I love certain models from Ruger. There is no need to be a "closet" Ruger fan. Several of us here have published articles in the Ruger Collectors Association Journal, including Doc44. I am pretty sure I remember an article in the RCA Journal by Roy also, but will defer to others on this.
Ruger makes a spectacular example of the SAA at any price, and the price is very favorable. Jeff Cooper liked his Super Blackhawk so much he had the cylinder made as rust resistant as possible for that era by having it finished in Armaloy, which gave it a unique two-tone appearance. He was quite a fan of the little Bearcat also. His was also two-tone. Skeeter Skelton was a fan of Ruger, and Elmer Keith had some also.
In the last 10 years, or maybe a little more, a great number of S&W managers and engineers have gone to work for Ruger, which accounts for their successful entry, after S&W, into the various markets including combat pistols, AR rifles, 1911s, etc.
With the price and features, it is hard not to appreciate Ruger.
That said, I still think the S&W has the better action. I think S&Ws are more handsome (that is just a personal preference issue, obviously), and I think that S&W guns are equally as strong, despite not being as thick. Others will disagree, and they are entitled to their opinions. On the other hand, I do not use the kind of loads that some handloaders seem to like so much.
I have said this before. We are lucky to have so many great guns from which to choose. Personally, I wish the American companies all success.
So, could we all get along with a Model 10 and a 1911? Yes, but the variety makes it more fun!
To the product planners at Ruger: How about a true "half-lug" (I despise that term, preferring "standard ejector shroud" versus "full length ejector shroud") GP-100 with a round barrel like the old Security Six? Yes, I know about the Match Champion, but feel the same way about its appearance as I do most of what comes from the Performance Center at S&W.
Enjoy your Rugers. They make good stuff! And for all of you who still hold a grudge against Bill Ruger for saying he thought a 15 round magazine was all consumers needed, you can do what you want, but the Ruger family has been out of the business now for several years, and their aggressive pursuit of the items Bill Ruger did not wish to pursue shows they are committed to gun owners, including those who like ARs, semi-autos, high cap magazines, and suppressors.