Short barrel 44 magnum (pre 29)

Joined
Jul 6, 2009
Messages
1,613
Reaction score
3,385
Location
Pittsburgh PA
Ever since I got my first 44 magnum (pre 29) which was a 6.5 gun, I wanted a shorty aka 4in. This proved more difficult to find than I had first thought. I wanted one that was original, which would also letter. I preferred to find a 5 screw, but I knew regardless, it has to be before a 29-2 for my first one. No real reason, except the earlier the better, as most times it goes in this hobby.

Just like with many other S&Ws we all search for, patience is a virtue. I would semi frequently find them online (5 screw, 4 screw, 29 no dash) but they were either low condition, refinished, had cut barrels, too much money, no letter, altered, etc. I didn't need the letter to buy one per se, but I of course didn't want to buy an early 4in 44 magnum which didn't letter either.

A few months ago, my patience paid off. I landed this nice 4 screw pre 29 which shipped in 1958. SN - S180093. The seller was in CA, we agreed to a price and the gun came to my S&W orphanage ;)

At some point in its life, it had trigger work done and let me tell you, its one of the best revolver triggers I have ever felt - period! The gun is in respectable condition, as are the grips. No rework or date stamps.

It really felt great to get this one. "Finally" I kept saying to myself. On top of the age, attrition rate, etc. far fewer early 44 magnums were made with 4in barrels. 4in production began about mid way through 1956. As time went on, more and more 4in guns were made but I would still estimate that only 1/3 of the early 44 magnum production was for 4in guns.

Here she is :D

IMG_0487_zpsh4fcdlf5.jpg

IMG_0489_zpsfbi6h7dz.jpg

IMG_0491_zpsfocqyqto.jpg

IMG_0492_zpsxf9pmhcp.jpg

IMG_0493_zpszaowdr9b.jpg


I managed to get the letter request out right before Roy went on his trip in April (I think it was). A few weeks ago I got the letter, and thankfully the gun lettered correctly. Also interesting was that the previous owner was in CA and the gun originally shipped there. The owner before me was not the first owner.

If any of you have a case for a 4in 44 magnum you would sell, I would be interested. This gun goes in the smaller black/blue presentation case.

Its nice when things work out ;)

pre%2029%204in_zps6wp1x4dg.jpg
 
Last edited:
Register to hide this ad
Sir that's a nice one indeed. Congratulations. I do see them come up from time to time. Most are out of my budget. I really like the four inch barrel length.
 
I also have a 6.5 inch pre-29 and would very much like to find a 4 inch like yours. Mine is not in the best condition, as someone touched up the finish with cold blue or something. But it shoots like a laser and has a nice set of cokes on it. Well done, sir!
 
I would be interested in hearing how they shoot, if indeed any of you plan to shoot yours. (I wouldn't blame anyone either way, just curious). Obviously, I wouldn't expect a shooting report on the engraved ones. :o

To my thinking, a .44 Magnum just screams for a 6" or longer barrel. But I have never fired one with the 4" barrel, so I am interested in actual experiences.

Another thing about those early ones is they are pre-endurance package, so there again I would wonder if they are a better choice for a collector and not the greatest for a shooter.
 
I bought a 4" M29, along with a 6.5" in 1979 while stationed in Germany. I still have the 6.5", but it took me less than a couple of cylinders of full power ammo to convince me that the 4" needed a new home. Way too much noise and recoil for me! I'm glad some folks like them, because it made it easy for me to move mine along.
 
To my thinking, a .44 Magnum just screams for a 6" or longer barrel. But I have never fired one with the 4" barrel, so I am interested in actual experiences.

I agree and I don't remember ever firing a shorty either. I will have to let you all know, unless of course I am too embarrassed at my target ;)

Another thing about those early ones is they are pre-endurance package, so there again I would wonder if they are a better choice for a collector and not the greatest for a shooter.

I agree that for shooting they are not as good as later models BUT one has to wonder, just how many licks would it take to get to the center of the tootsie pop, so to speak? I know on my 44 magnums (pre 29s), I will never find out!
 
I would be interested in hearing how they shoot, if indeed any of you plan to shoot yours. (I wouldn't blame anyone either way, just curious). Obviously, I wouldn't expect a shooting report on the engraved ones. :o

To my thinking, a .44 Magnum just screams for a 6" or longer barrel. But I have never fired one with the 4" barrel, so I am interested in actual experiences.

Another thing about those early ones is they are pre-endurance package, so there again I would wonder if they are a better choice for a collector and not the greatest for a shooter.



I have an M29-3 with a 3" barrel Lew Horton Special that is certainly "Pre Endurance Package". I shot the snot out of it with 300 grain Prvi Partizan, (I was misinformed and led to believe this gun had the "EP")... 75Vette from this forum was a big help informing me on the skinny of exactly what Models have the "EP", what Models Don't, and quick and unmistakable way of how to tell... He and others said that I would likely wear out my 40 year old beefy mitts before the M29 LHS would. I never had one hiccup nor did the cylinder every rotate backwards under recoil to a dead/spent round either. It's just as tight as the day I brought her home.

I save the 300+ grain steel silhouette hammer loads to my 3" barreled M629-5 now; but it's not due to the -5 having the "EP" and the LHS 29-3 does NOT... I'm sure 75Vette and others were right, my wrists and hands will wear lose before the LHS 29-3 will. It's simply because it took considerable time and effort acquiring a 3" M29-3LHS and I don't want to take the slightest of chance of something happening amiss. So it's been relegated to 255 grain loads and lesser.

As to a 3" M29/629 being a wrist breaker, hell no, not even close! It's quite pleasurable to push 100 rounds of full-house Mags in a single range session and another 50 hot Specials as well. Both of mine weigh over 40ounces! A 4" barreled version weighing 2 ounces more will fare even 2 hairs better.
M29-3 "LHS"
nvLD2lW.jpg

M629-5 "MBP"
k8WDrgA.jpg

Last range day, 10 and 12 yard groupings...
w2vQGcK.jpg
 
Last edited:
Excellent Jim! Beautiful example. I've had this one for quite a while. It's got quite a few scratches in it but it's all there.
Bill

OMG---THIS IS A GORGEOUS EXAMPLE. THAT HISTORICAL LETTER WAS WELL WORTH THE COST AND THE WAIT.....

THE FACT THAT IT IS DOCUMENTED AS THE VERY FIRST CLASS A, FACTORY ENGRAVED SPECIMEN, TRULY SETS IT APART........
 
OP, I'm happy for you. That is the nicest 60 year old gun I've ever seen. I'm not even sure it was ever shot outside the factory. I take really good care of my guns, vehicles, house, etc... But damn some considerable care was taken with your new piece; not a scratch, blemish, or spec of rust... that is truly astounding!
 

Latest posts

Back
Top