Thoughts/Advice on under barrel light and laser on semiauto pistol

Joined
Feb 1, 2011
Messages
6,862
Reaction score
17,182
Location
PRNJ
Was thinking of trying out a light/laser combination for the rail under the barrel of a semi auto pistol

I once had an in the grip laser on a small pistol and found it hard to stay on target with the laser dot.
Any thoughts/advice other than "you get what you oay for"
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Register to hide this ad
This is one of the few gun accessory ideas that doesn't really depend on money. You can get the very best quality and spend a lot of money and not overcome the basic flaws with the idea of using a laser on a handgun. A light has a lot of virtue, but a laser? No!

First, a real life story. No, I swear it's true! A close buddy was sent to Iraq right after the 1st Gulf War. I wanted him to have all the advantages he could so once he was there and told me the environment he was operating in I sent him a combination light/laser, and what was then the most advanced reflex/holographic sight, the EoTech, both for his M4. This guy is a very serious operator and used these to good effect while there for 12 months. After that experience, this was his opinion of each:
a. EoTech. Battery life too short. You don't have time to constantly adjust the reticle's brightness when you are in a firefight, especially when you are going indoors and out rapidly. Reticle too crude for distance shooting with accuracy. We went with a 2X Leupold scope after the first deployment.
b. Light. Superb in every respect. Very flexible and adaptable especially when using a tape switch. Use it when you need it, but otherwise keep it off.
c. Laser. Superb for intimidating the enemy or suspected enemy. Putting a laser dot on someone's chest has a way of defusing the situation. Also very handy when designating fire at night, but less so during the day since the dot is largely invisible in bright light past 30-40 yards. However, relying on it to help you aim your fire is a waste of time. Dot is too difficult to acquire initially, or reacquire after each shot. Looks cool in the movies but has little real world application.

I'm sure there will be comments that claim the exact opposite of what was just said, but hey, that's what makes a market economy function...different opinions.

b.
 
I've never been a fan! To me, common sense tells me that in the dark a Bad Guy would just shoot at the Light or Laser making you a pretty good target!

I leave on one 4 watt mini night light in my downstair hallway. It illuminates just enough for someone who knows the layout but not well enough for someone who doesn't. Since presumably were talking about a night time scenario, my bedrooms are upstairs and make for excellent visibility of what is going on downstairs amd is an excellent vantage point. I also have a switch upstairs to turn on the hall lights downstairs if I needed too.

If we are talking about a day time scenario, I don't thing a light or laser makes much difference to me.

Last but certainly NOT least........ If one practices and gets use to a light or laser coming on when his or her gun is gripped - and it fails...... that person will mentally be expecting to see something that has not worked and it could slow reaction time down just enough to matter. With defensive handguns, I like 'em plane Jane and like to keep things simple. AND as Muss stated, you are looking at a custom made holster - more than likely which not only adds expense, but your carry package is larger, and heavier also.
 
Last edited:
The light? Absolutely, if it is meant as a house gun or as an open carry piece.

The laser?

No.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top