shoot or no? 586 nickel

[sodacan]

On the recall some needed it and some didn't as my 686 never had a problem. They will still do the recall for free if yours has a problem. The only way to tell is to go out and shoot it.

The dash two's were not subject to the recall. The problem was remedied by then. BTW, that girl is no virgin. Keep shooting it and just give it some TLC as needed. Enjoy.

 

[peachhead]

I don't clean nickel guns any differently than I do anything else. Yes, I know ammonia based solvents are bad for nickel, but generally if you are not soaking your gun in it, you are not going to have an issue. Internally I like Hoppe's more than I like anything else and that doesn't affect the finish. Externally all I'm doing it is giving it a rubdown with my usual cleaning rag (which is full of Hoppe's and Remoil). Now if I come across something that is already losing the nickel finish in places, I will try to be careful that I don't let any Hoppe's soak those spots because it will work it's way under the finish and continue the removal. I've been working this way basically my entire life and I have no problems with any nickel guns I have ever had. YMMV. P.S. Hoppe's does have a new non ammoniated formula out, I can't vouch for it because I'm still using old stuff.

 

[ranger1202]

I would guess it has been fired since it left the factory, based on the front of the cylinder and the turn line. Bear in mind, that's just my opinion based on a few photos.

What does the top of the frame look like, just above the forcing cone?

At any rate, I would shoot that fine revolver and enjoy it. No question about that!

Here's a pic. Hard to get a good one but zero flame cutting.

 

[Florida Guy]

Sure is a beauty... to shoot or not to shoot? That's the reason I don't own any nickel guns
I prefer ss and blued and not having to be afraid of damaging the finish.

 

[CH4]

It's definitely been shot before, because it was made to shoot.
Shoot it!

 

[saemetric]

Remember that they test fire a gun for a reason. And during that test if something is wrong, it is fixed and goes thru the test again, and maybe again. I've bought nib guns back in the 80's that looked like maybe 20 or more shots fired. I was a dealer then and they came directly from a distributor.

 

[Cellar Hound]

The factory generally test-fires every other chamber of a cylinder, and this one looks to have been fired on all six. Therefore, at least two people have fired it, and you should go forth and do likewise .

A lead removal cloth with your favorite cleaner/solvent cleans this area up nicely, but you probably know this already. Enjoy!

I agree with this ^^^^^^^^

Shoot it and give it the love it deserves...... Unless for resale, shooting is the only way for you to truly get to know each other. That is a beautiful revolver. Enjoy!!

 

[ranger1202]

Remember that they test fire a gun for a reason. And during that test if something is wrong, it is fixed and goes thru the test again, and maybe again. I've bought nib guns back in the 80's that looked like maybe 20 or more shots fired. I was a dealer then and they came directly from a distributor.

Yeah I think this may have been the case. I got bored today and cleaned it and even took off the side plate to give it a look. It hadn't been cleaned but was clean like a new one if that makes sense. Either way, I'm in it at a fair price and I'm definitely going to shoot it and enjoy. As other people have said, if I'm not going to sell it why not shoot it. I've sold some guns in the past and regret it so no more unless I really have to.

 

[revolver686]

Shoot, clean, repeat.

I have never bought a gun within the intention of later selling it and realizing a profit. All of my guns were purchased to shoot.

Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk

 

[MCorps0311]

Could be, probably was, still look like a good buy!

 

[wproct]

That's a very nice Nickel 586-2. My vote is to enjoy it in the manner that brings you the most pleasure. If that means firing it and cleaning it properly afterwards by all means do it. However, I do own a few firearms that I don't shoot, but I still get much pleasure just owning them and getting them out to admire from time to time. So, whatever brings you the most pleasure, do it.

 

[0311INF]

If it were really unfired I might have the same consideration as you. But that thing has been shot. The turn line alone is evidence, and it would not leave the factory with the powder rings on the face of the cylinder looking like that.
Shoot the heck out of it. It's a 586! The most you'd lose in value would be $50 anyway. I waste $50 doing things much less awesome than shooting an L Frame.

 

[ranger1202]

If it were really unfired I might have the same consideration as you. But that thing has been shot. The turn line alone is evidence, and it would not leave the factory with the powder rings on the face of the cylinder looking like that.
Shoot the heck out of it. It's a 586! The most you'd lose in value would be $50 anyway. I waste $50 doing things much less awesome than shooting an L Frame.

I think that should have been my question, how much of a premium does an unfired 586 have vs a well maintained 586. $50 is negligible and to me it's not worth not shooting it. Heck I bought it to shoot and never really had any intentions of not doing so but you hear these claims like "never been fired" and it makes you wonder what you could be giving up. I'll be sure to report back after it's first trip to the range. Hopefully soon!

 

[0311INF]

Generally the L Frames are not collector's items. There are some rare configurations that will bring $ but a nickel 4" is too common to be especially sought after in the collector market.

Maybe in another 10 years an unfired nickel 586 would be worth 30% more than shooter grade. But it wouldn't bother me. At most a couple/few hundred dollars for years of shooting pleasure is well worth it.

 

[SFIDEC]

Shoot or no? 586 nickel

Ranger...Two options in my opinion. (1)Buy another to shoot and enjoy in nickel or blue 4". (2) Start shooting your nice unfired? 586-2 as soon as possible. I just happen to think they are the best handling and looking revolvers ever produced. I have not found anything to beat this sweet S&W 586...including the Python. Personally, I think the 4" is as accurate as the 6". You can shoot 38's or 357's. Just depends on if you like big bangs or softer booms. The full underlug will keep that baby nice and stable while knocking down those targets with ease.
Please enjoy!!!! She will love you for it. Whew...I think I'll have a smoke now...and I don't even smoke.

 

[ken158]

That gun has been fired past the factory testing and it should continue to be fired. If you don't want to fire it, why own it?

 

[leejack]

Shoot it, of course.

 

[bananaman]

The factory generally test-fires every other chamber of a cylinder, and this one looks to have been fired on all six. Therefore, at least two people have fired it, and you should go forth and do likewise .

A lead removal cloth with your favorite cleaner/solvent cleans this area up nicely, but you probably know this already. Enjoy!

What he said! I do not like a gun that will not go to the range once & a while. NICE 586! I have a 586 no dash blue 4" with no extras. They are a pleasure to shoot. Bob

 

[SFIDEC]

Shoot or No?

Ranger1202...You ever go ahead and shoot that 586?

 

[df06]

new guns

Pretty much my thoughts. I'm a freak about cleaning my guns after shooting and don't let them go back in the safe without being cleaned. My only concern was if I would be devaluing it significantly by firing it. For the record, I've never understood owning a gun you don't shoot but I guess I could pick up a cheaper one in lesser condition if i'd be hurting this one.

I am of the same ilk, I never buy a gun to not shoot it. And if I own a gun and don't enjoy shooting it, its gone.
ZI recently bought a 625-5 45C, made in 1993 but NIB. I will be shooting it tomorrow.