Snub nose

[Capt Steve]

I think the 642 is far and away the most popular of the snubbies and while opinions vary I like my 649. I shoot mostly 38's through it (cheaper and less recoil), but it is nice to have the 357 option. I also like the option of SA/DA with the shrouded hammer - nothing to snag when carrying concealed.

 

[wheelgun1958]

Originally posted by gunsmith11:
Model 60

 

[bricker]

You can't go wrong with a 36. The steel frame takes quite a bit of the bite out of a .38 special load. I sold my 442 and bought a 36 so I could practice longer!

 

[Thuer]

In the gunstore where I work one day pro week I carry an model 60.

 

[truckemup97]

Another vote for a 640-1. It's a little heavier than some of the alloy guns, but it can double as a hammer.

As for resale value, I paid $275 for mine used, and it would take a lot more than that to get it away from me. Almost any Smith you buy USED is going to be worth that much or more in the future. You will see a drop in value if you buy new, though, just like anything else. If you can buy a new 642 for $500, why would you pay $500 for a used one?

 

[Stevens]

I am happy with my 642 being hammerless it is great for pocket carry
Steve

 

[Old 44 Guy]

Any "J" frame that lights your fire.

 

[gunsmith11]

The model 60 has made me well the last 30 or so years,and i have a back up a bTj derringer in 38 special also

 

[Wyatt Burp]

Colt New Service 45! If your the size of Sheqille O'Neil.

 

[BOB THE PALINDROME]

I really like my 340PD. Light and very concealable. Shoot .38 in it and work your way up to .357. I still have problems with recovering with .357 so still carry .38 and work on shot placement and second shot follow-up.

 

[Frizzman]

I like all of the J frames. Lightweight vs all steel depends on how you plan to carry it. Then there is also the other brand...Colt Detective Special, Cobra or Agent. They are all good revolvers. Some like the S&W's and not the Colts and some vice versa. I like them all. The Colts are only available used. The Ruger SP101 is also well though of by many people.

 

[lev83]

I love the 2.5" S&W 66 but budget was limited to a 2.5" Rossi 68. It has proven to be a real bargain but still looking for that 66.