Tough decision

[David LaPell]

I came across two .44 Magnums recently. One is a Smith 29 Mountain Gun, with the lock but like new. The other is a Model 29 Classic 4-inch barrel, also with the lock. The price is the same on both. And I can't afford both.

 

[David LaPell]

I came across two .44 Magnums recently. One is a Smith 29 Mountain Gun, with the lock but like new. The other is a Model 29 Classic 4-inch barrel, also with the lock. The price is the same on both. And I can't afford both.

 

[Careby]

All else being equal, I'd give a slight edge to the Mountain Gun. But buy the one you like the most!

 

[DCWilson]

The classic has the heavier barrel, right? This may come down to a question of weight -- both physical and visual. I'm kind of recoil sensitive, so I'd go with the extra few ounces. But I must admit the contours of the Mountain Gun barrel are more attractive than the Big Chunk o' Metal on the alternative.

I don't think you can go wrong either way: it's really a matter of personal preference and which one has the slightly greater appeal for you.

DCW

 

[swamp creature]

If I had the choice between those two, I think I would opt for the Mountain Gun.
Just my two cents worth.
Swampy

 

[feralmerril]

Buy the one that "calls" you. Personaly, I am into light weight and portability. Mountain gun.

 

[Andy Taylor]

Another vote for the Mountain gun. But if you like the classic better for it.

 

[HOUSTON RICK]

Does the vendor have lay-a-way?

 

[shameless]

The Mountain Gun gets my vote. FWIW

 

[dlstewart01]

I had a 629 Classic with a 6" barrel that I really liked untill I found some one who liked it a lot better.

 

[shawn mccarver]

Originally posted by David LaPell:
I came across two .44 Magnums recently. One is a Smith 29 Mountain Gun, with the lock but like new. The other is a Model 29 Classic 4-inch barrel, also with the lock. The price is the same on both. And I can't afford both.

I would get the Mountain Gun.