Shooting .38 +P Ammo in a .38
- Thread starter Hammergun
- Start date
swca_life
swhf_member
nra_benefactor
active_navy
leo_none
SWCA #2023
- Joined
- Jun 28, 2007
- Messages
- 27,660
- Reaction score
- 21,269
Will try to summarize the one or two other threads on this question. 
For S & W revolvers, any model stamped steel K (medium) or N (large) frame revolver in .38 Special and .357 Magnum is factory approved for + P.
The J or small frame guns were not approved until the late 1980s to early ‘90s, depending on the model.
Standard .38 Special is up to 17000 psi and + P up to 20000 psi. In limited quantities even + P will not cause failure of a mechanically sound .38 Special made in the last 50 years or so, but heavy use will put extra stress on the gun.
Other opinions to follow...
For S & W revolvers, any model stamped steel K (medium) or N (large) frame revolver in .38 Special and .357 Magnum is factory approved for + P.
The J or small frame guns were not approved until the late 1980s to early ‘90s, depending on the model.
Standard .38 Special is up to 17000 psi and + P up to 20000 psi. In limited quantities even + P will not cause failure of a mechanically sound .38 Special made in the last 50 years or so, but heavy use will put extra stress on the gun.
Other opinions to follow...
nra_life
active_army
Skeptic 9c
Member
There is little reason to use +P ammunition. The increase in performance is small, relative to the increase in cost. Now, if it is policy, some LEOrgs have chosen a +P load based on performance evaluations (Chief/Sheriff got a bribe, or was blackmailed due to a tryst with a booth babe), some follow a State or Federal Agency, looking to avoid critics (this never works.)
Geoff
Who is a cynical pessimist (retired professional pessimist) who carries reduced recoil Hornady, because my arthritic wife can handle my guns.
Geoff
Who is a cynical pessimist (retired professional pessimist) who carries reduced recoil Hornady, because my arthritic wife can handle my guns.
swca_none
swhf_none
nra_none
active_none
leo_none
Hapworth
Member
- Joined
- Mar 22, 2012
- Messages
- 5,930
- Reaction score
- 6,115
If the particular load in the particular gun gets and keeps the pill within its threshold for performing as designed because of the +P loading where standard pressure won't -- as is sometimes the case with defense loads especially out of snubbies -- that counts good reason to use it.
swca_none
swhf_none
nra_none
active_none
leo_none
cowboy4evr
Member
I have always felt that +P in todays world is really just standard load back in " yesteryear " and maybe even less and I'm not talking about the infamous Speer 8 manual . Regards Paul
swca_none
swhf_none
nra_none
active_navy
leo_none
If you do a study on the loads used in the 1940's -1980's and
check them against todays loads, you will see what we are putting into our weapons.
True we have gone from a CUP to a PSI pressure system and some of the companies that made "Hot ammo" are no longer with us today, there are a few companies like Buffalo Bore and Underwood, that keep the torch burning.
The owner of a weapon needs to know the condition of the weapon and the use for the ammo, to select either standard or +P loads for their use.
Only firing the ammo in your weapon, will let you know if the load is a true +P loading or just hyped up by the company to get more $$$ for its ammo with it's advertising.
You KNOW what ADVERTISING is, right ?? !!
Good shopping.
swca_none
swhf_none
nra_endowment
active_none
leo_none
crstrode
Member
swca_none
swhf_none
nra_none
active_none
leo_none
Rammer Jammer
Member
There is a very good reason to use +P. Many loads in snubbies need that extra oomph to expand.
swca_none
swhf_none
nra_none
active_navy
leo_none
and some 158 gr LswHP and 125 gr JHP bullets with the +P speeds out of a snub nose, still don't expand, while the lighter bullets don't penetrate enough.
Know what you weapon and ammo can do for you.
swca_none
swhf_none
nra_member
active_none
leo_none
Sevens
Member
I think it is important to set a baseline for the discussion, it seems to me that many (too many!) don’t realize that a simple +P should be looked at critically.
Our entire industy/hobby benefits from an agreed upon industry standard. SAAMI is the organization that keeps this standard and to our benefit (and the benefit of all involved), both firearms and ammunition manufacturers usually accept and agree upon these standards.
SAAMI has designated +P as nomenclature for a small number of specific items. .38 Special+P happens to be one of them.
Generally, many many gun folks simplify things and say that +P just means higher pressure. On the other hand, and importantly so, SAAMI designates specifically what that means and when/where.
When some guy in a gun store is flapping gums and talking +P, it only means whatever he wants it to mean. When SAAMI uses it, or a gun manufacturer or ammo manufacturer uses it and follows the SAAMI standard, we can know exactly what it means.
It frustrates me when Buffalo Bore markets a product such as their .380 Auto+P because SAAMI says that doesn’t exist. Buffalo Bore is trying to say that they are marketing a round that exceeds the standard, but if it isn’t an industry-wide held standard, then exactly WHAT is it?
The +P term is tossed around casually and I wonder if folks recognize that it is a very specific standard and tossing it around casually does nobody much good.
According to SAAMI, if it isn’t 9mm+P, .38 Special+P, .38 Super+P or .45 ACP+P, it is not held to any agreed-upon industry standard.
When your gun manufacturer -AND- your ammo manufacturer both agree and follow a standard, you can and should expect your ammo to fit and function safely and properly in your firearm.
When your ammo manufacturer or source willfully or ignorantly abandons the SAAMI standard, then you should know that you are shoving ammo in to your gun that your gun manufacturer did not necessarily design the gun around.
Astute handloaders follow guidelines that ensures the ammo they craft fits within SAAMI specs. When they miss part of it, that’s when it doesn’t quite fit or does not run well or... they blow the cylinder in to two pieces, etc etc.
SAAMI standards are a blessing on this industry. Understanding them will serve you well!
Our entire industy/hobby benefits from an agreed upon industry standard. SAAMI is the organization that keeps this standard and to our benefit (and the benefit of all involved), both firearms and ammunition manufacturers usually accept and agree upon these standards.
SAAMI has designated +P as nomenclature for a small number of specific items. .38 Special+P happens to be one of them.
Generally, many many gun folks simplify things and say that +P just means higher pressure. On the other hand, and importantly so, SAAMI designates specifically what that means and when/where.
When some guy in a gun store is flapping gums and talking +P, it only means whatever he wants it to mean. When SAAMI uses it, or a gun manufacturer or ammo manufacturer uses it and follows the SAAMI standard, we can know exactly what it means.
It frustrates me when Buffalo Bore markets a product such as their .380 Auto+P because SAAMI says that doesn’t exist. Buffalo Bore is trying to say that they are marketing a round that exceeds the standard, but if it isn’t an industry-wide held standard, then exactly WHAT is it?
The +P term is tossed around casually and I wonder if folks recognize that it is a very specific standard and tossing it around casually does nobody much good.
According to SAAMI, if it isn’t 9mm+P, .38 Special+P, .38 Super+P or .45 ACP+P, it is not held to any agreed-upon industry standard.
When your gun manufacturer -AND- your ammo manufacturer both agree and follow a standard, you can and should expect your ammo to fit and function safely and properly in your firearm.
When your ammo manufacturer or source willfully or ignorantly abandons the SAAMI standard, then you should know that you are shoving ammo in to your gun that your gun manufacturer did not necessarily design the gun around.
Astute handloaders follow guidelines that ensures the ammo they craft fits within SAAMI specs. When they miss part of it, that’s when it doesn’t quite fit or does not run well or... they blow the cylinder in to two pieces, etc etc.
SAAMI standards are a blessing on this industry. Understanding them will serve you well!
swca_none
swhf_none
nra_member
active_none
leo_none
Some companies make bullets.....
....that are designed to expand at lower velocities and do pretty well in calibrated testing and in 'practical testing' (ex. Paul Harrel's 'meat target')
I have some +P ammo and standard velocity ammo in 9mm and .38 Special and in most the benefit of +P is small.
....that are designed to expand at lower velocities and do pretty well in calibrated testing and in 'practical testing' (ex. Paul Harrel's 'meat target')
I have some +P ammo and standard velocity ammo in 9mm and .38 Special and in most the benefit of +P is small.
swca_none
swhf_none
nra_life
active_navy
leo_none
ddixie884
Member
Will try to summarize the one or two other threads on this question.
For S & W revolvers, any model stamped steel K (medium) or N (large) frame revolver in .38 Special and .357 Magnum is factory approved for + P.
The J or small frame guns were not approved until the late 1980s to early ‘90s, depending on the model.
Standard .38 Special is up to 17000 psi and + P up to 20000 psi. In limited quantities even + P will not cause failure of a mechanically sound .38 Special made in the last 50 years or so, but heavy use will put extra stress on the gun.
Other opinions to follow...
What he said............
swca_none
swhf_none
nra_life
active_none
leo_none
stansdds
Member
This question, along with the K-frame forcing cone cracks, comes up all the time. Perhaps this information could be put into a "sticky" for easy and quick reference?
Plus P ammo does not seem to be an issue for carry in something like a K frame. But they make snubbies rated for .357 now, so those would digest plus ammo with no prob. I have a box of Winchester 110 grain plus P plus for police issue. Now that is something you want to avoid. I fired 5 rounds of that out of a snub model 15 one time at the range and it was quite uncomfortable to shoot and on the ears. Seemed like magnum.
swca_none
swhf_none
nra_benefactor
active_air_force
leo_none
SWCA #3480
Maj Dad
Member
Years back a federal agent friend gave me a box of very hot 110gr 38 Spl loads made by Winchester for the feds. The box had warnings all over it not to use it in any but modern, well-made weapons, and I can tell you, I only used them in a Mod 19, and sparingly. I still have 10 or 12 of then I just keep in the box as examples. Not sure what the ballistics were, but those suckers were hot! I'll take a Mack truck at 55 mph over an MG Midget at 70 any day...
swca_none
swhf_none
nra_member
active_none
leo_none
Sevens
Member
There was a period of time when LE were getting boxes marked “.38 Special +P+” which is also not a SAAMI designation and the rumored backstory is that these were .357 Magnum level loads stuffed in to .38 Special brass, specifically for LE Organizations that operated in silly PR environments where being issued “magnum” sidearms was verboten.
This ammo could very well bring hell on old .38 Special revolvers, especially before the heat treated cylinders.
This ammo could very well bring hell on old .38 Special revolvers, especially before the heat treated cylinders.
swca_none
swhf_none
nra_life
active_none
leo_none
Vilkus
Member
I suspect Sevens is correct. I own a 38 Special chambered Mod 640 that is marked "tested for +P+".
It was built on the old frame (1991) before they stretched it to accommodate the .357 (1995). I suspect that since S&W couldn't chamber a J frame in 357 (because the frame was too short), this was a way of providing 357 power in a 38 Special gun.
If true, what I own amounts to a short chambered .357
and was a step in the evolution of the 357 J frame.
It was built on the old frame (1991) before they stretched it to accommodate the .357 (1995). I suspect that since S&W couldn't chamber a J frame in 357 (because the frame was too short), this was a way of providing 357 power in a 38 Special gun.
If true, what I own amounts to a short chambered .357
and was a step in the evolution of the 357 J frame.
I think the police that used that plus P plus stuff used something like my heavy barrel 64. Not snubs. The light JHP might help alleviate recoil some but I still have the whole box minus the 5 I tried. Even not being a full box I bet that in today's market I could sell them easily. Maybe this is a good time to sell your partial boxes of ammo or stuff that you don't use anymore.
