Smith & Wesson 27 2 Full engraved Questions

Sigfried Rentzschke engraved for Smith & Wesson for a couple of years in the late 1950s before going independent. He did a lot of work for Winchester from his home in Massachusetts. I was contacted by his neighbor several years ago about a 44 Magnum I was researching and he arranged for Mr. Rentzschke to look at photos of the gun. If I can find his contact information, I will send it to you.

Bill
 
Doc44 said:
Sigfried Rentzschke engraved for Smith & Wesson for a couple of years in the late 1950s before going independent. He did a lot of work for Winchester from his home in Massachusetts. I was contacted by his neighbor several years ago about a 44 Magnum I was researching and he arranged for Mr. Rentzschke to look at photos of the gun. If I can find his contact information, I will send it to you.

Bill
Click to expand...

Doc 44,
That would be awesome if I could contact him about these.
 
Welcome to the forum! That is a heck of an entrance! As the saying goes they are worth as much as someone is willing to pay. But I would expect to pay $2000 for 2 consecutive 27-2s without any engraving in the condition they are in. If it turns out they were factory engraved you will more than quadruple your money. If it is a well known engraver after the factory you will double your money.
 
If you are serious about a custom case you should look at Huey custom cases. Home - Huey Gun Cases Their cases are really nice. Good call on the other posters suggesting not storing them in the case though. Let us know what you find out about these nice revolvers.
 
With the help of Doc44 I was able to contact Rentschke's neighbor and he has agreed to show him the pictures and see if it is one of the guns he engraved.
 
What kind of moron would have pawned those for $1000?
And how does someone that stupid have ownership of nice pieces like that in the first place?
 
I am pretty sure he inherited these. He has been selling a lot of engraved guns to shops in town some have been shot a lot and put away dirty. I am glad he did not shoot these.
 
Here is a email I received from FEGA
I was able to see enough of the scroll work to determine that the engraving was done by one of the Japanese engravers who were working in the US during the 1970's. REI Engravings of Illinois employed Hiroo Ogawa and other Japanese engravers who all worked in the style evident on your guns. Also, Ken Eyster who owned Heratige Gunsmiths in Ohio employed Sam Kinamuchi who also worked in the same style. Unfortunately, it is very rare for any of the Japanese engravers to sign their work.

The style of ornament on your guns is based on German black leaf scroll. Because of the type of graver and method of cutting, the work of Japanese engravers is distinguishable from similar work done by German engravers. Some of my fellow engravers have speculated that at some point a Japanese engraver was trained in Germany and later taught other Japanese the style. However that idea has never been confirmed.

I hope the foregoing has been of help in determining the provenance of your revolvers.

Sincerely,

C. Roger Bleile
 
the ultimate snubbie

it's been a while since I have been on the forum. I am looking for information about engraved revolvers, and ran across this post.
I am trying to find out if a factory engraved revolver is worth more than a non-factory engraved revolver.
one of my goals is to find a beautiful snub nosed smith and Wesson either blued or stainless, or even nickel plated that really stands out.
I have seen lots of engraved snubbies on guns international that are "almost" there, but not quite.
if I ever find that "special snubbie" either double action only or
da/sa, I would like to know if it is more valuable if engraved by s&w or by a non-s&w engraver. obviously this puts a collector in the unenviable position of choosing the revolver which is more pleasing to the eye or choosing the one that is worth more in the real world.
any opinions?
as for the two revolvers pictured here: a once in a lifetime find.
 
fivetwo:

Typically a factory engraved piece is worth more to S&W collectors that a non-factory engraved piece unless the engraver is well known such as Alvin White, Winston Churchill, etc. S&W did not do a large number of custom engraved guns with extensive gold, etc.

Since engraving is so personal, keep watching the auction sites or let some of the larger collector dealers (David Carroll) know what you are looking for. The other alternative is to commission an engraving project with a good engraver. It will not be cheap, but you get to help design your piece and will have what you want. I would highly recommend John K. Pease engraving - John K. Pease Engraver - Home He has done three pieces for me and I am very pleased.

Bob
 
Ok..so now one has to ask...are the Factory Letters back...?

Absolutely stunning find.... I have seen a lot of engraved Smiths and these are two of the nicest...

Bob
 
Ken Eyster was the go to man back in the day when it came to working on double guns in the Mid-West.

-Steve
 
I am still waiting for the letter, from what I have read he had something like 900 in front of mine so it will prob be 6 months or more before I here back.
 
I would love to see these in person, you are so lucky. im so jealous
 
Rad29 said:
fivetwo:

Typically a factory engraved piece is worth more to S&W collectors that a non-factory engraved piece unless the engraver is well known such as Alvin White, Winston Churchill, etc. S&W did not do a large number of custom engraved guns with extensive gold, etc.

Since engraving is so personal, keep watching the auction sites or let some of the larger collector dealers (David Carroll) know what you are looking for. The other alternative is to commission an engraving project with a good engraver. It will not be cheap, but you get to help design your piece and will have what you want. I would highly recommend John K. Pease engraving - John K. Pease Engraver - Home He has done three pieces for me and I am very pleased.

Bob
Click to expand...

thanks for that information.
also, I ran across an engraver on another website: craig vitello of texas. his work is very impressive. does anyone have information on how to contact him.
 
Got the letter in today it was not engraved at the factory. It was shipped to Gopher Shooters Supply Co. in Faribault MN. So now I am back to square one on figuring out who engraved these pistols.
SampWLetter_zps34932591.jpg
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

O
Engraved, Silver Plated 44 DA
Replies
3
Views
741
Oldmanwesson
O
K
Gold engraved 44 magnum 29-2
Replies
8
Views
1K
RKmesa
RKmesa
M
Type 3 Factory Engraved Triple Lock Revolver
2
Replies
26
Views
2K
mrcvs
M
RM Vivas
The small world of my NYPD Commando
Replies
13
Views
759
RM Vivas
RM Vivas
M
Smith & Wesson engravers timeline, pre WWII
Replies
9
Views
1K
mrcvs
M

Latest posts

Back
Top