SW 686 vs SW 66
- Thread starter The judge
- Start date
Kamerer
Member
If you want a 4" .38 special for target work, and a gun for ONLY that purpose, I'd recommend a 15 or 67 like Jellybean said. The bullet will not have to jump to the cylinder bore like in a .357.
Examine a few guns and buy the best of those you sample, not necessarily one gun over the others. I have two 686's and three 66/19s. The two 686s have better triggers and are tighter overall than the K guns. This is too small a sample to make a sweeping statement from, but it's my experience so I'll share it. I am a fan of the L frame.
If you want the MOST versatile gun in a 4", then a 686 would be the ticket - it's control with magnums is impressive, and much more pleasant to shoot those with than a K.
Examine a few guns and buy the best of those you sample, not necessarily one gun over the others. I have two 686's and three 66/19s. The two 686s have better triggers and are tighter overall than the K guns. This is too small a sample to make a sweeping statement from, but it's my experience so I'll share it. I am a fan of the L frame.
If you want the MOST versatile gun in a 4", then a 686 would be the ticket - it's control with magnums is impressive, and much more pleasant to shoot those with than a K.
I'm bidding on this M66 what do you guys think of this gun, comments please...
what is the gun worth as a shooter...
http://www.gunbroker.com/auction/viewitem.asp?item=105566671
what is the gun worth as a shooter...
http://www.gunbroker.com/auction/viewitem.asp?item=105566671
Frizzman
US Veteran
I have never bought a gun over the internet. That said, that revolver at anywhere near the last bid would be a bargain if it is in the shape it looks in the photos. If you just plan to stick to .38 WC, then the K-frame is a wonderful platform for that. If I was going for a steady diet of magnums, I would prefer the L or N-frames. The K-frame is lighter to carry. The .38 and the K-frame are a perfect match!
The seller, Lee Jarret, is a member of this forum. I have bought a gun from him, and it was a real nice one. Better than described. You can deal with Lee with complete confidence.
44wheelman
Member
- Joined
- Feb 2, 2006
- Messages
- 1,709
- Reaction score
- 997
I wouldn't bid too much over $300.... there is s/h & FFL fees to consider. I would think you could find one locally for under $400 without the pitting. But, if the pitting doesn't bother you, it appears in excellent mechanical condition, then you should go higher. Just realize resale may be more difficult.
Shooting factory 357 loads, I have had better accuracy shooting 686's than 66's; however, I haven't seen much (if any) difference using .38spl ammo. If you think you will carry it at all, I would lean towards the 66.
Shooting factory 357 loads, I have had better accuracy shooting 686's than 66's; however, I haven't seen much (if any) difference using .38spl ammo. If you think you will carry it at all, I would lean towards the 66.
I can go $330...and probably will.
I've never seen that stainless matte finish on a 66 before, usually bright stainless or nickel...the pitting only bothers me regards resale, if I win the auction I will try to polish some of it away...
I don't shoot the 357's at all just 38 wadcutters (cheap & low recoil) and I shoot a lot around 3000 rounds a year.
There are several in the low $300's on GunsAmerica, without the pitting...
I am also looking at a couple of Model 67's.
I've never seen that stainless matte finish on a 66 before, usually bright stainless or nickel...the pitting only bothers me regards resale, if I win the auction I will try to polish some of it away...
I don't shoot the 357's at all just 38 wadcutters (cheap & low recoil) and I shoot a lot around 3000 rounds a year.
There are several in the low $300's on GunsAmerica, without the pitting...
I am also looking at a couple of Model 67's.
carguychris
Member
FWIW I recently got rid of a M19 because I mostly shoot .38Spl LHBWCs and LSWCs, and I got sick of scrubbing the crud out of the forward 0.10" of the chambers.
Ditto the suggestion to get a M67; I'm currently shopping for a M15 or M67 to replace that M19. Why spend the extra $200 for a .357Mag L-frame if you're only going to shoot .38Spl?
Ditto the suggestion to get a M67; I'm currently shopping for a M15 or M67 to replace that M19. Why spend the extra $200 for a .357Mag L-frame if you're only going to shoot .38Spl?
Well I won the auction on GunBroker for $333.00 for the Model 66, the one with a little pitting on the cylinder and lightly chewed on wood grips.
I will have $375.00 into the gun by the time of my first shot...
The thing that drew me to the gun, other than its reputation for being a great shooter, is that it has a flat or matte finish on the stainless as opposed to the normal shiny SS finish...I smell aftermarket here...any comments...???
I'll be getting the gun next week from Lee Jarret in Georgia apparently he sells quite a few S&W's.
I am now looking for an inexpensive Model 67 as another shooter....I do 3 or 4000 rounds a year strictly target 25yd and in...
I'll put pictures up next week sometime along with target pics...
I will have $375.00 into the gun by the time of my first shot...
The thing that drew me to the gun, other than its reputation for being a great shooter, is that it has a flat or matte finish on the stainless as opposed to the normal shiny SS finish...I smell aftermarket here...any comments...???
I'll be getting the gun next week from Lee Jarret in Georgia apparently he sells quite a few S&W's.
I am now looking for an inexpensive Model 67 as another shooter....I do 3 or 4000 rounds a year strictly target 25yd and in...
I'll put pictures up next week sometime along with target pics...
Cool Hand Hodge
Member
Based on the prices near me, you got a great deal! I think the pitting depending on depth should come out nice and easy, and new grips shouldnt be to hard to come by. I say restore it (wont cost much) and shoot the heck out of it!
If it helps any, my 66 2.5 inch likes a 158gr. wc in front of 4 grains of unique. Very dirty load, but its very mild and shoots great.
If it helps any, my 66 2.5 inch likes a 158gr. wc in front of 4 grains of unique. Very dirty load, but its very mild and shoots great.
Cool Hand Hodge
Member
just realized...you are near me, im in allen park...you got a great deal. That gun would draw an easy $450 in our neck of the woods.
Good to know you are nearby Joe, never know when I might need backup...
I have a shooting buddy that has a 66 along with other SW's...he wouldn't sell it for less than $500.00 and its not as nice as what I just bought, so I am pleased so far...
I'm in Allen Park every once in a while, buy my ammo from Mike at Michigan Ammo, Allen Park.
I have a shooting buddy that has a 66 along with other SW's...he wouldn't sell it for less than $500.00 and its not as nice as what I just bought, so I am pleased so far...
I'm in Allen Park every once in a while, buy my ammo from Mike at Michigan Ammo, Allen Park.
Cool Hand Hodge
Member
where abouts do you do your shooting at?
Similar threads
