The Ruger LCR vs S&W 442...my take...

Nice write up.

I too, prefer the J-frame. Perhaps it is just that I have owned and shot them for so long. I'm lucky in that the Smiths seem to naturally fit my hand and "point" well for me. The LCR is a great, snub choice for many. There is nothing wrong with owning both.

As to ankle carry? I've found the one holster that just "works" for me. The older school Desantis model 044. I never liked the way the newer Neoprene ones felt. Too much movement on my leg. The 044 uses a D-ring that really locks in the gun. I finally bought a replacement after nearly 20 years of use (the velcro was losing some strength). I kept the original and may try to replace that velcro. It actually works "ok" still, so I may just keep it as is. BTW, the one holster fits all three of my J-frames. My 640 (no dash), my 638 and my 642. Love my Desantis.
 
Petepeterson,

Indeed, I am no Mr. Spock when it comes to gun selection, apparently :)

I think that in the end it is your "perception" of what is "right" that determines your selection. Not just numbers.
 
Last edited:
Nice write up.

As to ankle carry? I've found the one holster that just "works" for me. The older school Desantis model 044. I never liked the way the newer Neoprene ones felt. Too much movement on my leg. The 044 uses a D-ring that really locks in the gun. I finally bought a replacement after nearly 20 years of use (the velcro was losing some strength). I kept the original and may try to replace that velcro. It actually works "ok" still, so I may just keep it as is. BTW, the one holster fits all three of my J-frames. My 640 (no dash), my 638 and my 642. Love my Desantis.

I will certainly take a look at this holster, it's only $59 on Amazon so it looks like a terrific buy, thanks for the suggestion.
 
Good report. I ultimately went with a PC 442 and the trigger is awesome! I really find it hard to understand how 10-15 yds is close distance for belly guns. Guess I am out of the mainstream LOL.
 
Back
Top