OP (and everyone else) decide what is right for him (or them)?
I can tell you definitely that not everyone agrees with you and the OP needs to form his own opinion. Any of the other guns he mentioned might feel better to him with a trigger modification as well, or, he might like them exactly the way they are.
Remember, everyone has an opinion about it, yours isn't the final word "period" as you put it.
I think all the OP or anyone else needs to know about this is that trigger modifications are available for the Shield "IF" he feels he might want or need one.
Edmo
US Veteran
The Shield and G26 are great guns and I own them both.
Some differences are: No safety on the G26 and you can get the Shield with or without a safety. I think the stock trigger on the GLOCK is better than the Shield's. The G26 is thicker, but with a good IWB holster it is as easy to carry. The G26 will accept the 15, 17, and 33 round magazines. These are really small things since I own and carry both guns.
I personally think both the Shield and G26 are both too big & heavy for pocket carry.
I don't own the Ruger, but I think it has a magazine disconnect safety which is a no-go for me.
Edmo
Some differences are: No safety on the G26 and you can get the Shield with or without a safety. I think the stock trigger on the GLOCK is better than the Shield's. The G26 is thicker, but with a good IWB holster it is as easy to carry. The G26 will accept the 15, 17, and 33 round magazines. These are really small things since I own and carry both guns.
I personally think both the Shield and G26 are both too big & heavy for pocket carry.
I don't own the Ruger, but I think it has a magazine disconnect safety which is a no-go for me.
Edmo
Similar threads
