What carry to get for my woman?

ussoldier1984

US Veteran
Joined
May 9, 2015
Messages
116
Reaction score
14
I am trying to figure out what carry weapon to buy for my (soon to be wife October 4, 2015) She does not like my 40c but she does like the full frame Beretta px9. I think that it would be too big for a purse carry. Any ideas on a similar weapon in a smaller frame for her????
 
Register to hide this ad
If she's set on 'Off-Body' purrse carry, make sure she's made aware of the hazards associated with it, then shop for a appropriate one.

If she's shot the PX9 and likes it, you can suggest alternatives, but in the end she's the one that hhhas to like shooting it, or she'll
1. Never practice/train with it
2. leave it at home and let it collect dust.

In short... you can lay out the money, but it's her choice. :)
 
Get her a little 38 Airweight revolver (if she likes it). Make sure to get her the model with the exposed hammer. While she will never use single action in a confrontation, the next time that wild dog that's been killing your chickens shows himself, she will at least have a chance to take an aimed shot. It's a compromise since the hammer will snag on things, but it will turn her gun into more of a dual-purpose weapon.
 
I would suggest a trip to a range that happens to have carry options and accessories (holster, purse, etc.) to try out the entire system, and a definite second to letting her decide.
 
funny you mentioned the purse thing, at the range today we saw a bunch of purse carry with compartment for a small framed handgun lol How is the 380 and 38 compared to the 9mm never fired a 380 or 38
 
You already know she doesn't like the smaller gun, why on God's green earth would you even think of looking at a smaller gun? She's already said she likes the PX9. Just get that.

I can't guarantee she'll like it, but I can guarantee that you won't go wrong with that one.

One thing I'll never understand is why guys try to get girls tiny, light weight guns. The lighter the gun, the heavier the recoil will be. Trust me, if you want her to become a gun enthusiast, steer clear of anything with "air-weight" or "titanium frame" in the name. Those will hurt to shoot and you'll drive her away from guns altogether.

Get her shooting first. Then worry about the carry stuff later.
 
Get her the saw map Bodyguard 380 . .. nuff said..

Wife was smitten by the Bodyguard 380 and had carried it a few years. Then she caught a glimpse of my model 60... Traded me straight up. Happy wife, happy life. In all honesty, let her choose after shooting/handling a bunch of different models and calibers.
 
funny you mentioned the purse thing, at the range today we saw a bunch of purse carry with compartment for a small framed handgun lol How is the 380 and 38 compared to the 9mm never fired a 380 or 38

The "purse thing" is a fairly popular carry option for women. You can imagine the disadvantages of off-body carry - access/speed, the purse is lost or stolen, untrained people (small children) finding the gun.

If your wife is proficient in the use of a 9 mm, .380 or .38 Special she will not be undergunned. If your range has rental guns have her try several calibers. Did I mention also trying out how the gun feels in the purse and letting her decide on the gun? :)
 
ultimately it will be her choice, I was just looking for other models for her to try out. It seems she likes having a hammer. I do want her to be comfortable. I had her try .45, .40 and 9mm. Next Tuesday is lady's night at my local range. Free gun rentals and lane for women lol. So I will take her again to try out more options. I was just asking if there are any similar style frames to the Beretta px series.
 
Get her a little 38 Airweight revolver (if she likes it). Make sure to get her the model with the exposed hammer. While she will never use single action in a confrontation, the next time that wild dog that's been killing your chickens shows himself, she will at least have a chance to take an aimed shot. It's a compromise since the hammer will snag on things, but it will turn her gun into more of a dual-purpose weapon.
I mostly agree.

The extra 6-7 ounces of a steel framed Model 36 or Model 60 makes the revolver much more pleasant to shoot, but does not add enough extra weight to make carrying it an issue.

I've carried Model 36s, Model 60s and SP101s and I've never had the hammers snag on anything.

-----

As for off body carry, there are some significant downsides and if she does it she should at a minimum get a purse that's designed for concealed carry, and then practice with it.

The good news here is that when it doesn't work out, she can always carry a J frame on her body.
 
I have yet to have her try a revolver. hmm never crossed my mind. I shall see if she likes that next week when I take her to the range.
 
ultimately it will be her choice, I was just looking for other models for her to try out. It seems she likes having a hammer. I do want her to be comfortable. I had her try .45, .40 and 9mm. Next Tuesday is lady's night at my local range. Free gun rentals and lane for women lol. So I will take her again to try out more options. I was just asking if there are any similar style frames to the Beretta px series.

A whole bunch of similar size guns, and I will probably miss more than a few:

The S & W M & P 9 and 40 Compact
An older S & W 469, 669, 6906
One of the smaller Springfield Armory XDs
Sig P228, 229
Glock 19 and the .40 equivalent (23?)
 
You already know she doesn't like the smaller gun, why on God's green earth would you even think of looking at a smaller gun? She's already said she likes the PX9. Just get that.

I can't guarantee she'll like it, but I can guarantee that you won't go wrong with that one.

One thing I'll never understand is why guys try to get girls tiny, light weight guns. The lighter the gun, the heavier the recoil will be. Trust me, if you want her to become a gun enthusiast, steer clear of anything with "air-weight" or "titanium frame" in the name. Those will hurt to shoot and you'll drive her away from guns altogether.

Get her shooting first. Then worry about the carry stuff later.

Well said!!! I haven't read all the threads here yet but this is what crossed my mind when I read the OP's question: *You* shouldn't be getting your lady anything. You should take her shopping and let her pick out what *she* likes. Hopefully there's a range near you where you can rent different things.

Randy
 
Well said!!! I haven't read all the threads here yet but this is what crossed my mind when I read the OP's question: *You* shouldn't be getting your lady anything. You should take her shopping and let her pick out what *she* likes. Hopefully there's a range near you where you can rent different things.

Randy

I am fully aware of she needs to pick out a handgun that she likes I am asking for advice on what to have her try out considering the beretta px9 feels good to her. I want her to try more like that so she is very comfortable. I would never force a certain handgun on anyone.
 
Let her try many things and pick herself.

Don't go too small though... Not until she gets enough experience to handle added recoil.

If she didn't like the m&p compact in 40, she may like it in 9mm. Mine doesn't shoot much different than my full size.

Pistols in that size range conceal well and shoot decently too. The glock 26 may work for her too.

The shield in 9mm isn't bad at all, my fiance likes hers. She can't shoot it all day like other Pistols, but a box or two of 50... After that the recoil starts getting to her. I hear the glock 43 is similar in its recoil handling.


A purse will allow carry of larger Pistols, but I do not advocate that type of carry.

A flashbang holster may work well for her so she can carry on body. What Pistols work for this kind of carry depends on her build. Depending on her "ampleness" she may be able to conceal a sub compact, or she may need a single stack for that kind of carry.


I also advise you to get a modern hollow point design, like HST or Gold Dot, in standard pressure loads. I like 124gr personally, good recoil characteristics.

The reason... Is that the standard pressure loads actually perform better than the +p stuff in these loadings. So you get less recoil and better performance... Always a plus for anyone, man or woman.
 
Last edited:
I am fully aware of she needs to pick out a handgun that she likes I am asking for advice on what to have her try out considering the beretta px9 feels good to her. I want her to try more like that so she is very comfortable. I would never force a certain handgun on anyone.

One thing its the Beretta PX4 not a PX9. Its an excellent weapon for conceal carry .. have been carrying a PX4 Subcompact for over year. It comes in 3 sizes Full, Compact, and Subcompact .
 
Take her to shoot as many different guns as she likes. One will stick out that ft she likes. LET HER CHOOSE ! You can pick this or that , but if she doesn't like it,she won't carry it.
 
I found that going to a top notch range on couples night with experienced and knowledgeable trainers works.

Fewer lunks impressing everyone with their .500 hand cannons and lasers, just couples, and the chance to try out a little of everything: J Frames, .380's, Single Stack 9's, with/without laser (that Crimson Trace ad really catches the lady's attention), airweights, scandiums, purple/pink grips. Stay with the fully jacketed and lighter loads, no use throwing her in the deep end with a .357 or +P+.

Sometimes these ranges will do an appointment based system. The companies who do a good job want to make sure they don't sell a high dollar gun to some lady who can't figure out how to make it work, until she blows off her husband's, uh, well, you know....
 
Does she want a gun purely for self-defense or does she want to become a "shooter/gun enthusiast", because they are two very different things.

If purely for personal defense and she is not experienced and doesn't plan on really spending much time training, seriously consider a enclosed hammer j-frame revolver like a Smith & Wesson 642.

These guns are simple, safe, lightweight and handle neglect well. Purse carry perhaps isn't ideal, but these little revolvers handle this environment very well as no lint or debris can get into the action and she could even shoot through the purse if need be. You don't want or need single action/an exposed hammer on a self-defense gun...it's a liability in every way. Snubs are not long range range/target guns capable of marksmanship accuracy, but that doesn't really matter as civilian self-defense scenarios happen at very close ranges so there's no need to be a sharpshooter. They do suffer from low capacity, but stats show the vast majority civilian defense encounters involve very few shots. Most(90+ %) follow the rule of 3's as the averages work out with most armed defense scenarios occuring approximately within 3 yards, are over within 3 seconds and are resolved in 3 rounds or less.

In close quarters, the snub is extremely quick to bring into action, especially if talking purse or pocket carry compared with autos and would offer better weapon retention against disarms(a bad guy,mugger, racist trying to take her gun)than any other firearm and you can press the muzzle against the assailants body and the gun will still function whereas a semi-auto's slide would get pushed out if battery. In civilian self-defense scenarios, making contact with assailant/grappling or otherwise getting into a physical struggle is common, so it's wise to prepare accordingly.

Another consideration is that a revolver cannot be limp-wristed. With woman, limp-wristing is actually a fairly common occurrence, especially with polymer pistols(the lightweight frame is the problem) even at the range using a two handed shooting from a stance. During real defense scenarios, one handed shooting is common as is having a less than ideal grip on the gun. Shooting on the move or from a compromised position is common as well so the chances of induced malfunctions by not providing good support for the pistol to cycle would be much higher.
 
Last edited:
almost every woman out there would go straight to the semi autos mostly because their BF's or husbands would lead them there or they own one... But in all reality they have issues racking the slides and/or loading the mags and they end up going back to the LGS & pick up a revolver. I suggest a S&W m442 or even a taurus poly protector .38spl.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top