Keith Brown
Vendor
collectordude, the ethical part is an opinion, the legal part varies and is subject to much legal interpretation.
Are you talking about elephant ivory? It's unethical and illegal to purchase
If you're talking to the OP, I think you should read the title of the thread again.
collectordude, the ethical part is an opinion, the legal part varies and is subject to much legal interpretation.
Your post doesn't violate forum rules, but you probably will alienate a number of forum members.... I don't know if this post violates the forum rules, I kindly asked s&wchad to take a look at it and if it violates them to delete it.
Your post doesn't violate forum rules, but you probably will alienate a number of forum members.
Many of us hunt and/or fish and do so ethically. It's a responsible way to manage wildlife numbers, it generates much needed revenue for conservation efforts and puts food on the table.
The game meat harvested from Argentinian goose hunts and African plains game hunts typically goes to feed locals and isn't wasted. The hunts also generate a lot of money that supports the local economy.
If you believe that the extinction of elephants and the loss of biodiversity is a positive outcome, then you might argue that purchasing ivory is not unethical. However, even buying pre-ban ivory still contributes to the black market. If there were no demand for ivory, elephants wouldn’t be poached for their tusks. It’s similar to the issue of illegal drugs—if there were no demand, there wouldn’t be smuggling, violence, or gang-related crimes associated with it.
I don't have an issue if the ivory is passed down from a family member. I think its unethical to engage with the trade in the market.
I could not disagree more. Currently several African countries struggle to deal with the destructive effects of heavy elephant populations and the effect on farming, agriculture and safety.
Easy for us in the US to say “Protect the Elephants” when they’re not in our backyard.
Maybe we should reintroduce coastal brown bears into the California interior? After all they were there only a
hundred and fifty years ago.
Maybe a massive effort to repopulate several million wild Bison across the US plains ? They were there before us.
It’s so easy to piously judge how other countries should manage resources.
I guess we don’t believe other humans have the same rights to improve their quality of life.
We in the US would not tolerate other countries to dictate how we manage our wildlife.
Need to make a distinction between hunting and poaching. It is legal to hunt elephants in Africa. Botswana, Namibia, Tanzania and South Africa all have legal elephant hunting, as do other countries in Africa.In Africa it’s illegal to hunt/poach elephants.
In Africa it’s illegal to hunt/poach elephants. If you’re caught poaching an elephant you get shot. It’s already a criminal activity to poach them. Current population stands at 415,000 which has shrunk by 110k in the last decade.
Illegal poaching which produces criminal enterprises is not a valid solution to “destructive effects of heavy elephant populations”
In the earlier 1800s there were an estimated 26 million elephants