Any flavor of 4513, 457, or 4516 (as well as the CS45). I'll even throw in the M&P45c, probably my next purchase. I'm in love with my new 4516, I think it just jumped the line of my favorite. It spurred my existing desire for an M&P45c.
Off topic, but what holster do you other guys use? I'm looking for a good rig.
Incredibly, the CS45 fits perfectly in a DeSantis shoulder holster that was made for a 1 7/8" J frame!Off topic, but what holster do you other guys use? I'm looking for a good rig.
M&P won't put your pants on the ground.
When you say "Shorty 45" are you referring to a particular model, or the group of short barreled .45's?IMO the Shorty 45 is the "best" S&W 45 for concealed carry. Light weight, tight fitting, extremely accurate and easy concealment being its major attributes. The price tag on the Shorty 45 goes anywhere from $750 to north of $1000. Not exactly a bargain. Well worth $750, again, IMO.
That said, the 4516, and 4513 as well as the 457 and CS45 will all serve you well and are excellent pistols.
I own the 4513TSW, 4516-3, 457 and Shorty 45. The 4516-3 while a little heavy, is my absolute favorite S&W compact 45. It shoots groups only a little larger than those from the Shorty 45. Quite a bit less money to come up with for a nice one too. Good luck with your search. Regards 18DAI.
Other's to consider would be 4513 and 4516.